All stories

Tumblr dysphoria from 2012, no medical transition

Female · Desisted1.3K
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a desister — I never medically transitioned, but I experienced Tumblr-induced gender dysphoria from 2012-2014, disidentifying as a woman and using they/them for years before crawling out of it. I now identify as female-bodied rather than as a woman, and I question the notion that everyone must have a gender identity. I have not experienced the medical or mental health system as a trans person, but I engage actively with the detrans community as an ally, advocating for gender-agnostic medical care, criticizing medicalization of gender dysphoria, and supporting sex-based protections. I was influenced by detransition YouTubers like Carey Callahan and Leoica Motanelul. I remain critical of what I see as an extremist trans activist agenda while still allying with trans people who acknowledge the material reality of sex.

Full story

I have never medically transitioned, so I describe myself as a desister rather than a detransitioner — though I've said I'm 'not a member of detrans community and I'm not quite an outsider either.' I fell down the Tumblr hole back in 2012-2014, when I disidentified as a woman and, as far as I recall, even disidentified as a female. I wouldn't say I specifically identified as a man or as male. I never sought a therapist for eventual medical transition, and therefore I never medically transitioned. I've called what I experienced 'tumblr induced gender dysphoria' — for instance, I would wear pants and a button-down shirt, look in the mirror, and lament the existence of my unmistakably female hips. I was definitely a 'they' for a good number of years. I somehow crawled out of this postmodernism hole. I still don't identify as a woman; I guess I identify as female-bodied, and I now question 'Compulsory Gender Identity,' the notion that one must have a gender identity. My handle, 'The Future Is Detrans,' is a take on shirt slogans from the 2010s like 'The Future Is Female' and 'The Future Is Nonbinary,' and I also really believe many people will be detrans in the future. I have not experienced going through the medical or mental health system as a trans person, but I have experienced going through these systems as someone who does not identify as a woman, as someone who is gender nonconforming, and as someone who is of female sex. I've said I'm a desister who cares a lot about detransitioners and experienced Tumblr-induced gender dysphoria. I've mentioned being influenced by YouTubers Leoica Motanelul and especially Carey Callahan, whom I described as exceptionally articulate on effective therapy with dysphoric people, and I've recommended her videos to others. I've also recommended Dustin's podcast interview and Shapeshifter's videos on MtF transition regret. I'm 37 as of June 2020, have been fat most of my life, and my body has given birth. At 15 I had acne and was prescribed Diane-35, an anti-androgen; my breasts grew, I would cry for no reason, and my libido decreased to zero, and after a few months I decided I'd take acne any day over that. I have large breasts and wear sports bras comfortably. I'm not dysphoric about how people who wear sports bras identify. I've written that I actively ally with trans people who acknowledge the material reality of sex and who support sex-based protections in prisons, athletics, and sex-segregated spaces. I've been banned from both r/GenderCritical and r/actual_detrans for saying 'transwomen are women who are male.' I've argued that the detrans community's platform should be to advocate for thorough, consistent, rigorous, gender-agnostic medical care for sexual and gender minorities, with the goal of optimal mental health. I've criticized Dr. Will Powers for prescribing anti-androgens to dysphoric females going through puberty, saying he is effectively chemically castrating them, and I spoke from my own experience with Diane-35 at 15. I've said I wish medicine didn't pathologize masculine females, and I wish masculine females didn't feel there is anything wrong with them just the way they are. I've compared Dr. Powers to a 1950s doctor giving lesbians anti-androgens to 'change' their sexuality. I've argued that puberty blockers may be physiologically temporary but functionally permanent because so few kids go off them, and that robust longitudinal research is missing. I've said gender identity is established by age 3 for most people, including trans people excluding ROGD folks, which makes blockers seem like 'closing the barn door after the horse has escaped.' I've argued that neither transition nor detransition is a treatment for dysphoria, and recommended therapy for body dysmorphia and overcoming fixation on one's sexed body. I've said 'woman is not a feeling, but simply an adult human female.' I've recommended less screen time, physical athletic activity, spending time with pets, and embodied experiences to reduce fixation on appearance. I've advised against further surgical or medical interventions for physically healthy organs, and said that if someone is suicidal they need therapy, not elective surgery. I've suggested that suicidality may be independent of de/trans status. I've discussed AGP and HSTS typologies and their relevance to bottom surgery satisfaction. I've expressed concern about Jazz Jennings being put on blockers at 10 or 11 and struggling with depression since. I've been skeptical of a study concluding retransition is infrequent based on kids aged 8-13, wanting a 15-year follow-up. I've shared a Gender Dysphoria Alliance Canada statement raising concern that a study won't be conducted in good faith, and I've recommended the Gender Dysphoria Alliance podcasts to others, describing them as trans guys trying to make sense of these issues. I've posted a video titled 'Dismantling the Gender Identity medicalization industrial complex.' I've advocated for a backup online gathering place for the detrans community since we can't rely on Reddit to protect our rights, and I've asked others to write to YouTube to stop censoring channels critical of medical transition. I've suggested desisters should be included in 'detrans only' flairs, proposing a 'detrans and desister replies only' flair. I generally don't answer questions flagged 'detrans only' because I haven't gone through the medical system as a trans or detrans person, though I've made exceptions. I've expressed critical views of 'Big Trans' and what I see as an extremist agenda, and I've said being agender is technically gender critical. I've been skeptical of a poster I thought was a throwaway account fantasizing about what detransitioners think. I speak some Hebrew, based on comments I've written in Hebrew. I've described myself as 'a dull normal.' I don't currently identify as a woman; I identify as female-bodied and as a desister.