All stories

Warned about atrophy, then signed anyway

Female · Detransitioned91
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a detransitioned woman who went through the NHS and gave informed consent for hormone therapy after being fully warned about vaginal atrophy, uterine atrophy, and fertility effects. I've become critical of both trans subreddits that silence dissent and of inflated statistics used in detrans discussions. I now view the desire to transition partly through a universal 'grass is greener' lens and openly discuss the burdens of being female, saying I am 'permanently opting out' of female biology while rejecting the charge that this is misogynistic. I've argued against conspiracy theories about trans medicine, citing historical and statistical evidence. I have not described my current identity status, any surgeries, or a specific detransition date in this material.

Full story

I went through the NHS in the UK to start hormone therapy, and I was required to sit down and verbally go through a list of effects and risks with a clinician before beginning. Vaginal atrophy was at the top of the list of effects of HT I was given, and we also talked about fertility treatments and eventual uterine atrophy. I can't say I wasn't completely cognizant, or not made aware of these effects, going in — I gave informed consent with full knowledge of what I was signing up for. I've been active in detransition and trans-related discussion spaces online. I noted that the detrans subreddit did a survey that got responses from less than 300 active detrans people, and that both detrans and trans subs have wildly over-inflated numbers, presumably a lot of lurkers or observers, so those numbers shouldn't be given much weight. I also got moderated on a trans subreddit — a mod told me 'don't recommend a bullshit sub' — and my reaction was that, like most trans subs, no dissent is allowed. That experience of having my comment removed for pointing people toward detransition resources stuck with me. On the question of why people transition at all, I've come to a broader view: I think there's an innate view in every human that 'what I don't have, is better than what I do have'. People who have curly hair wish to have straight hair, people with straight hair wish to have curly hair. People who have light skin wish to have dark skin, people who have dark skin wish to have light skin. People who are male wish they could be female, people who are female wish they could be male. We all think the grass is greener on the other side. We all overemphasize the perceived comforts of the other side. We all want to fit a median, and anything that puts us outside that median causes us discomfort. I've also thought a lot about the specific burden of being female. I think nature has inherently given women a shit hand — on top of being physically smaller and weaker (on average) than males, having one to two weeks a month where your hormones go crazy, leading to emotional and physical fluctuations that are debilitating, and the risk, burden and reward of pregnancy, then after 50 having another huge bodily change. It's a whole shit show being female, and it doesn't surprise me people want to opt out of it. I said plainly that I don't want to deal with any of the nature of being female, not even going into gender stuff — I'm permanently opting out of that. I pushed back on the suggestion that this makes me misogynistic for doing so. I've engaged with arguments about whether trans medicine is a pharmaceutical conspiracy. I pointed out that in the UK there are two very big court cases from the mid 20th century — Corbett v Corbett and Ewan Forbes' inheritance — which were widespread mainstream news, as was reporting on Christine Jorgensen. Society has been dealing with gender variance since the beginning of recorded history, and dealing with medically transitioned transsexuals for at least 80 years. What has happened in the last 20 years is the legal recognition of transsexuals in the UK and USA, though the first country to legally recognise transsexuals (after Weimar Germany) was West Germany in 1980. I also argued the medical treatment trans people use is not unique to trans people: in the UK 1.93 million prescriptions for estrogen hormone therapy are given a year, and according to recent census data there are 48,000 trans women in the UK — even if all of them were on estrogen HT, that would be 2.5% of all prescriptions given a year, a drop in the ocean for pharmaceutical manufacturers. I asked the person I was arguing with how they thought these technologies were being abused. I've also pushed back on the idea that the USA is the centre of everything — when someone suggested a conspiracy, I told them to 'get to fuck' and reminded them that the USA is not the whole world. I'm still working through where I stand. I don't regret going in with informed consent — I was fully aware of the risks — but I've become much more skeptical of the spaces that surround transition online, both the trans subs that allow no dissent and the inflated numbers people throw around in detrans discussions.