These stories have been summarised using AI.
On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.
Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.
Full story
I am a 68-year-old lesbian who came out in 1971, and I have been out for 50 years. I am not detransitioned myself — I come to this community as an ally, and I post here to support younger women and men who are detransitioning or questioning. I want to be clear about that: I've never taken hormones or had any transition-related surgeries, but I have spent decades watching this issue from the lesbian side.
I was born female and have always known I was female. When I came out as a lesbian in 1971, my role models were 'butches, dykes and bulldaggers' of all races and backgrounds. Although I'm not butch myself, thanks to those brave women I cut off my hair and haven't worn a skirt in about 50 years. I don't own a tube of lipstick. When I was younger I was often mistaken for a man because of my short hair and clothing choices. That never really worried me, although sometimes men were threatened by me and wanted to beat me up. I'm still a woman. I've been a lesbian for 50 years and I've never experienced anything resembling the abusive behavior some people attribute to gay and lesbian communities.
I've been aware of the misogynist and homophobic aspects of trans ideology since the mid-1970s. Around 1975, I was at a meeting of lesbians at the gay and lesbian center when a researcher from the University of Buffalo showed up looking for volunteers for a study on transsexuality — the word 'transgender' didn't exist yet. She was offering each of us $25 to participate, seeking women who thought they might like to consider becoming men. That was a lot of money for young working-class dykes back then.
In 1993, I attended a lesbian festival on the East Coast where Julia Penelope, a brilliant linguist and writer, gave a talk. She had just come back from a queer theory academic conference in Texas. Her opening words were: 'well, they want to disappear the lesbians. They're saying that maleness equals power, and if you, as a woman, want power, you should become a man. Don't be a butch lesbian, be a man.' I asked her why we should care about what academics were saying. She said, 'because they're teaching this in the classroom and young women are absorbing it.' She was right.
I've been in an abusive relationship with a sociopath. Although it wasn't a cult, the relationship had many of the same features — constant control and criticism of my thoughts and actions, and separating me from my friends and family. After I left, I couldn't believe I had allowed myself to be so controlled by someone who claimed to love me. It took me years to de-program myself, including therapy to understand why I had tolerated an intolerable situation for so long. I still feel shaky sometimes, but mostly I'm good, and getting better all the time.
I also had a knee surgery to remove a large cyst, and it took about a year to regain sensation — that experience helps me understand what detransitioners go through with post-surgical numbness.
I am in the menopausal category now, which gives me some perspective on hormone treatments. I watched HRT be touted for decades as a cure-all for hot flashes, osteoporosis, mental decline, and depression, until cancer and blood clot rates went through the roof and doctors said 'oops, sorry ladies.'
My main reason for being here is to give support and encouragement to younger sisters who are detransitioning. I know from experience how hard it is to be a gender-nonconforming woman in this world. I try to help people see that masculine women have always existed, that lesbian community and visibility are keys to self-love and survival, and that detransitioners are not to blame for what happened to them. I've recommended Dr. Lisa Littman's detransition study to many people, and I've shared resources like Crash's blog, the book 'Female Erasure,' and the Parents of ROGD Kids organization. I believe the affirmative model of care is irresponsible and that what's happening to young people right now is medical malpractice on an international scale. I'm angry about it most days.
I don't believe in fate or destiny — I think we live in a random universe and our lives are the sum of our choices. I'm skeptical of metaphysical claims. I'm a libertarian about bodies: I support any adult's right to modify their body if that's what they need to feel sane. My problem is with the pseudoscience and misogyny underlying trans ideology, not with individual trans people. Some people really are trans and transitioning is an existential necessity for them. But it's not the answer for everyone, and the current system fails to help young people sort out their issues before making irreversible decisions.
I'm doing well. I have 50 years of lesbian community behind me, and I'm grateful for the friendships and love that have sustained me. I'm healthy, I'm still here, and I plan to keep speaking out.