All stories

A fetish for being a man, and the misogyny that kept her there

Female · Detransitioned326
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a detransitioned lesbian woman — an ex-trans man — who now accepts myself as female and tries to be proud of it, though the misogyny where I live makes that hard. I describe my past desire to be a man, including a fetish for having sex with women as a man, as a harmful and unrealizable delusion that I have escaped. I am gender-nonconforming, do not wear makeup, and have repeatedly been asked in 2025 whether I am transgender. I hold critical views of trans women in women's sports and models, of trans-inclusive lesbian discourse, and of childhood medical transition, while supporting adult consent-based surgery. I referenced depression — saying I might "push it" on a night of severe depression — but described no suicide attempt or self-harm.

Full story

I am a lesbian woman and an ex-trans man — I used to want to be a man, and I lived through a period of identifying as trans, which I have since come out of. I write in English using a translator because my English is poor, and I am an Asian woman living in an environment with a lower average height than many people in the community I post in. My experience as a trans man included what I now describe as a fetish or delusion: "When I was a trans man, I had a fetish for having sex with women as a man. However, this delusion was very harmful and biologically unrealizable." I describe myself now as "a person who has escaped from that desire." I do not give dates for when I first felt dysphoria, came out, socially transitioned, took hormones, or had any surgeries — none of that is stated in what I have written, so I leave those timeline points blank. I also do not describe any medical interventions, complications, or fertility concerns. What I do describe is the process of accepting myself as a woman again. I wrote: "I accept that I can't be fully male and try to be proud to be a woman, but the misogyny where I live is terrible." I have advised another person going through the same thing: "If you feel comfortable, you don't have to stop the habits of when you identified yourself as a trans. The only thing that has changed is that you have accepted that you are a woman. I spent the same period, so I know it's hard." I believe being a woman is a matter of biology, not presentation: "To be a woman, you don't need makeup or dress. It's just that you're biologically a woman, and that's enough. You can be a woman without following a woman's gender role." I am a gender-nonconforming woman — I don't wear makeup and don't dress very femininely. I note that since the beginning of 2025 I have been asked many times, "Are you a trans gender?" I think society has gone backwards over the past 10 years: "If a woman does not do feminine things, she is literally considered not a woman." I reject that: "Being a gnc woman does not affect my femininity at all. I am a woman. All biological women are equally women." I also see gender stereotypes being applied in reverse — "if you have short hair, you are man; if you wear a skirt, you are woman" — and find it "ridiculous" that people assume this view is progressive. On mental health, I have referenced depression: when asked about pushing forward, I answered, "To be honest, I think I would push it. On a night of severe depression." I do not describe a diagnosis, self-harm, or a suicide attempt. I have not described therapy, either helpful or harmful, nor exposure to detransition communities, research, spiritual experiences, psychedelics, time off hormones, medical scares, or family/partner intervention as factors in my detransition — none of that appears in what I have written. On adversity, I point to the misogyny where I live as a serious burden, and I describe a broader social climate in which women who are not feminine are read as not-women. I have not described childhood trauma, abuse, assault, bullying, or family dysfunction. On sexuality, I am a lesbian. I describe my past sexual fantasy life as a trans man as a fetish for having sex with women as a man, which I now regard as harmful and unrealizable. I am critical of how lesbian communities online handle this: "many lesbian communities on the Internet are full of transideologies. I'm tired of topics like 'There are lesbians with male genitals' and 'Cotton sealing is unfair'." I believe such content "only affirms fetishism" and will not have a good effect on lesbians or trans women, and I object to what I see as gaslighting heterosexual sex as lesbian sex. When I raise this, I say people accuse me of being "a narrow transphobia, a radical evangelical, or an anti-feminist who opposes abortion," which annoys me greatly. On regret, I do not use the word regret explicitly, but I express strong negative feelings about my time as a trans man: I call the desire I had "very harmful and biologically unrealizable" and describe myself as having "escaped" it. I also express anger at people who "tell lies to their children, such as that humans can change sex and hormone therapy is reversible," calling them hypocrites for teaching "mentally unstable children that you were not born with the right body" and then giving hormones. I have not stated whether my feelings are improving, stable, or worsening over time. On outcomes, I am living as a woman and trying to be proud of it, though I find the misogyny around me difficult. I do not describe career, family, or support-network details. On attitudes toward transition for others, I hold a mixed position. I think sex reassignment surgery should not be prohibited for consenting adults of sound judgment: "Everything should be done at one's own risk and with a thorough explanation of the risks by a physician." But I do not believe surgery changes sex: "we can have surgery to look like the opposite sex, but we cannot have a perfect opposite sex body," and I think it is "nonsense" that genital surgery should allow entry into opposite-sex spaces or competition in opposite-sex sports. I dislike Trump but agree with some of his positions on gender ideology, calling it "madness to decide which toilets you can enter, which sports you can participate in or which hospitals you can visit based on your self-identification" — while worrying he wants to reinforce gender rather than dismantle it, since "Women don't have to be feminine and men don't have to be masculine. They just can't be anything other than the sex they were born into." I am also critical of trans women competing in women's sports and of trans women working as female models, arguing this takes awards, scholarships, and work away from biological women. I have not described any formal advocacy or activism beyond posting and commenting online.