All stories

Two years on hormones, then a body that wouldn't come back

Male · Detransitioned171
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a detransitioned man (mtftm) who is autistic and who transitioned after developing a "trap" fetish and feeling I had "failed" as an effeminate, submissive man. After two years on HRT I detransitioned and now experience erectile dysfunction likely caused by the hormones, which has caused significant distress, regret, and depression, though I also worry my regret is somehow invalid or "toxic." I identify as a socially moderate, anti-Trump conservative who wants better gatekeeping in trans medicine while still supporting liberal attitudes toward gender roles. I reflect on AGP, autogynephilia, and using femininity to avoid masculine demands as key drivers of my transition.

Full story

I am a male-to-female-to-male (mtftm) detransitioner who is autistic. I first wanted to become a girl because I felt I had "failed" as a man — I had always been very effeminate, emotional, and submissive, and I've since learned to accept those features about myself and am much happier after detransitioning. I believe a lot of hormone-approving doctors discount how autistic people can be driven toward transition because of black-and-white thinking when they don't like traditional gender roles. When I started to transition, my mom even suggested I might be happier being genderqueer, because she knew I hated both gender roles. I also recall that I transitioned after gaining a "trap" fetish — I guess I always felt I wasn't manly enough and that this meant I should become a woman. I was always more sensitive and effeminate than other guys, but not in a way that signified I was trans; it was more that I didn't like gender roles in general, though I didn't realize I also disliked female gender roles since I hadn't lived them before. I think liking the male gender role, without actual body dysphoria, is a bad reason to transition. I was on HRT for two years. After detransitioning I developed erectile dysfunction, likely caused by those two years on HRT — I was waiting on blood test results to see if I had low testosterone, and other possible factors included a porn addiction and taking Adderall for my ADHD. I've tried to have sex with three different women and each time I couldn't get an erection. I rarely get erections now except in the morning; the best way I can describe it is that my penis gets "hard, but not sturdy," as in it bends when I try to penetrate a woman. A urologist said they wanted to see my testosterone results before prescribing anything, because they wanted to see if I needed testosterone replacement therapy. This has caused me significant mental distress, filled with regret and depression. I also can't shake the feeling that I'm being toxic — like a douche bag who only cares about his dick. I feel my feelings are invalid because I'm advocating for greater gatekeeping in trans medical practice just because I want to be able to have sex, and I feel my story is less valuable than many ftmtfs who went through more significant bodily changes. Yet I can't shake this masculine rage at being unable to be intimate with someone, which feels counter to my general attitude as a more effeminate man. I used to listen to erotic audios (like on r/gonewildaudios) to feel less lonely, but they've become triggering because they involve penetration, reminding me of my predicament. There's also something emasculating, I feel, about having sex the same way cis lesbians do — I know I of all people shouldn't care about being masculine, but it causes me anguish. I tried to stop porn but found it very hard; addictive behavior runs in my family, and I stopped for a week but was miserable and didn't see erections becoming more frequent. On transition and sexuality more broadly: I relate strongly to AGP (autogynephilia). I was also an incel-lite, never had a girlfriend until I was trans, very "nice guy" and nerdy. I felt I became really "lady-like" artificially when I transitioned, to fit a mold of an ideal woman — I would constantly wish I could get pregnant and become a Catholic baby machine "trad-wife." I got into a kinda toxic relationship with a guy and tried to be super stereotypically female with him. I think it has to do with how nerd/anti-bro types like us use femininity as a way to avoid the typical demands inflicted upon a male (having to be tough, assertive, a leader, etc.). Currently I'm really into role reversal/gentle femdom and have a high desire to be treated like a girl in a relationship — I think it's my AGP talking, and I really don't like being the "pants-wearer" in a relationship. But this contrasts with my usual male sexuality during masturbation, which is aggressive and stereotypically male. I think AGP is a way of rejecting some inherent maleness in my personality that comes from my biology, because I dislike that part of myself. I think this dislike of male sexuality incentivizes people like us to transition — we don't want to face the male "monster" inside, so we look to become more delicate creatures. I also believe some trans people make everything about gender as a way to avoid reality — it's an easy excuse for why your life is bad and helps avoid deeper trauma and insecurities. Politically, I identify as a socially moderate, anti-Trump conservative. I appreciate conservative support of detrans stories but feel they're being used in the wrong way — often with a religious spin that undermines the fact that many detrans people still don't follow traditional gender roles. I think there's an opening for center and center-right people to push for more liberal attitudes toward gender roles and greater gatekeeping in medical practice to combat "transition or nothing" attitudes. I hope for better screening processes for getting HRT. I believe transitioning is a dangerous medical procedure that shouldn't be taken lightly, and that rigidity in gender roles makes people more inclined to transition, especially teens who already seek to rebel against their parents. For anyone in a similar situation, I'd recommend seeing a general therapist or someone who specializes in masculinity rather than a gender therapist (who will probably push you to transition) if you want help. I've offered my DMs to others going through similar things.