All stories

Mastectomy at 21 — and the grief of never breastfeeding

Female · DetransitionedFirst dysphoria 12 → Transition 20 → Detransition 241K
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a detransitioned woman who was on testosterone for about 4 years and had a double mastectomy at 21, detransitioning around age 24 when I stopped T to regain fertility. I now identify simply as a woman — not trans or nonbinary — and I'm a happily married Catholic stay-at-home mom with two children. I regret my transition and especially my mastectomy, which I now see as unnecessary and akin to self-harm; the grief over being permanently unable to breastfeed my children has been particularly painful. My mental health, which was as bad before as during transition, has improved, and while I still have occasional dysphoria and grief, I know detransitioning was 100% the right choice for me. I believe transition should be much more thoroughly explored before permanent changes, but I don't oppose adults choosing to transition.

Full story

I was born female. I decided I was trans at 12 after stumbling upon an FtM page online, which seemed like an explanation for why I hated myself and my body so much. I transitioned at 20, was on testosterone for about 4 years, and had a double mastectomy at 21. I detransitioned about 3-4 years ago (stopping T to try to regain fertility when my husband and I considered having children), and I now consider myself a woman — not trans or nonbinary. My transition was driven by a mix of factors: mental distress around my body and being perceived as female, a poor sense of identity that transness filled in, and growing up as an 'ugly tomboy' in an ultraconservative religious family surrounded by hyperfeminine women, which gave me a sense of inadequacy as a woman that I interpreted as gender dysphoria. My family belonged to a controlling religious group with standards nobody could meet; I was instilled with the belief that women were less than men and had to defer to men. My dad was uncomfortable with girls/women and openly homophobic; my mom was hyperfeminine, obsessed with dieting, and pushed me toward makeup, shapewear and dieting. At school, boys I'd hung out with distanced themselves after puberty and I felt out of place with other girls. I also associated being female with pain and fear. I had OCD and what I believe was secondary dysphoria stemming from underlying psychological issues rather than anything innate. I had doubts before transitioning and tried reading detrans narratives, but it wasn't fruitful and I proceeded anyway. During COVID quarantine I felt less dysphoria, which made me question whether it was social rather than biological. After 4 years of HRT and mastectomy I still had trouble passing and was exhausted by hyper-vigilance about how I spoke and moved. My mental health was as bad as before — anxious, depressed, with nil self-esteem. Learning about female reproduction, fertility, pregnancy and childbirth reduced my fear and disgust about being female. Fertility testing raised ambiguities about how T had affected me. I realized how little long-term research exists on HRT's effects on female bodies. I detransitioned and it was the right decision. I stopped T cold turkey; I was very tired and emotional for a few months, and my periods returned in about 4 months. Residual effects: my voice remains deep (I use a 'customer service voice'), some facial hair (weekly shaving/plucking), and clitoral enlargement (neither I nor my husband mind). Everything else reverted. My breasts will not grow back. I never changed my gender marker back on my ID, and I chose a feminine variant of my chosen masculine name rather than a legal change. I became pregnant about 6 months after stopping T. My first pregnancy was healthy and uncomplicated with no fetal anomalies; my son is now almost 3 with no physical or developmental issues. I just gave birth to my second child (also healthy). Both times postpartum I developed painful hard lumps in my chest where residual tissue tried to produce milk with nowhere to go. I feel deep guilt and grief over being unable to breastfeed — worse with the second child — and feel like a 'substandard mother' since my mastectomy 'didn't solve anything at all.' I also grieve that I wasn't able to even try breastfeeding. I regret my transition and especially my mastectomy. I used to say I didn't regret it, but over time living as a woman I came to see it as unnecessary — akin to self-harm in hindsight. I lost my breasts, my name, relationships, time and money, and wasn't happier or healthier at the end; I had basically the same mental health problems as at the start. Suggestions that I 'can just get implants' frustrate me because the issue isn't the look of my chest but that I rejected my body so radically I had parts surgically removed for no medical reason. I still have mixed feelings — sometimes wish I was a man, sometimes desire to appear male, still hesitate using feminine pronouns — but it's manageable and I've accepted it's what's best for me and my family. I still struggle with feelings of inadequacy and grief 4 years post-detransition, but it's gotten better. I was a 'pro-trans detransitioner' and 'token detrans' early on, downplaying my negative feelings and being accused of lying, which caused additional hurt that festered into self-hatred. I've since stepped away from that. I was very political and radical before; detransition challenged notions like an immutable internal gender. I now believe sex is binary and meaningful, that dysphoria is often secondary to other issues, and that transition should be thoroughly and holistically explored before permanent decisions — though I don't want to blanket ban transition or stop consenting adults. I feel used as a political pawn by both sides. I'm Catholic and take my faith seriously, married to a man (initially hostile to the faith, now considering conversion), a stay-at-home mom living in the suburbs. Almost nobody in my personal life from the past 4 years knows I'm detrans. I'm happy — far happier than living as trans — and know detransitioning was 100% the right choice.