All stories

Testosterone, then butch again — without the misogyny

Female · Detransitioned379
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I was born female, socially transitioned and took testosterone, and have since detransitioned to identify as a masculine (butch) woman at peace with myself. I now believe my dysphoria was driven by internalised misogyny and hatred of beauty standards and the male gaze, rather than by being a man. The things that helped most were spending time around other butch and masculine women in real life, learning about Taoism and spirituality, and realising the connection women share in conversation. I experienced severe depression and anxiety with violent thoughts, managed with medication, and I don't report current suicidal ideation. I'm now critical of how transition is offered to young gender non-conforming girls and actively warn others about the risks of FTM bottom surgery.

Full story

I was born female and grew up in Australia. Looking back, I think my journey toward transition was driven largely by internalised misogyny — I hated the beauty standards being put on girls my age, hated the sudden sexual attention from men, and fell into the 'I'm not like other girls' trap. I didn't like wearing makeup, shaving, or feminine clothes, and I genuinely believed that because I didn't enjoy those things, I must not really be a woman. With so much spotlight on trans issues at the time, the conclusion felt obvious: 'if I'm not like other girls, I must be a man then.' I now think that's society's failing, not the failing of girls like me — most women are completely unaware of the oppression and constraints they face, so a gender non-conforming girl sees everyone else complying without complaint and concludes she must be different, that she must be other. 'It sucks being a woman. It's great being a man. So become one!' — that misguided intent led me a very long way down a sad path. I socially transitioned and lived as a man for a period. I was on testosterone for some time — I don't state the exact duration in what I've written, but I know it matters for thinking about potential organ issues, and I've noted that these kinds of medical details should be available at the gender clinic rather than requiring people to research them online themselves. I also had depression and anxiety severe enough that I experienced violent thoughts, which I managed with medication alongside conscious ongoing management. The turning point for me was quieter than a crisis. Spending time in real life at my old job around other butch lesbians and masculine older women did wonders for alleviating my dysphoria — my old job supervisor helped me enormously 'by just existing.' A unique peace of mind comes with finding out there are other women out there like you. The most important realisation of my detransition was that I couldn't relate to talking with men; instead I yearned for that special connection women have when conversing together, the way we feel safe and open with each other even when just met. 'It's impossible to explain but it's there.' Spirituality and learning about Taoism in particular helped me temper the distress of external identity — once I realised my authentic self is inside and the outside doesn't matter, life became much easier. I didn't figure out and become comfortable with my gender and sexuality until I was 23. On the practical side, I became a lot more comfortable with myself once I realised that almost everything women do that makes them 'feminine' is just annoying procedures to please the male gaze — dresses, skirts, high heels, makeup, shaving, 'it never ends.' I advise other people against forcing themselves into feminine clothing 'to see if you will eventually get comfortable with it': I tried it, and you never will. I haven't worn a dress or skirt since I was forced to wear formal dress at school at age 14. Coming to peace with being a masculine woman was hard — my mother would comment 'I wish you'd try to look nicer' when I was perfectly comfortable going to the shops in boxers and a hoodie, and strangers would glance at my unshaven legs in disgust. But that's all driven by the pressure on women to be appealing at all times, and masculine women have always existed. I'm also cautious about FTM bottom surgery in particular: I tell people to research it because it is never as simple and easy as people make it out to be, and that it's much easier to just use a strap than risk losing sensation for the rest of your life. On sexuality and social life, I've reflected that teen years are when personality, humour and social circles centre around a particular thing — cosplay, video games, or, as I've seen, being 'different' by being trans. I advise younger people to come out to their friends sooner rather than later because honesty hurts but is almost always best, and to be prepared to lose friends if the friendship was built only on that shared 'thing.' I also note that people have these self-realising journeys all the time — it's far more common than people talk about. Current status: I identify as a detransitioned, masculine (butch) woman who is at peace with herself. I don't describe any current suicidal ideation or self-harm. I'm critical of how transition is presented to young gender non-conforming girls, and I actively offer advice to others in the detrans community, including warning about surgical risks and pointing toward the relief that comes from finding masculine women in real life.