These stories have been summarised using AI.
On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.
Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.
Full story
I was about 14 when I first started identifying as trans (ftm), and I only "realised" I was trans around a year before I posted here at 15 in November 2022. Looking back, I called myself stupid for not seeing it sooner, and I compared myself to people who follow fashion fads and TikTok trends — I had always felt better than people who did that, but clearly I was no different. Transitioning, I realised, would not solve my mental health issues or magically make my life better.
Everything I had thought was a "sign" was just a normal thing. I was a tomboy my entire childhood, and a lot of girls are. I like short hair, a lot of girls do. I like looking masculine — a lot of girls do. I do feel some form of gender dysphoria, there is no doubt about that for me, but I was realising there are probably other ways of coping with it rather than wasting time and money acting like something I'm not.
I passed pretty well as a boy, and while it made me feel better than being perceived as a girl, I ended up feeling like a fraud. My boyfriend would call me a "pretty boy" and all I could think was that he was lying to my face. I felt embarrassed admitting any of this because I had been so insistent that this was who I was. My friends had been pretty supportive, but my family completely disrespected my gender identity, which I knew would be annoying to deal with if I detransitioned because I just knew how smug they'd be about it. I felt I perhaps deserved to feel humiliated, that it was essentially my own fault — I was the one spending hours online every day trying to convince myself I was trans, that this was normal.
I concluded I did not think I would ever want to medically transition. I'd be too old for puberty blockers by the time I could access them, and I didn't think the costs outweighed the benefits of starting testosterone. The idea of balding and getting even more spots was not appealing, and I knew it would lead to me getting bullied even more than I already was. The only thing I was sure I wanted was a flat chest, but maybe that would change as I grew older. I liked being called by the name I chose and I liked wearing my binder and having a flat chest, but apart from that I thought I should consider detransitioning. It would probably be fairly easy — I was only out to my friends, social media, and my close family, and hadn't done anything except wear a binder and have my friends call me a different name.
I asked whether there was any point in transitioning, whether I should just accept that ultimately I'm female even if I don't necessarily like it, and said I thought I could learn to be OK with being a tomboy since that's what I was for my entire childhood. In the replies I said I would probably wait a few more years and see how I felt about transitioning then, and I asked someone what made them realise they weren't trans. I said I was going to detransition "for now" because I felt like a constant fraud and thought I would be happier, plus it would give me more time to see if I actually wanted to go through with it in the future — but I was going to keep my name because it's cool and I like it. I also asked whether it would be cool if I continued binding, saying it genuinely made me feel more comfortable and that I didn't think it was a trans thing anymore.
In December 2022 I noted that a Mr Rogers song made me feel dysphoria "for the first time in ages," implying a gap since I had last felt it strongly. By January 2023 I said I had "slowly left all the trans subs" because they refuse to allow any opinion that isn't 100% supportive. I frequent different subs to get different perspectives on LGBT issues and don't agree with a lot of what's said in some of them, but I sympathise with detrans people's struggles. In an argument I told someone their points had "incel vibes" and were a clear sign they spend too much time on the internet, and I corrected their claims about breast cancer versus testicular cancer rates.
In late January 2023 I posted asking how to be supportive of a trans friend. I had stopped identifying as trans while I figured stuff out, and I couldn't help but view being trans differently — I could see how it really is a phase for a lot of teenagers now, and I felt it might be that way for my friend. We weren't the type of people to share feelings, so I didn't know if they felt dysphoria. Part of why I wasn't a fan of their transition was that I thought they were beautiful as a boy, and I felt they might be mistaking wanting to dress feminine for being trans — I said I did the same with dressing masculine. I thought we were very similar and often acted alike, so there was a chance they were making the same mistakes I did. I acknowledged I was probably projecting and wanted to stop thinking like that, and that it was their decision at the end of the day. I said I couldn't take transgender subreddits seriously anymore. A few days before that comment I had told my friend about my experience; they weren't dismissive but their mind was made up, and they said they weren't sure about medical transition. I decided to try my best to be supportive.
In February 2023 I summed up my realisation simply: "Realised I liked being a girl more than I liked the idea of being a guy." In March 2023 I said something still annoyed me a bit but wasn't a big deal, and that I say he/him usually "just because I can."
In September 2023 I said my parents were relieved and very nice about my detransition, and that we hadn't talked about it at all. I was very insistent about being trans so I was glad they didn't turn my detransition into a "gotcha" moment, but I thought they really just want me to be happy. On the topic of teachers and trans issues in schools, I said in sex ed they were mentioned but I really don't think teachers are going around suggesting kids are trans. When asked what would have helped me when I identified as trans, I said honestly nothing — as a teen there was literally nothing anyone could've said that would've changed my mind, though maybe warn them on the dangers of taking hormones or binding and make sure they know the risks.
In October 2023 I advised someone not to force themselves to be a woman if they genuinely feel they aren't, telling them they deserve to be happy and to reach out for help. I also told someone considering detransition that people will generally accept them pretty quickly — maybe make a little announcement or just start referring to yourself as your old name/pronouns and wait for people to follow, treat it casually. In November 2023 I said I'm very wary of PragerU and hesitant to support it, calling detransitioning because of religion "sad" and citing a person interviewed who still suffers intense gender dysphoria but stays a woman for family and religion, saying that won't solve her dysphoria. I also told a troll they were clearly only there to spread hate.
As for my own body, the only physical intervention I ever used was a binder, which I said made me feel more comfortable and which I considered continuing even after deciding to detransition. I never started hormones or puberty blockers. I noted I'd be too old for blockers by the time I could access them. I don't discuss any medical complications, fertility concerns, or irreversible changes beyond noting that I already felt I was bullied and that I feared balding and acne from testosterone.
On mental health, I said transitioning wouldn't solve my mental health issues, but I don't name specific diagnoses. I described feeling like a "constant fraud," embarrassment, and anticipated humiliation from my family. I don't describe any suicidal ideation, self-harm, or attempts.
On adversity, I mentioned being bullied and my family disrespecting my gender identity, but I don't describe abuse or trauma in detail.
Socially, my friends were supportive of my trans identity and most of my friends are guys. My family disrespected my gender identity while I identified as trans but were relieved and kind when I detransitioned. I had a boyfriend at the time of my original post who called me a "pretty boy."
On sexuality, I don't explicitly discuss my orientation, though I mention having a boyfriend and later say all my friends are guys.
On regret, I regretted the time and energy I spent convincing myself I was trans, the hours online, and the identity I'd been so insistent about. I felt like a fraud when passing. I don't describe intense regret over medical procedures because I never had any beyond binding. I don't describe how regret has changed over time.
Currently I have stopped identifying as trans and am figuring things out. I say he/him "usually, just because I can," and I kept the name I chose. I don't state a definitive current identity beyond having stopped identifying as trans.
On attitudes toward transition for others: I believe nothing could have changed my mind as a teen, but I think teens should be warned about the risks of hormones and binding. I support a friend's decision to transition even though I privately doubt it, and I told someone not to force themselves to be a woman if they aren't. I'm critical of religiously motivated detransition and wary of PragerU. I sympathise with detrans people's struggles and have left trans subs for being an echo chamber, but I don't describe formal advocacy or activism.