All stories

Idaho parents stopped the transition she now worries her friend will start

Female · Desisted467
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I was born female, identified as genderfluid and presented male from around age 14 for about a year before outgrowing it, and I now identify as a gay woman who occasionally crossdresses but doesn't identify as anything other than a woman. I credit my conservative Idaho environment and my parents with preventing me from medically transitioning. I'm now deeply worried about an 18-year-old female friend in California who identifies as genderfluid and whose mother fully supports transition, fearing they may pursue medical steps they'll regret. I'm critical of how readily medical transition is pushed today and of pressure around genital preferences. I remain grateful I didn't go down that path and find reassurance in connecting with others who feel similarly.

Full story

I was born female. When I was around 14 or so I identified as genderfluid but presented as male, using a different name and pronouns, for about a year, with hopes of medically transitioning one day. I eventually outgrew it, and I'm thankful I didn't have to go through what some others did. During that phase I lived in Idaho, a conservative state with no access to trans medical resources, which I now see as protective — I've said that if I hadn't had parents like mine and an environment like mine, I might have ended up in a very different position and I don't think I would have listened. I'm glad my parents had some sense. I now identify as a woman and I'm gay. Male genitalia actively gross me out due to me being gay, on top of some mild trauma. I've described myself as having been 'neck-deep in the ideology' when I was presenting male. I still crossdress to deal with lingering feelings, but I don't identify as anything other than a woman. I have a friend, also female, who identifies as genderfluid and presents male; we're both 18, their mom is totally on board and there's no dad in the picture due to divorce. They live in California, where I believe access to trans medicine, including top and bottom surgery covered by insurance, is far more lenient than Idaho. I'm terrified of what they might do to themselves in the name of gender identity — deep down I don't think they're really trans, like I wasn't, but I don't want to voice that since we're not particularly close. I've speculated about family dynamics possibly playing a role in such cases, while acknowledging I know nothing about their family. I've worried that maybe the only way she can find herself is through a hard path, though I don't want her to endure that pain. I've thought about bringing up my concerns but don't know how to do it organically. I'm critical of how common transition is being pushed, saying real gender dysphoria sounds horrible and medical transition is arduous, expensive and very risky, and I hate how much that kind of pain is being pushed nowadays. I'm also critical of the pressure to 'unlearn my biases' regarding genital preferences, noting how often lesbians are called transphobes for not liking so-called 'female penises'. When I was presenting male I had a crush on a girl a nonbinary classmate also liked; they suggested polyamory and I agreed then, though I'm not open to it anymore. I've expressed gratitude for finding others who feel as I do, saying it's reassuring and an affirmation that maybe I'm not crazy.