All stories

Eight years in trans spaces, no hormones, one damaged rib

Female · Desisted249
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a detransitioned, socially gender-nonconforming woman who was born female, diagnosed with autism and GID, and spent over eight years fully identifying as trans after entering trans spaces as a teenager. Childhood sexual, social, and emotional abuse by boys and men, my brother's bullying of my high voice, internalized misogyny, OCD, and black-and-white thinking all fueled my dysphoria, while trans spaces escalated it into a life-consuming illness. I never took hormones or had surgery myself, though I have rib damage from long-term binder use; I now use a unisex public name, keep my old trans name as a middle name, and remain 'on the fence' about identity while at peace as a female person. Most of my dysphoria is quiet now, though I still get occasional short-lived spikes, and I have limited support from siblings and some trans friends. I actively participate in r/detrans, advising questioning teens and critiquing transmedicalism and mainstream trans ideology.

Full story

I was born female and was diagnosed with autism; I've also been diagnosed with GID (gender identity disorder) a few times. I was in trans spaces since I was a teenager and was 'fully' into being trans for over eight years — roughly a decade of the whole process — and the time it took to finally allow the possibility of detransition into my life was around eight years. Detransition used to be my phobia. Looking back, I think a lot drove me toward transition. I was abused — sexually, socially, and emotionally — by boys and men in my life, and that trauma manifested in dysphoria and dysmorphia. I felt humiliation about having a vagina, about the idea of penetration, and I didn't even want to say the word or refer to my own body that way. My brother bullied me a lot for having a high-pitched, excited voice, and as a young child I thought my high voice was ugly and wanted to get rid of it. Even adult men seemed to make fun of little girls, so at a young age I developed a complex about being 'girly' being gross. I also associate my birthname with childhood abuse; it's quite feminine and I never connected with it. I grew up with black-and-white thinking that the trans community validated, which drove my dysphoria and made my body feel unliveable and unbearable. I had OCD and would pick my mind apart, questioning my 'validity' based on anything female-associated I did. I also saw women as less complete and complex people than men, and I was tired of being treated the way women are treated, so being trans felt like a safety blanket — an escape, even if it was delusional and people still saw me as a woman. I held mild-to-medium transmedicalist beliefs when I was younger, which made me wallow in dysphoria and self-hatred and act as my own expression and thought police — an 'OCD fly trap.' Trans groups I was in unhelpfully encouraged my gender dysphoria to obsessive and dangerous levels; hanging around trans people gave me a lot of dysphoria because those spaces trend negative and toxic about their own bodies and indirectly enforce negative gender roles on females. I saw peers in those spaces as a teen DIYing hormones over the internet — I knew someone profoundly mentally ill who got hormones at 13-14 while actively psychotic, without real parental permission, and I saw a few get top surgery at that age too. I personally have damage to my ribs from long-term binder use as well as some irresponsible misuse, and I would not recommend a child wear a binder. What moved me toward detransition was slow and internal: cognitive dissonance caused by contradictions and sexism in mainstream trans thought, feeling (or knowing) I would never be an actual male, and inter-community discourse I could no longer pretend to agree with. I couldn't justify the 'true trans'/born in the wrong body framework to myself anymore after over eight years of fully being into it. I don't rush or force anything, I don't feed my OCD monster, and I find my mind slowly changes anyway. It felt like my entire world was being uprooted at the start. I compared the relationship to being trans to a bad ex — the closeness felt good but rang hollow and was ultimately toxic and self-destructive; sometimes I feel briefly 'homesick' for it, then realize I can be myself without it and feel genuine relief. I discussed detransition with my partner, who said 'it's like a bad ex.' I never underwent hormones or surgery myself — I didn't do the DIY or surgery route I saw peers do. My rib damage from binding is the main physical consequence I've described. I don't try to be a woman or 'feel' like any gender; I've accepted that woman/female is just my regular, neutral state. I'm very masculine and nothing has changed in my presentation or personality except that my enduring cognitive dissonance has cleared up because I accepted the lack of logic. I have big boobs but wouldn't mind a flat chest — none of that makes me a man. I have a masculine name and appearance; I use a second, more unisex name for public-facing stuff and new people because my chosen trans name is socially strictly masculine and I don't like the stares I get for using it. I use my old trans name as my middle name now, and some people, including my partner, still call me it. I've never connected to my birthname so I felt no urge to return to it. In real life I get called he and she and I have no problem with that. I'm not a lesbian so I'm not sure it's appropriate to call myself butch, but I relate to the concept and go through life perceived similarly to one. Mentally, I had OCD and obsessive thoughts about my appearance; I advised someone else to look up feedback loops in OCD and to seek help for obsessive thoughts, saying neither transition nor detransition would change their problems. I think detransition without a mental resolve and conclusion is very painful and I could not have made myself detransition years ago without a significant mental breakdown. My more violent dysphoria lessened over time, especially as I escaped from trans spaces, though I still get occasional short-lived spikes even if I don't identify as a man anymore. The vast majority of my dysphoria is quiet now; if I get it, it's usually because someone has told me I can't do or feel something as a woman. I've made peace with it and my thoughts have less strife — comfort slowly snuck up on me, and I never thought I'd feel any comfort with this path. Socially, I have limited support: I don't have a stable connection with my siblings, and when I raised detransition once, in very gentle terms, a friend suggested I was being brainwashed by TERFs, and I felt that single conversation hurt the friendship irreparably. I feel like an existential threat to my trans friends because if we all relate and they've seen my dysphoria and goals over the years, how could I give up and comfortably realize I could be a woman? I have a partner who supports me. I participate actively in r/detrans, offering advice to teenagers questioning transition, defending the space as a support subreddit, and directing trans people to /r/ask_detransition. I've pushed back against transmedicalism, against 4chan trans subreddits, and against misrepresenting breast ironing as transgender binding. I'm 'on the fence' on my identity but I've accepted that a woman/female is my regular, neutral state; I allow myself to be a socially GNC woman because I was born female, not because of any expectation of what a woman is beyond her sex. I don't follow the gender roles expected of my sex. I don't think there's much difference between me and the average (masculine) transmasculine person outside of personal belief on gender. I don't feel qualified or motivated to comment on medical transition for everyone. I genuinely don't have an issue with 'it makes me more comfortable' reasoning at its face — I just see it as degrees of gender nonconformity; it's the community sexism and faulty logic that bothers me. I don't believe you have to believe in being born in the wrong body to be questioning or sympathetic to trans people.