All stories

Gender-critical, never transitioned, mostly lurking to argue

Female · Desisted324
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a detransitioned or never-transitioned gender-critical woman — I've stated plainly 'I'm GC, not trans' and that I mostly lurk in these spaces to support people speaking against groupthink. I have not described any transition, hormones, or surgeries of my own in what I've written; my contributions are supportive comments about language, skepticism toward experimental transition medicine, and encouragement toward people finding comfort in their own bodies. I argue for clear language, oppose untracked experimental medical practices, and believe very few trans people truly 'pass.' I have not reported any mental health conditions, suicidal ideation, or self-harm.

Full story

I am an adult human female and I identify as gender-critical; I've said publicly that I'm 'GC, not trans' and that I mostly lurk in detransition spaces because I value and admire the courage of people who speak against popular opinion or 'compelled groupthink.' I have never described transitioning myself in anything I've written here — my participation has been as an outside supporter rather than as someone who detransitioned. I'm a big fan of words, language and etymology, and a lot of my commenting has been about language. I pushed back on redefining words, saying 'Redefining words isn't what changes a person's opinions or feelings, and a better command of language enables clarity of communication,' and I argued that people shouldn't attribute unspoken presumptions to a word that 'does not have any other meaning.' I also objected to people keying into a few words in someone's post and calling them out for scrutiny when they weren't the crux of the post. On transition medicine I'm openly skeptical. I wrote that 'It shouldn't even be legal to not be tracking the outcomes of such unconventional and experimental medical practices!' and called for 'a legitimate and unbiased analysis of data.' When someone asked whether few people really pass, I answered flatly: 'Yes. Very few people really ever pass. Even the ones you think are pretty and dainty in their online visuals.' I've also suggested therapy for someone seeking help, but cautioned against 'someone who's going to convince you more drugs would help,' and I've wished people comfort 'in your own skin and mind.' I've responded warmly to people describing top surgery scars and flat chests, telling one person that so many women are flat or small that it wouldn't be noticed outwardly, and that scars are 'a more intimate relationship conversation, or a change room where it's nobody's business anyway,' while hoping they find 'comfort and ease in your own skin real soon.' I've also encouraged people to 'face the world as yourself, proudly.' I've engaged with parents of gender-questioning kids, telling one father his heartfelt words were thoughtful and hoping his kid would take time to figure out 'how they really want to live....fighting their body forever, or working on mastering the self,' and telling another parent 'I'm so sorry this is happening to you, and specifically to your child. It's wrong,' while asking whether they had a network of resources. I've also complained about losing coverage for things like vision checks. On appearance and presentation I've said I've 'looked like this and I'm straight. Kinda girly in fact, just not flouncy,' describing a 'mod look' and saying I like the pants. I've commented supportively on people's photos ('You look great!') and used supportive, encouraging language throughout — 'Hang in there. Better days are ahead for you!'