All stories

A professor's scream and a friendship she couldn't save

Female · Desisted148
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a detransitioned or desisted woman who came to doubt queer theory and gender identity after witnessing a professor scream at a student for defending radical feminism. I've expressed critical views of current trans activism, including what I see as renewed homophobia and pressure on others to pretend they can't 'clock' trans people. I grieve a childhood friend who transitioned and with whom I could no longer sustain a friendship, feeling unable to voice concerns about his toxic relationships and family situation. The transcript does not describe my own transition or detransition medical details, mental health diagnoses, or current identity beyond these critical and grieving stances.

Full story

I was born female. I took a class on gender during an academic exchange in Brazil more than five years ago; the professor was an older, openly homosexual male who was into queer theory, and I admired him and enjoyed his class. One day he started ranting about radical feminism, and when a student said radical feminism wasn't that bad, he screamed at her until she cried and ran out of the classroom. I felt terrible for her, and he didn't think twice about using his authority to shut down further discussion. I think that was the beginning of my doubts about queer theory and gender identity, though I usually keep those ideas to myself; it shattered the 'all-inclusive, good spirited, kind and accepting' image I used to have about it. I'm not a native English speaker. I later recalled a Chilean detrans group that tried to talk about their experiences online and only received hate and death threats, which I found awful and unsurprising. I commented that 'they really went full circle and became homophobic again.' I also commented that, in my view, 'it's not about not being clocked, it's about forcing others to pretend they aren't clocking them.' I had a good friend I grew up with whom I loved dearly; today is her birthday and I still have the reminder on my cellphone's calendar. He transitioned years ago and we couldn't sustain our friendship. I miss my friend but I can't see him fall in the same toxic cycle over and over again and be unable to say anything because they're really sensitive. He has toxic relationships, bad friends and a terrible family, and sadly transitioning doesn't solve everything. Writing about it made me sad.