All stories

Came close at 16, then found the mundane explanation

Female · Desisted275
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a detransitioned/desisted woman who never medically or socially transitioned — I came close as a teenager but realized before making permanent changes that my distress had more mundane explanations than gender dysphoria. I now write critically about trans ideology, particularly the framing of common adolescent discomfort as dysphoria, the demand for external validation, and the pressure to cut off family. I was never diagnosed with anything and made no permanent bodily changes, so there are no medical regrets. I hold strongly critical views of transition advocacy and the trans community's framing of suicide statistics.

Full story

I was born female. I never actually questioned my gender as a kid or teen — I just fell into the trap of thinking that because I was experiencing very common things like being depressed, being anxious, feeling I didn't fit in, and being uncomfortable with my body, particularly as a girl who was still in or had just completed puberty, then maybe I wasn't "really" a girl. This happened especially around the time I was a teenager who had just moved cross-country. It wasn't that I actually minded being a girl; gender dysphoria just seemed like the easiest, most convenient explanation for all my problems, because entire online communities were presenting it as such and promising that it would all go away if I "just" transitioned. Fortunately I realized there were more mundane, if not as simple to address, explanations for my issues before I made any permanent changes. I never came out, never socially transitioned, never started hormones, never had any surgeries, and never made permanent changes to my body. I now think that the assertion that extremely common experiences are signs of gender dysphoria is one of the biggest myths the trans community promotes. I also think the myth that transition is itself simple in any way is dangerous — "egg-crackers" seriously undersell how complicated, stressful, and exhausting it is, even before you get to the parts you'd need a doctor's help for. A lot of the complications come from family and friends struggling to adjust and keep up, no matter how supportive they are. I seriously wonder if the reason the trans community is so quick to encourage cutting off family and moving to an all-trans or "queer" friend group is because it disguises how socially difficult it is to completely change yourself like that. I'm critical of how trans identity is framed as depending almost entirely on external perception rather than internal experience. I contrast it with being gay, which I see as completely self-enforcing and internal — you need zero external validation to be attracted to the same sex. When someone comes out as trans, by contrast, there's a requirement that whoever they come out to treat them differently in nearly every interaction, and if that validation isn't provided, the trans person feels slighted. I have quite literally never seen a trans person who accepts being treated in the same manner as before they began identifying as trans, even when the manner they were being treated in wasn't gendered to begin with. I've thought a lot about suicide statistics cited in trans advocacy. I question the claim that people die because of transphobic rhetoric. The rate of transphobic hate crimes is very low and it's unclear how many are actually motivated by hatred, since most involve other factors like drugs, prostitution, or gangs. The deaths in question are really referring to suicides, but the rate at which trans people attempt or commit suicide is much higher than the rate at which people actively being genocided attempt or commit suicide. When your group is committing or attempting suicide at higher rates than victims of the Holocaust, there must be something other than social pressure going on — especially since the level of acceptance from family/friends/peers doesn't seem to affect the likelihood of a suicide attempt, nor does transitioning in a unfortunately high number of cases. I've also commented on detransition dynamics. I think most detransitioners are relatively young and often people who started their transition while underaged — "I was a confused, traumatized teenager and they railroaded me into transition instead of addressing my underlying issues" is a common theme. People who transition later in life tend not to detransition even when it's obvious they're making themselves miserable. I've noted that a lot of MtFs on reddit are older autogynephiles who are more socially isolated in real life and much more heavily embedded in internet trans culture, so they fall victim to sunk cost fallacy more and their social life would completely vanish if they detransitioned. I also think girls and women seem more likely to start identifying as trans at a younger age than boys and men, so the average FtM is in a better position to say "No, this was a mistake, but I'm going to try to reclaim my life now." I've discussed intersex issues too — many "corrective" surgeries on intersex babies were not medically necessary but done to make them match an arbitrarily assigned sex. Thankfully that practice has largely fallen away in the US and karyotyping is now used to determine sex. I think appropriation of AFAB/AMAB to describe non-intersex people is on par with trans-identified males describing themselves as victims of female genital mutilation. On community safety, I've said that demographic and community are not the same thing — an abusive person can transition and detransition all they want, you don't have to let them into your spaces. I avoid male transitioners at all costs but prefer to give male detransitioners (or regular men who never got into gender stuff) the benefit of the doubt and only cut them off if they behave badly. I have brothers, and if someone accused either of them of sexual assault with no proof and they denied it, I'd believe my brothers over the accuser. I also told a 20-year-old poster to get off the internet, get a job, and stop asking other people what to do with their life, saying that spending all your time online and relying on others to do your thinking is exactly why they're so immature. I don't currently identify as trans. I see myself as someone who briefly considered transition as an explanation for ordinary teenage distress but caught it before making permanent changes.