All stories

Anonymous poster who hid her own detransition — then wrote the arguments

Female · Detransitioned136
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a detransitioned person who, in late 2019, posted motivational support for the detrans community while arguing online that gender dysphoria is a mental illness per the DSM-5 and that transitioning is not a real treatment but rather an extreme, aesthetic 'easy way out' akin to liposuction. I did not disclose personal details of my own transition or detransition in these posts. I hold critical views of transition as a medical intervention and believe underlying mental health issues should be treated first.

Full story

I posted a motivational message to the detrans community in November 2019, encouraging people to find ways to make themselves happier, enjoy the bright things life has to offer, be proud of who they are, and be kind. Around the same time, I got into a series of online arguments about someone who had been permanently banned from a forum for asking what I considered a legitimate question. I thought the ban was intolerant and ridiculous, and that the person hadn't insulted anyone. I argued that gender dysphoria is classified as a mental illness in the DSM-5, and that the person asking about it hadn't done anything wrong by raising a point that science has brought up. My view, stated plainly, was that "changing genders isn't a treatment" and that someone should seek treatment first. I said that if someone is willing to go to the extreme of getting an operation such as transitioning, then maybe it is a mental illness, because it's a huge operation that causes many side effects, and treatment should be sought prior to making that huge leap. I was quite combative with people who disagreed with me. I told one person they sounded like the intolerant people the original poster had written about, that they were "absolutely abysmal at listening to a differing opinion," and that I wouldn't be surprised if they lived a sheltered life with no acknowledgement of the outside world. I dismissed comparisons I found flawed, noting that a Christian belief in the Bible has zero scientific evidence while the DSM-5 does. I also compared transition to what I called "looking for the easy way out and getting liposuction which does nothing for your health, doesn't change your lifestyle, and just brings an aesthetic change." I argued that people who don't want to hear the truth get absolutely nowhere in life because they keep avoiding the underlying problem, and that if there's an issue you need to raise awareness and do something to resolve it. I didn't share any personal details about my own transition, detransition timeline, medical history, mental health, or reasons for detransitioning in these posts — only these general views and the motivational message.