These stories have been summarised using AI.
On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.
Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.
Summary
I am a desisted gay man, born male and autistic, who publicly identified as nonbinary for several years before desisting without ever medically transitioning. I never felt male and still can't perceive myself as a man among men, and I believe autism, homosexuality, internalized homophobia, and internalized misandry all contributed. I've been avoiding sexual activity and struggling with discomfort about my male body and genitalia, while therapy has been unhelpful or overly affirming. I'm presenting as male in daily life but still prefer no pronouns online, and I continue to work on accepting maleness. I have no reported self-harm or suicidal ideation.
Full story
I'm a desisted male — born male, gay, and autistic — and I've been writing about what led me to identify as nonbinary and what desisting has actually felt like day to day.
I publicly identified as nonbinary for a few years and was socially trans for around four years. I never medically transitioned — no hormones, no surgeries — so I describe myself as desisted rather than detrans, and I've tried to be careful to give space to people who actually went through medical changes. I've been fully desisted for a while now; as of one of my posts I'd been fully desisted for nearly a year, and elsewhere I described myself as "desist*ing*" because the process is ongoing. I'm 6'4" with size 13 men's shoes and a naturally higher voice than many men, and I've never been androgynous-looking, which matters because I know I could never pass as a woman no matter what.
The core of my experience is that I have never felt male. Not in the vague way people say most cis people don't 'feel' like their gender — more that when I'm around other men I feel fundamentally different from them, like there's something unknown and intangible they have that makes them male that I lack. I feel about as far from maleness as from femaleness despite being born in a male body. On a work Zoom with almost all men I legitimately could not see myself as a male the same way they were. I can't be in a group of men and see myself as anything but a genderless, nonbinary individual, even when they treat me as a man. Everyone else seems to see me as unambiguously male, so why can't I? It feels like there's something I'm missing that other men have but I don't know what it is.
I think several things fed into this. I'm autistic and was infantilized my entire life for it, and I'm high-masking. I realized I was gay during high school and stayed in the closet for the rest of it; the point at which I started feeling ostracized by other boys was, not coincidentally, the point at which I started thinking I might not be male at all. I grew up with nothing in common with other males and found it easier to connect with women. I attended a public high school with a uniform — black dress shoes, khakis, long-sleeve oxford shirts or polo, ties for boys — and I actually enjoyed the ties back then, liked tying alternative knots, and didn't feel like I didn't deserve to be male because I was surrounded by people of all genders who shared my intellectual interests. I was never good at being social or making friends. I'm a rhythm gamer, and I've noticed that male-dominated niche hobbies are often policed by other men as 'gay' or feminine, and those spaces can be toxically masculine; I've avoided those communities partly because being a male in a male-dominated space makes me feel like I'm somehow part of the problem or making things worse for women.
Homophobia was at least a factor. I wouldn't say it was the primary reason for my transition, but having some way to say I wasn't gay felt amazing. I still dream of being a woman so I can be with guys and not feel disgusting. My sex drive is nearly nonexistent, and most of the homophobia I experienced was because of that rather than me being out. I've also come to believe internalized misandry is a considerable factor in why I hate my genitalia and body — a commenter raised it and I realized I'd actively avoided considering it because I'd been told it doesn't exist or is a cop-out. I've taught myself to hate being a man, having a male body, and presenting masculinely, and convinced myself it's completely incompatible with me, due to both internalized homophobia and internalized misandry. I also feel guilt over the benefits I reap from patriarchy by being male, and I hate being part of the demographic responsible for so much violence against women.
Desisting has been confusing and, in some ways, made things harder. I present 'as male' in the real world now, which was a huge and scary step, and I've been mentally preparing to lose my longer hair. Online I still prefer no pronouns or they/them; I'm not at the stage where I can be he/him and pretend I'm a gay male. Unisex clothes that look good on either sex feel affirming — I borrowed an oversize jean jacket from my mom's closet that fit me perfectly and nobody batted an eye, and I hadn't felt that good about my appearance in years; the contentment came from the unisexness of it. I've had a strange dream about wearing 18th-century men's clothing for a play in which my dysphoria vanished completely, which felt affirming in a way that wasn't just costume fun.
Words still sting. He, him, his, handsome, man, brother, sir, mister — they give me an instinctive discomfort to the same degree as when I was outwardly trans. Statements like 'men can't get pregnant' or 'men can't get periods' make me irrationally uncomfortable, not because I don't know they're true but because they remind me I'll never be part of a sisterhood. I've been avoiding anything sexual for a while because looking at or touching my genitalia in the shower gives me discomfort and guilt; sometimes they feel 'on loan,' like I'm waiting for the body I was supposed to have. I have a lot of issues with my height because it illustrates sexual dimorphism, which makes me anxious and hopeless — it's impossible for a man to come close to having the anatomy of a woman. I've thought about surgery and told myself I could cope with complications, but intellectually I don't think I could, which is one of the only things that has kept me from pursuing transition. I'm not going to transition; I've seen the horror stories. I'm certain it isn't AGP — there's nothing sexual about it, and I'm not even attracted to women.
I've also felt unsafe and out of place. Until recently I avoided any gendered bathroom at the expense of my bladder, never going into women's rooms because I didn't belong and gender-neutral spaces are rare; I've now started using men's bathrooms again, but I feel sized up and like something bad could happen. I live in a large city where bending gender roles or being gay ranges from accepted to risky to my physical safety depending on the area, and I've learned where it's safe; I've done what I hope is a good enough job of 'passing for straight.' People have weaponized my height against me — 'you're a 6'4" man, what do you have to be scared of' — to invalidate my fears.
I've been going to therapy, but my therapists have been unhelpful and/or overly affirming. I've looked for detrans/desist male spaces and found them scarce; detrans spaces are primarily women, which is wonderful, but it can feel lonely and makes me hesitant to discuss issues specific to men. I changed my name recently — I got rid of my father's last name — and found it relieving, a weight off my shoulders. I don't think identifying as nonbinary helps me accept being male; it's a hurdle I'm still trying to get over. I want to find ways to experience something like gender euphoria as a man, and I've realized I need to work on internalized misandry and internalized homophobia. There aren't many gay or neurodivergent males in fiction or otherwise whom I look up to, and I think finding that would help. I still struggle to see myself as a man, but I'm not in the same pattern I used to be in, and I have faith I'll get there — though it may be a lifelong challenge.