All stories

Two 30-minute assessments, five years of estrogen, a lifetime of testosterone

Male · Detransitioned50
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a detransitioned man who transitioned to live as a woman after a physically abusive upbringing, and I now regret listening to peer pressure to transition. After 5 years of HRT — obtained through just two 30-minute online assessments — I detransitioned and have been off estradiol for 4 months, but because of surgery I must take testosterone for life. I'm dealing with irreversible changes including retained breast tissue, puffy nipples, and altered fat distribution, and I wish I'd received real therapy for my C-PTSD, anxiety, depression, and self-esteem instead of quick access to hormones. I now see my transition as an attempt to merge a daydream of escape from violence into reality, and I cringe at having performed a stereotyped caricature of femininity.

Full story

I was born male and grew up in an abusive environment — I experienced physical abuse both at home and at school, largely from males. That abuse made me repulsed by my own maleness and pushed me away from male spaces. I never felt comfortable around sports or machismo culture; growing up I always found solace with other women, and as people my age moved into dating I got left behind. I always "knew" I would fit in better as a woman — I was wrong. My desire to be a woman was rooted in a daydream I invented to escape the violence: a fantasy of being whisked away to some safe, non-violent world where I could live as a woman. A lot of what drove me toward transition was narrative and self-storytelling — my story was that of a sad boy who wanted to be rescued. As I got older I saw trans people taking HRT, holding regular jobs, and living in society, and I began wondering if that was for me; occasional cross-dressing or gender-fluid presentation wasn't enough anymore. When I started getting pressure from trans spaces that my "egg would crack," that fed the narrative — I took it to mean I was something authentic and that transition was right and meant for me. I began by dressing gender-fluid and presenting as a woman. Then people pressured me, saying my egg would crack. My actual medicalization was remarkably quick: I got GAHT after two 30-minute online assessments plus proof of a physical within the last year. It hardly seemed "gender confirming" in any deep sense. I was on HRT for 5 years. I also had laser hair removal a few years ago. I woke up when I realized I might end up a middle-aged trans woman with no career and only hive-minded, hug-box internet friends. I'm already behind my peers career-wise, and I wasn't sure a man or woman would want to spend their life with someone who has an "uncanny valley look." Real life isn't the internet — the best pictures I took of myself thinking I looked "so femme" were just filters, light, and shadow. You get tired of caking on foundation every day to cover a beard or trying to hide male face shapes. After 5 years I'm over it — the hassle and the discrimination. This story/fantasy world I was trying to live in isn't real; it was just trying to merge a daydream I invented to escape an abusive environment into reality. What I most regret is listening to peer pressure to transition. Now, after 5 years of HRT, I'm stuck with breast tissue, puffy nipples for a man, and fat deposits in unmanly places. I also cringe at having acted as a caricature of a woman — always putting on an "en femme" show of what I thought femininity was, based ultimately on stereotypes. I detransitioned. I've been off estradiol for 4 months, but because of surgery I need to take supplemental testosterone orally for life. Progress since stopping is slow but present: stubble is returning with coarser hairs coming in slowly, and I have sparse chest hair coming in — which looks strange alongside the breast tissue I still have, especially around the ripple area. I'm concerned about nipple size and whether it will shrink back to pre-HRT levels. I don't know exactly where I'd draw the line on gatekeeping, but I think my HRT journey was a joke — two 30-minute appointments and a physical and BAM, I'm on hormones. I believe some form of therapy (far more than 2 sessions) exploring C-PTSD, anxiety, depression, and self-esteem issues would have helped me. I wish we'd look at underlying issues in therapy instead of quickly assigning hormones as an answer. I can only speak for myself, but that's what I wish had happened for me.