All stories

Tumblr and a college club, then three years of testosterone

Female · Detransitioned565
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a detransitioned woman who lived as a man for several years. I was born female, identified as trans after exposure to Tumblr and a college LGBT club, took testosterone for about three years (last shot in 2017), and had a double mastectomy. I detransitioned around 2017 with the help of radical feminist material, and while I initially said I didn't regret it, I now do and feel bitter about it, though I can't afford therapy. I still pass as male, which causes ongoing distress, and I've had suicidal thoughts most of my life. I remain broadly supportive of trans people but am critical of community hypocrisy and uncomfortable around transition topics.

Full story

I was born female and first came across trans identity on Tumblr between 2012 and 2014, when I had barely considered transness before. The idea that any question about your gender meant you were definitely trans was everywhere on there, and around the same time I went to a college with an LGBT club that was mostly trans people who told me, after hearing about my feelings, "You're trans!! You're trans!!!" I've never had a firm grasp on my sense of identity, and the promise that transition meant becoming your "true self" is what did it for me. I saw a gender therapist for about 3.5 years. She was the one who jumped through all the hoops to get me on HRT, and she never listened to my doubts about being trans. When I started expressing doubts, she insisted it was just because I had a narrow definition of what a man is; whenever I said the label didn't fit anymore, she would shut it down and tell me of course I was trans. My psychiatrist at the time was male, but the endocrinologist who prescribed my hormones was female, as was my gender therapist. I was on testosterone for about three years (I've said 2-3 years and three years at different points; my last shot of T was in 2017). I passed as a man quite well and was stealth after just a few months on T. I had a double mastectomy without chest masculinization, but no SRS. I purposefully chose a unisex name in case I had regrets and wanted to detransition, though at the time I was 100% sure transition was right for me. I hated the way men treated me and each other, felt like I was lying to myself and everybody, and eventually found myself drawn more and more to women—something odd, since before I was trans I thought it was hard to relate to other women. I realized I identified with them more and wanted to be around them, not as a man but as a woman, and suddenly being trans didn't make sense anymore. On sexual factors: for as long as I can remember I had a lot of sexual fantasies about being a man or having a penis, and I was really into yaoi and BL. I believe autogynephilia and possibly autoandrophilia are real things worth researching, though controversial on all sides. I also think body dysmorphia played a role—one reason I transitioned in the first place. I detransitioned with the help of radical feminist and gender critical material, though I don't really subscribe to it anymore. It's been about three years since I detransitioned as of mid-2020. When I first came out as detransitioning, I said I didn't regret it, mostly to keep my trans friends from hating me outright; it didn't work, and now I do regret it. I'm bitter about it, though I recognize that isn't healthy, but I can't afford therapy right now. I lost a fair few trans friends, though my family was just like "whatever floats your boat, man." I didn't mention radical feminism to friends; when I just said "I realized I'm not a dude," they were accepting, but I still lost a few friends—bound to happen with an insular community like the trans community. In January 2019 I emailed my old gender therapist to tell her I had detransitioned. She apologized for her role in my transition (which seemed self-serving, given I'd told her I didn't blame her) and asked me to come in for a meeting to discuss my experience and what she should know to be respectful and thorough with future clients. I accepted and met with her; I hoped she'd listen and take my story into account, while preparing for the worst. I still get unreasonably angry and uncomfortable around trans and transition-related content, even three years after detransitioning. I find the claim that I wasn't "really trans" to be bullshit—I had gender dysphoria, which I've since pretty much gotten over after detransitioning—and I can't stand the hypocrisy that the same people saying detransitioners were never trans are the ones saying anyone who says they're trans is trans. As much as I still support trans people, I get very uncomfortable listening to people talk about transitioning, and I'd rather not hear about it. Physically, I'm masculine: I'm masculine, I wear my hair short or bald, and the testosterone deepened my voice and made me look more masculine. I still pass as male 100%, and people who do call me "ma'am" and "she" do it in a way where I can tell they think I'm a trans woman. Getting mistaken for a man is devastating; it's not just "you're a man" I hear, it's "you're ugly." When I was getting a bridesmaid dress tailored in September 2020, the tailor assumed I was male and I didn't correct her because people trip over themselves to apologize and make a huge deal out of it. I smiled and nodded and pretended to be a man because it's easier than explaining I'm detransitioned. I know I'm a woman and don't need validation, but it makes me feel like garbage. I was a pretty androgynous girl growing up and the T pushed me squarely into manly territory. It took a long time to get any semblance of a sex drive again—maybe a few months to a year—after having had a high sex drive beforehand; antidepressants and other psychiatric medication may have contributed, and my doctors never discussed those side effects with me, I had to look them up myself. I've had suicidal thoughts most of my life. I've been in self-imposed quarantine for about a year (as of January 2021) and socialize mostly on Discord servers with a lot of trans members. I tried telling them I'm detrans; most were supportive, saying things like "It takes a long time to figure out your gender, and just because you made a mistake doesn't make you any less of a person," which irked me because it wasn't a light or happy decision—it weighed on me for weeks before I acted and months before I told people. It felt patronizing, like "haha oopsie-daisy" rather than "oh I fucked way up." Then I was told not to talk about it lest I trigger or offend anyone, and had to delete the message. I don't have many IRL friends and feel I have to walk on eggshells or be dishonest about myself. I've thought about breast reconstruction after my double mastectomy and would recommend fat grafting over implants, especially for smaller breasts, since results look more natural and have fewer complications. My mom also had a double mastectomy and reconstruction with implants that didn't look good—a divot between her natural remaining fat and the implants—and she didn't live much longer after that. On dating, I note in my Tinder profile that I've had a double mastectomy and have no breasts, in a sardonic tone like "if you like boobs, you might want to look elsewhere," and recommend being upfront before getting into bed with someone. I've also reconsidered politics: I used to explain female-to-male transition as misogyny, internalized or otherwise, but reading about male detransitioners opened my mind. I'm beginning to see that what I experience could be attributed to misandry, and that as a woman and a feminist I was trained to believe men were garbage. Blanket statements like "all women are oppressed" and "all men are oppressors" don't make sense to me anymore, and I hope to be more open-minded about male detransitioners and male issues. I'm 26 and out of university as of February 2021. Many of my friends are trans and nonbinary and seem to think "she's REALLY nonbinary, she just doesn't want to say it," and sometimes I feel like I should give in, but I know deep down I am a woman. I've also given advice to someone starting T about acne, voice drop, oily skin, hair thinning, moodiness and libido.