These stories have been summarised using AI.
On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.
Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.
Full story
I am a gay man, older than the young people now caught up in rapid transition, and I first thought about being a girl as far back as I can remember; that continued into my 20s. I never transitioned. I was a feminine boy for whom masculine interests and activities held no interest, and my gender dysphoria was the source of a lot of rejection and trauma in my childhood, though I was never assaulted. I don't think trauma causes dysphoria, but being a gender non-conforming boy in our society is itself a traumatizing experience.
I was very fortunate to find a therapist who was neither anti-trans nor mindlessly affirming — he wasn't a transition facilitator but wasn't intimidated by trans ideologues either. He helped me define my own goals rather than pushing me onto preconceived rubrics. Through that work I arrived at two realizations. First, that transition would only ever offer me the chance to be a medicalized simulacrum of a woman: I could never be a biological female, only a medicalized simulacrum of one. I never wanted a woman's body; I just thought my life would have been easier if I had been born female, and it probably would have been, but I wasn't. Second, that my inability to conform to male gender expectations did not have to be an impediment to my self-actualization — being a gender non-conforming man did not make me any less of a man. My choice was between being a GNC man and being a transwoman; I couldn't be a 'straight' man and I couldn't be a cis woman. I didn't want my understanding of success to be based on how hard I tried to be a woman, and I didn't have to try at all to be a GNC man.
I sorted out my trauma with that therapist and came to see myself as having a good life as a GNC man. The gender dysphoria never went away — it doesn't go away, but you find ways of adapting that make it manageable, and it takes a really long time. It stopped being something that kept me from getting on with my life. I eventually came to accept that dysphoria is part of who I am and that doesn't have to be a bad thing; I don't worry about being into feminine things. I have grown into myself as an out gay man who is no less of a man because of this, though I wish the journey had been easier.
I was lucky to have dealt with all this before social media and before the 'everybody must be trans' craze. I'm a teacher, and when I started hearing young people say they didn't really want to transition but thought it was their best option, I started having serious second thoughts about what I'd previously supported. Like Jamie Reed, I've done a 180 in my views on any kind of medical transition for youth. I don't think anyone under 18 is equipped to make that choice, and puberty blockers held for five years or so between the onset of puberty and informed consent can't be considered a short-term course.
I remain against banning anything an adult wants to do that doesn't abuse the rights of other people; I think transition is genuinely the right choice for some people, and trans people who are happy with their choices deserve respect and support. But I believe the process needs to be safeguarded so people know exactly what they are choosing, and those safeguards should be determined by healthcare professionals and state medical boards, not courts or legislatures. I'm critical of the current transgender discourse: it's highly polarized, recklessly pushes people to rush into medical transition, promises unconditional support but turns vicious on anyone who expresses regret, and bullies healthcare professionals into rubber-stamping quick transitions. I also worry that the pushback against it is often a wedge for rolling back LGBT and GNC rights generally, and I've criticized gender critical sources for turning a blind eye to the agendas of their material supporters.
I want gender non-conforming kids affirmed and celebrated as they are — I believe that if young people felt they were fine as themselves we'd see a much lower rate of transition, and those who do choose it would be sure it was what they really want. I think non-binary identity reinforces the idea that you can't be a man or woman if you don't meet cultural expectations, and I worry that feminine boys and masculine girls are losing their place in the world. I've spent time on Reddit encouraging young people who are questioning, telling them they don't have to transition, that dysphoria decreases with maturity, and that they should find a therapist they trust.