These stories have been summarised using AI.
On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.
Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.
Summary
I am a detransitioned woman who identified as a trans man for years, went five years on testosterone, had top surgery and a total hysterectomy as a stage-0 for phalloplasty, but never pursued bottom surgery. I no longer identify as a man and want to embrace life as a butch lesbian, though I worry about how I'll be read given my masculine appearance, voice, name, and male ID marker. I don't regret my transition medically but I feel I was living a lie, and I now regret the hysterectomy most, feeling less like a woman without a uterus/ovaries and worrying about long-term health. I believe the healthcare system failed me by not exploring other treatments for dysphoria before hormones and surgery, and I criticize online trans communities for villainizing cis people. I am exclusively attracted to women and now understand myself as a lesbian rather than a straight man.
Full story
I've been questioning my gender identity for the past couple of months. I'm five years on testosterone, and I've had top surgery and a total hysterectomy. I don't regret my transition, but I no longer identify as a man. I knew medically transitioning wouldn't make me a biological male and thought I'd be satisfied as a trans man, but I feel like I'm living a lie.
Before I transitioned, I had a masculine appearance and exclusively dated women. I was perceived as a butch lesbian, but I never identified myself as butch. Lately I've been wanting to explore my womanhood as a butch lesbian, though I'm not sure how I'd be perceived in sapphic/lesbian spaces. I have a beard, an adam's apple, a deep voice, broad shoulders, a flat chest, and narrow hips. I feel like I'd be invading their space by looking too manly even though I'm a biological female. I worry that I'll be mistaken for a trans woman in female spaces since I have a masculine name and a male gender marker on all my IDs.
I had been on T for five years and had top surgery and a hysterectomy. The 'next step' was bottom surgery, but I realized that phalloplasty/metoidioplasty were too invasive and wouldn't have given me a functional penis. Detransitioning has given me a sense of relief. For a while I was considering bottom surgery, but after seeing the outcomes of meta/phallo, I've come to accept my body as is. I no longer have to worry about changing my personality to fit in with men or wearing certain clothes to pass. I can just exist as myself without having to meet a standard.
I'm exclusively attracted to women, but I've never felt comfortable calling myself a straight man. I'm stealth and pass 100% of the time, so when I interact with straight cis men they assume I'm also a straight cis man. Amongst themselves, they talk about women in the most derogatory way. I worked with a guy who was really into 'red pill' content. He regularly bragged about sleeping with multiple women because 'that's what men are supposed to do' but his girlfriend was only allowed to sleep with him. I've also never understood male culture. In predominantly male environments, I'm shy and prefer to keep to myself while the men enjoy roughhousing and talking shit to each other. For years I tried to fit in with men but I always stood out. Now I realize it's because I'm a lesbian and not a straight man.
On my physical changes: people don't usually notice my adam's apple unless I tilt my head back. I'm not interested in reconstruction or any other surgeries — aside from scarring, I'm satisfied with my chest. I don't wear anything under my tops besides a t-shirt occasionally; before I had top surgery I wore a binder, so I don't mind having a flat chest. I pass as a man when I'm not clean shaven; my facial hair gets me misgendered more than my chest.
I felt the same way when I was a teenager — maybe it has something to do with being young and seeking validation from your peers. Nowadays I don't care if I'm gendered male or female.
I had a hysterectomy (with ovaries, fallopian tubes, and cervix removed) as a 'stage 0' procedure for phalloplasty. Initially I felt like a weight had been lifted from my shoulders. But now, after almost four years, I'm having second thoughts. I never moved forward with phalloplasty, and I no longer identify as a trans man. I want to embrace my womanhood, but not having a uterus/ovaries makes me feel like less of a woman. I try to think about the advantages like not having to worry about periods, PMS, pregnancy, birth control, or cervical/ovarian cancer, but I worry about my long-term health.
On hormones and mental health: being on T definitely gave me brain fog and made me feel 'dumb' in general.
On the healthcare system: I agree that a healthy body shouldn't be altered to treat a mental illness. However, those of us who struggle with dysphoria are told that transitioning is the only treatment. It reaffirms the feeling of being 'trapped in the wrong body'. The healthcare system should be blamed, not the patients. I wish doctors explored other forms of treatment before prescribing hormones and surgery. I also pushed back against comparisons of dysphoria to stage 4 cancer, saying 'I wasn't comparing stage 4 cancer to dysphoria.'
On trans communities: cis is the default. Online trans communities villainize cis people, which makes people think being cis is bad. I also quoted approvingly the advice: 'You should figure out the root cause of your dysphoria and find ways to manage it instead of medically altering your body.'