All stories

Since 2019, arguing online that the brain comes first

Female · Detransitioned393
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a detransitioned, straight, femme-presenting woman born female, with ADHD and a history of depression treated with Zoloft, who has carried a pregnancy. Since 2019 I have posted extensively in detrans and gender-critical forums, arguing that transition is a conscious choice, that criticism of trans activism is not bigotry, and that permanent bodily changes should never be made while mental health is in crisis. I advise others to treat underlying conditions — OCD, BPD, bipolar, suicidality — first, telling one person 'Body comes second — brain comes first right now,' and I have urged anyone with suicidal ideation to call 911. I identify as a biological female woman and have advised others on how to reclaim access to women's spaces after detransitioning. I remain critical of transition as a general proposition while allowing it may be right for some individuals.

Full story

I have been posting in detransition and gender-critical spaces since at least April 2019, and my comments make clear that I am a detransitioned woman — a natal female who previously transitioned and later stopped. In January 2020 I advised another detransitioned person on a practical problem: how to regain use of the women's locker room. I suggested talking to management, explaining that she is a biological female and detrans, and giving management permission to explain to anyone who complains that the person in the locker room is a biological female woman. That advice reflects how I have handled my own re-entry into female-only spaces: straightforward disclosure of my natal sex rather than argument. I was born female. In July 2019 I wrote, '(Natal woman, no hormones, feet swelled in pregnancy but went back down),' which tells me I have carried a pregnancy, and I described myself elsewhere as 'a femme presenting straight woman.' I also said, 'I can't "not be" a woman or female— I am one,' and 'I have ADD and working with an organizational therapist worked wonders for me,' so I have ADHD and have benefited from therapy. I also mentioned struggling to get medication refills in the past — needing an ID I didn't have, an expired physical prescription, a pharmacy out of stock — and that I was once 'scared to start taking depression medication' before finding it 'the best thing I've ever done,' with Zoloft. I've noted I'm '50 lbs heavier' than as a teenager and that I was 'a 10' in shoe size in my teens (in the aughts) and am now an 8.5. My writing is dominated by advocacy rather than personal narrative, but several statements reveal my own reasoning about transition. I am sharply critical of what I call 'Trans activist circles' that tell gay people it is 'transphobic' not to be attracted to trans people — 'that assertion is actually quite homophobic' — and I insist that 'sexualities are based on what other people *are* and the bodies they were born with, not what they wish they were and wish they had.' I argue that 'if there was no difference between cis and trans, there *wouldn't be such a thing as trans*.' I push back hard on the idea that criticism of trans activism is bigotry: 'You don't see the irony in creating a "safe space" for detransitioning people but then dictating what they can say about how they feel towards trans activism and current ideology?' I distinguish criticism of 'the current political and social movement' from criticism 'of trans persons.' I also defend gender-critical feminists: 'Rad fems do not want you to suffer and die,' and I challenged someone who described feminists as lacking humanity merely because they 'only care about women's rights.' A great deal of my advice concerns mental health and the danger of making permanent bodily changes while in psychological crisis. Telling a 19-year-old with borderline personality disorder, bipolar, and ADHD, I wrote: 'Maybe you are trans, but there is so much else going on that you'll never be able to figure that out until you tackle your other mental health issues. Don't make any permanent changes to your body until you do that.' I added, 'Changing your body won't give you the control over your brain and life that you're seeking. It will only add to the chaos.' I urged someone with debilitating OCD to seek medication immediately: 'This is WAY past what "mindfulness" can control... This is neurotransmitters out of wack,' and I told them, 'You aren't a male, you aren't in denial about being a male or a man... Your body is a female body and you are a woman.' I repeatedly frame transition as a conscious, controllable choice: 'People don't accidentally transition, or stumble into it— it is a conscious choice, and one within your control.' I am skeptical of hormones as a route to feeling better: 'as someone who has never taken them, why do you think that a specific drug that you've never used will somehow make you feel the way you've always wanted to feel?' I worry about 'the hope that you put in a drug that you have no idea how it will make you feel' and about 'irreversible surgery,' while conceding 'you are an adult, and it is your money and your choice.' In one thread I advised someone already on hormones: '(Not T. If you've stopped that, Keep stopping that. If you haven't; ask your endo how to safely stop them. Body comes second — brain comes first right now.)' I also address suicidal thinking directly, telling one person, 'If you are considering taking any steps towards "ending it", please call 911 immediately,' and analyzing a man's wish to transition as an escape from a 'toxic masculinity prison in your own mind' — 'Transitioning would let you off the hook from all the requirements that you've put on yourself to have value as a man.' I told him the solution 'isn't to push through to try to be a woman. It's to work with mental health professionals to dismantle the prison in your mind.' I ended by allowing that transition might be right for some: 'Perhaps talking hormones and surgery and going by a new name is the right choice for you to finally not want to be dead— and if it is the right move for you then Godspeed.' On gender generally, I hold a gender-critical view: 'Gender doesn't really exist— it is little boxes that society came up with to keep everyone in line,' and I told a gender-nonconforming man, 'You'll always be a man, a male, a he, but you don't have to meet any external standards for what that means.' I've argued that historical medical errors — lobotomies, the four humors, bloodletting, recovered-memory panics, the Salem witch trials — show that '