All stories

The only woman in her circle who never transitioned

Female · Desisted849
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a detransitioned... no — I am a never-transitioned gender critical woman in my late 20s who participates in the detrans community as an ally. I was born female, identify as a woman, and have a boyfriend; I have never taken hormones or had any transition-related medical treatment. I came to these spaces because my partner seriously considered MTF transition and many of my close friends, including four female friends, now identify as trans or nonbinary, leaving me isolated from woman-to-woman friendship. I believe biological sex is real and that therapy, not hormones and surgery, should be the response to gender distress, while also pushing back against hatred toward trans people in gender critical spaces and advocating that detransitioners' stories be heard. I have no recorded mental health conditions, trauma, or suicidal ideation of my own.

Full story

I have never transitioned — I describe myself as a gender critical woman who is here as an ally to detransitioners, and I say plainly 'never trans, here' and 'I have never transitioned so I'm speaking from the detrans ally perspective.' I was born female and identify as a woman; I refer to myself as a 'cis' woman and note I am a woman attracted to men with a boyfriend. I am in my late 20s as of August 2019, and in October 2019 I mention being 18 nine years ago, which fits being around 27 then. I am white and from a big city in the Northwest that gets mentioned on the detrans subreddit a lot. I come from anarcho/punk/anti-racist/queer subcultural backgrounds and know fewer 'cis' people than trans or nonbinary people; I have an account on Spinster under the handle 'Cailleach' and other social media. I work taking care of children, which is noisy and doesn't pay enough to do anything fancy. I have been hairy-legged since about 2006/2007 and was surprised to get zero grief wearing shorts in Atlanta in 2010. I do not take any pharmaceutical medication and prefer herbal approaches like nettle tea and anti-inflammatory eating, and I have a positive relationship with my menstrual cycle. I have a partner who seriously considered MTF transition but ultimately decided against it — he was most curious about being able to carry a child, which he could never do, and I was relieved he chose not to transition. I have many trans friends, most of whom I've known 10+ years, and I have seen them suffer health problems and other suffering that I believe therapy could have alleviated better than drugs and surgery. I had four close female friends from four very different parts of my life and not one of them identifies as a woman anymore, which has left me wishing for close friendships with women I can no longer have with those people. I also had a friend who changed entirely through gender ideology; we drifted apart and are now more like acquaintances with a shared past, which was painful. I spend time on both detrans and Gender Critical communities because before finding them there were no dialogues that aligned with what I had experienced and witnessed with friends and loved ones, though I also say there is a lot of fear, narrow-mindedness, and hatred in GC spaces and that I sometimes think I should find a place with less fear and more nuance. I believe biological sex is real and dimorphic, that you cannot change sex through hormones and surgery, and that therapy to help people feel comfortable in their bodies should be the medical approach instead. I am critical of current trans rhetoric and what I see as unintentional medical abuse and mass delusion, and I think the current cultural moment is postmodern decadence. At the same time I try not to presume why anyone has decided to transition, I get angry when GC people assume all trans women are narcissistic or abusive, and I say the detrans subreddit should be a place for actual detrans people to connect first and foremost rather than a soapbox for gender critical people like me. I have advocated for detrans people's stories to be heard, encouraged others to share their stories on YouTube, and pushed back against downvoting of people describing their pain. I have also given practical advice on skincare after testosterone, birth control options to stop menstruation as harm reduction instead of taking testosterone, and I have discussed the risks of HRT and surgery leading to lifelong medical dependence. I have discussed suicide in the community with compassion, including a detransitioned person who died by suicide after regrets about surgery. I have no recorded history of transition, detransition, hormones, surgeries, mental health diagnoses, trauma, or suicidal ideation of my own in this transcript.