Overview
Chest binding means flattening the breasts with a tight garment so that the chest looks male. Trans-identified girls and women and some non-binary people bind. So do some girls who never take on a trans identity at all. Binding is often the first physical step of social transition, and it is easy to start. Binders are sold online without age checks, and peers, youth groups and some charities pass them on. In the UK the charity Mermaids sent binders to young people as young as 13, some of them without their parents' knowledge (see Mermaids).
The research on binding is thin. Almost all of it comes from online surveys of people who bind and who chose to take part. The largest, by Peitzmeier and colleagues in 2017, asked 1,800 people born female about symptoms they put down to binding. Over 97% reported at least one, most often back pain, overheating, chest pain and shortness of breath. Rib problems and skin damage were less common but not rare. The same respondents also reported large improvements in mood when they bound. No study has followed people over time, measured lung function or ribs directly, or looked at what binding during puberty does to breast development or later breastfeeding.
Detransitioned and desisted women describe binding in ways that study participants mostly do not. Many say it was where a growing dislike of their chest became fixed. Some say it made their distress worse, because the flattened outline became the "real" body and the uncovered chest became intolerable. Some say the damage they believe binding did to their breasts later made a mastectomy feel like a small further step. Many also describe the reasons they bound: discomfort with puberty, unwanted sexual attention and a wish to stop being seen as female. In hindsight they did not see these as signs of being male. Many trans men describe binding as something they endured to get through the years before surgery, and they say it was worth the cost.
This page covers what binders are and who supplies them, the health research, effects on breast tissue and breastfeeding, binding as a step towards surgery, why girls bind, how detransitioners and trans men look back on it, and how people stop binding and recover.
What binders are
A binder is a purpose-built compression garment, usually a short vest or full-length tank top of nylon and elastane with a reinforced front panel. It presses breast tissue flat against the chest wall and spreads it towards the armpits. Binding can also be done with sports bras (often several layered), athletic compression wear, elastic bandages, or, more dangerously, duct tape or plastic wrap. A newer option is trans tape, a stretchy adhesive tape like kinesiology tape that is stuck across the breasts and worn for several days.
| Method | Share of Peitzmeier 2017 sample who had used it | What the study found |
|---|---|---|
| Commercial binder | 87.2% | The method most often linked to symptoms (20 of 28 outcomes), possibly because it compresses hardest |
| Sports bra | 33.1% | Among the methods least often linked to symptoms |
| Layered shirts | 24.0% | — |
| Several sports bras at once | 18.6% | Among the methods least often linked to symptoms |
| Elastic or other bandage | 16.5% | Linked to 14 of 28 outcomes |
| Athletic compression wear | 15.3% | Among the methods least often linked to symptoms |
| Duct tape or plastic wrap | 4.3% | Linked to 13 of 28 outcomes |
The commercial binder result surprised the authors. Trans community advice has long held that a correctly sized commercial binder is the safe option, and that tape and bandages are the dangerous ones. The study could not tell whether binders are risky in themselves or whether people wore them too tight, layered two at once, or wore them for longer (Peitzmeier et al. 2017).
Community safety rules usually say: wear a correctly sized binder, never sleep or exercise in it, take it off after 8 to 12 hours, and take days off. Many detransitioned women say they broke these rules as teenagers, and that nobody stopped them. One recalls binding while sleeping and in the shower:
It was extremely unhealthy, yet at the time I was met with "Awwww I understand" and not "dude you can break your ribs wearing a wet binder." —scoutydouty, detrans female
Who supplies binders, including to minors
There are four main routes:
- Online retailers. Specialist companies sell binders by mail order. The Charity Commission for England and Wales noted that binders "can be bought without age limits" and that there is "no legal requirement" for parental consent (Charity Commission 2024).
- Charities and free-binder schemes. Some LGBT charities give binders away free or at reduced cost, so that young people do not use tape or bandages. Between January 2021 and September 2022 Mermaids issued 125 binders. It sent 24 directly to young people it judged to be "unsupported" at home, 15 of them aged 13 to 16. The Commission found that the charity had given "no advice ... on the possible psychological effects of wearing binders". It said that a charity supplying binders lends them "the authority of the charity's approval". Mermaids ended the service in October 2023. The full findings are on the Mermaids page.
- Friends and youth groups. Binders are passed between friends or ordered on someone else's behalf. One woman who ran LGBT youth groups at school before she desisted describes doing this:
I even ordered chest binders to my house for several young people so they could use them behind their parents back— I don't think any of them ended up actually transitioning but I know they wore those binders for at least a year each at around 15-16, which is really bad from a physical standpoint alone. —xxdiemadaboutit, desisted
- Parents and clinicians. Some parents buy a binder on the advice of a gender service or online support group, often as harm reduction. Gender clinics' guidelines discuss teaching young people about "the risks and benefits of binders ... and safe use", as England's Cass Review (2024 independent review of youth gender services) notes in passing. The Cass Review treats binding as part of social transition, which it says should be seen as an "active intervention" rather than a neutral act. It gives binding no separate assessment.
In a US online survey of 684 young people aged 13 to 24, most of those who bound had learned how to do it online and were not connected to any gender clinic or community centre. The mean age was 16 (Julian et al. 2021). For many teenagers, then, binding begins without an adult or clinician involved. Some detransitioned women now feel strongly about this:
Christ, this is why kids shouldn't have access to binders. It's so dangerous. —SnooCompliments8762, detrans female
The health research
Peitzmeier 2017: the Binding Health Project
The first large study was an anonymous online survey promoted through social media and trans community networks (Peitzmeier et al. 2017). It recruited 1,800 adults born female who had ever bound. Their median age was 23, and 68% lived in the US. About 80% described themselves as transgender and a third as genderqueer or agender. Most (86.9%) had not had chest surgery, though two-thirds wanted it. Just over half (51.5%) bound every day, for an average of 10 hours, and the median person had bound for two years.
Participants were asked whether they had ever had each of 28 symptoms and whether they put it down to binding:
| Outcome | % reporting (n = 1,800) |
|---|---|
| Any of the 28 outcomes | 97.2% |
| Any skin or tissue problem | 76.3% |
| Any pain | 74.0% |
| Back pain | 53.8% |
| Overheating | 53.5% |
| Chest pain | 48.8% |
| Shortness of breath | 46.6% |
| Itching | 44.9% |
| Bad posture | 40.3% |
| Shoulder pain | 38.9% |
| Breast tenderness | 33.9% |
| Acne | 33.8% |
| Lightheadedness or dizziness | 27.8% |
| Breast changes | 27.5% |
| Fatigue | 27.2% |
| Numbness | 15.7% |
| Rib or spine changes | 11.6% |
| Scarring | 7.7% |
| Skin infection | 5.3% |
| Rib fractures | 2.8% (50 people) |
After adjusting for other factors, how many days a week someone bound was linked to more outcomes (22 of 28) than anything else. The number of years spent binding was linked to 13, mostly skin and musculoskeletal (bones, joints and muscles). Larger breasts were linked mainly to skin problems. The number of hours per day was, unexpectedly, linked to few outcomes once other factors were taken into account. The authors suggest this may be because people who develop symptoms cut back on their hours.
The same survey found large mental-health benefits. On a 1 to 5 scale, average mood rose from 2.1 without binding to 3.8 with it, and the share rating their mood "positive" or "very positive" rose from 7.5% to 69.9%. In free-text answers participants described less anxiety, dysphoria and suicidality. The authors advised clinicians to help patients reduce harm, by recommending days off and avoiding tape and bandages, rather than to advise against binding outright. They also suggested referral for chest surgery as a way to "limit the duration of binding".
Limitations. The sample was self-selected through trans networks, so it cannot show how common these effects are among everyone who binds. Every outcome was self-reported and self-attributed: no one was examined, X-rayed or given a lung-function test. Mood was measured in one sitting, by recall, while participants were still binding. The sample excluded under-18s. Because recruitment ran through trans networks, people who had stopped binding and left those communities, such as detransitioners, were probably under-represented.
Later studies
- Time to first symptoms. Reanalysing the same 1,800 responses, Peitzmeier et al. (2021) estimated when symptoms first appeared. Over half had begun binding by age 21, and 30% by 18. For 18 of 27 symptoms, most people who got the symptom got it within the first year of binding. Pain appeared fast and kept rising, peaking after more than five years. Skin damage and rare serious outcomes such as rib fractures took longer. The authors concluded that puberty blockers "may delay initiation of binding". In other words they saw drug suppression of breast growth as one way to avoid binding harms.
- Adolescents. The Julian et al. (2021) survey of 684 people aged 13 to 24 came from the Children's Hospital Los Angeles gender clinic team. Those who bound reported being misgendered less often. Higher chest dysphoria (distress about the chest) went with lower life satisfaction. The authors concluded that young people "will continue to bind" and that parents and clinicians need better education to support them. The study did not report physical harms in detail.
- Reviews. A 2024 scoping review found that little is known about binding outcomes despite its long history (Pehlivanidis & Anderson 2024). A 2025 systematic review pooled 18 studies of binding and genital tucking (3,235 participants). It described a trade-off between physical risks and psychological relief, and called for research on long-term effects (Bumphenkiatikul et al. 2025).
What is not known
No study has:
- followed people who bind over years with physical examinations, imaging or lung-function tests
- compared binding adolescents with similar adolescents who do not bind
- measured whether binding during puberty changes how breasts develop
- studied breastfeeding after binding
- asked whether binding strengthens, weakens or leaves unchanged a young person's gender distress over time
- included people who stopped binding because they stopped identifying as trans
The evidence that binding relieves distress and the evidence that it causes physical harm come from the same kind of source: one-off surveys of current binders. Neither is strong.
What detransitioners report: ribs, breathing and pain
Detransitioned and desisted women's accounts match the survey's most common symptoms. They also describe effects that lasted after they stopped. These accounts are self-reports, and people cannot always tell binding apart from other causes such as posture, asthma or testosterone.
On breathing:
I bound my breasts every day for two years. My lung capacity is ruined and I can't take deep breaths anymore. —inmebed, desisted
i was nb and binding messed me up, i was binding starting at 12-13 when i was still growing, at least 10 hours a day every day. idk if it's bc of the binding but i have a very limited lung capacity now and it's hard to breathe in all the way :( —Few-Entrance-5090, desisted female
On ribs, including from people using purpose-made binders:
Even using a binder can be dangerous, I injured my ribcage using a binder that was too small. —cedle, detrans female
I've always had a small chest, but binding through puberty has made my ribs messed up and flared outwards. —imbibitionn, detrans female
Me as well. I started binding at 12. Wore binders to bed. I have rib problems and I don't think my chest fully developed either. —kaleice, detrans female
A few describe nerve pain, which the survey counted as "numbness" (15.7%). One woman says it continued more than six months after she stopped:
I was prepared for potential back issues and potential damage to my breast tissue back when I was binding, none of that is a good thing at all of course but I justified it in my head and I wish that was all that happened because I was not expecting to develop severe neuropathy in my arms chest and hands. —taintedmoondust, desisted female
Others describe back and shoulder damage and bruising under the arms. Several advise anyone with lasting rib or breathing symptoms to see a doctor, and to describe the garment plainly, because not every clinician knows what a binder is.
Breast tissue and breastfeeding
Effects on breast tissue
The survey's "breast changes" (27.5%) and "breast tenderness" (33.9%) were not defined further. Surgical papers cited by Peitzmeier describe skin excess, ptosis (sagging) and reduced skin elasticity after long-term binding. Surgeons say these can worsen the results of a later mastectomy. No study has measured breast shape or development in people who bind.
Detransitioned and desisted women fill some of this gap with their own experience, and their accounts vary. Some describe lasting change:
Binding stretched my skin and damaged the tissue in my breasts so now I have non-cancerous lumps that make it very hard for me to check for cancer. —inmebed, desisted
I had a small chest before binding, however after I started it basically became malformed and now I feel a hundred times more dysphoric than I was before I started binding. It gives momentary, short-term relief but irreversibly damaged your body afterwards. —ThrowawayAccountXYKZ, questioning
Several believe that binding through early puberty limited how their breasts grew:
I wasn't on HRT thanks to (god bless) my parents, but I binded through puberty and stunted my boob growth —Disastrous-Topic-450, desisted female
Others in the same threads doubt this. They point out that compression stretches skin and ligaments rather than stopping glandular growth, and that small or low-set breasts are common in women who never bound:
As far as I'm aware, the reason people sometimes have breast shrinkage after long-term binding is because the ligaments and skin stretch out due to the force of compression, causing the breasts to sag. It doesn't reverse the growth of tissue, it just makes it softer and less self-supporting. —throwawayvoicecracks, desisted female
One woman who bound heavily from 13 to 15 says her breasts seem normal now:
But now, as an adult, I'd say my breasts seem to be normal? For reference, they're on the larger end of "average" size, and nothing about them would suggest they were damaged. —joan_train, desisted female
No one can yet say which experience is typical or why they differ. Age at starting, tightness, hours, breast size, weight change and testosterone use probably all matter. Testosterone itself thins breast tissue (see testosterone in females).
Breastfeeding
No study has looked at whether binding affects later breastfeeding. The nearest evidence is indirect:
- Binding during lactation. Tight breast binding was once used to stop milk after birth. A 2003 trial in 60 non-breastfeeding mothers found it caused more pain and leaking than a support bra, and recommended that it stop (Swift & Janke 2003). This shows that compression affects the lactating breast. It says nothing about binding years earlier.
- Transmasculine parents. An interview study of 22 transmasculine people who had given birth included one person who bound while lactating and reported no drop in supply. The authors noted that clinicians know little about lactation and binding (MacDonald et al. 2016).
Detransitioned women who bound but kept their breasts sometimes describe breastfeeding as an unexpected relief:
Not quite the same since I never went on T but since binding for years, now that I have a child and am breastfeeding it's such a relief that I CAN do that, sometimes it hurts and I have issues like clogged ducts but I'm just so grateful to be capable of it. —novaskyd, desisted female
Breastfeeding is mainly lost through surgery, not binding. The mastectomy page covers the grief over lost breastfeeding that some detransitioned mothers describe, including the published case report by Gribble et al. 2023. See also fertility.
Binding as a step towards mastectomy
Binding and mastectomy are usually linked in gender medicine. Binding is treated as the interim measure until surgery. Surgery is then presented as the way to end the harms of binding.
- A 2018 survey from the Children's Hospital Los Angeles clinic compared 68 transmasculine young people aged 13 to 25 who had had chest surgery with 68 who had not. Chest dysphoria scores were far lower after surgery (3.3 against 29.6 out of 51), and 94% of those without surgery rated it "very important". The paper describes binding as an interim strategy with negative health effects (Olson-Kennedy et al. 2018). The study is cross-sectional, with a short follow-up and no measure of later detransition.
- An interview study of 30 young people aged 13 to 21 at a Philadelphia gender clinic described chest dysphoria as "functionally disabling" (Mehringer et al. 2021).
- Peitzmeier 2017 suggested that referral for surgery could reduce the harms that come with years of binding.
- A 2024 systematic review found only two studies that directly compared mastectomy with continued binding. Both gave very low-certainty evidence on gender dysphoria (Miroshnychenko et al. 2024).
The argument runs: binding is harmful, so surgery should come sooner. Detransitioners point out that it leaves out a third option, which is stopping binding without surgery. It also does not ask whether binding itself feeds the distress that surgery is meant to treat. The transition pipeline page describes how each step makes the next one feel natural. Binding is often the first physical link in that chain.
Some detransitioned women describe the link in personal terms. One explains how the damage she believed binding had done changed her thinking about surgery:
Before my top surgery I remember thinking, "well I've damaged them from binding anyway, so they aren't nice/will never be nice so why not cut them off" like I wonder if I would have not done the surgery if I didn't feel already very physically damaged as a teenager from binding. —ughhhhfuckthishit, detrans female
Another went from binding to mastectomy within three years and later wished she had chosen a breast reduction:
I had a full on mastectomy at 16 after binding for like 2.5 years and the skin looked so wack before they did the procedure.. I've since gotten breast implants after detransitioning but nowhere near the size of my OG breasts. I often times wish that I'd just had a reduction and continued on so that's mainly why I bring it up. —DEVlLlSH, detrans female
Does binding make chest distress worse?
Several detransitioned women describe binding as a cycle. Binding brings relief, but taking the binder off then feels worse than before, so they bind more and want surgery more:
Honestly I agree with the idea that binding over time will make chest dysphoria worse, it's like one of those sales ploys where they give you a demo of a product knowing you'll get hooked. —DetransIS, detrans intersex female
Yeah binding made my breast dysphoria worse too since I'd see how I wanted my body to look and then have to take off the garment and compare. After I stopped binding I started to accept my natural body more and more to the point I actually like having breasts. —Lurkersquid, detrans female
Some went further and felt that binding made them "more trans". One woman says anxiety stopped her from binding, and that this may be why she left a trans identity:
I definitely think there's some truth to the idea that binding can, for lack of better phrasing or explanation, make afab people feel more trans than they would otherwise feel. I do think it had that effect on me, but because I couldn't bind I got out of it. —UndercoverUrsine, questioning
No study has tested this. Peitzmeier's mood finding compares mood with and without the binder while people are still binding. It cannot show whether the unbound baseline gets worse over months of binding, which is what these accounts describe. Similar arguments about "identity lock-in" are made for social transition in general (see social transition).
Why some girls bind
Detransitioned and desisted women give several overlapping reasons for having bound. Many say that at the time they read their discomfort as proof of being male, and only later understood it differently. The internalised misogyny page covers the wider pattern. This section sets out how it shows up around the chest.
Discomfort with puberty
Breast growth is often the first visible sign of puberty in girls and can feel sudden and public. Some women recall reaching for binding before they had heard of it:
I remember being hideously embarrassed when my left breast popped up and the right stayed flat. Didn't know at the time that it's a fairly common occurrence. I tried to flatten it down by winding tensor bandages around my chest, hoping that no one would notice, praying that the right one would catch up. —feminotorious, woman who never transitioned
When I hit pre-puberty and puberty, being trans was not a thing, yet I still wanted to cut my tits off. I thought they were disgusting and weird looking and positioned strangely on my chest and too small. I hated everything about my new body shape. —Net_Negative, desisted female
The second writer, now almost 30, says her distress eased by her mid-20s and that she now accepts her womanhood. Studies of children referred for gender distress have found that it often resolves through puberty when there is no social or medical transition (see desistance). See also puberty and the sudden body.
Sexual attention
Many detrans women name unwanted sexual attention, often from adult men and starting before their teens, as what made their breasts feel like a problem:
Truth. Maybe if men didn't start to ogle me at like 10 I wouldn't have felt the need to remove them as a teenager. —SnooCompliments8762, detrans female
For real, I also hated my chest, but I realised it was mostly because it was like having a target on my back regarding sexualisation —cheerlessThinker1122, desisted female
I used to think this was dysphoria too, but I think I just don't want people looking at my sexual bits. I don't even feel discomfort about having boobs, I just don't want people to see them. —lowrcase, desisted female
For some, the attention followed sexual abuse, and breast growth felt like a renewed threat (see trauma). One desisted woman, replying to a girl who said she felt "sexualised walking around without being binded", made the distinction this section turns on:
Your post makes no mention of HRT or surgery, no desire to have facial/body hair or a deep voice, no "bottom dysphoria" or even "top dysphoria" (not wanting to be sexualised is different from not wanting breasts at all). —DraftCurrent4706, desisted female
Being read as female
Some say the problem was not the breasts as such but what they signalled to other people:
When I started out I didn't hate my boobs at all, but as time went on and they identified me as female to onlookers I wanted a binder/ top surgery more and more. —pretty_cool_bananas, desisted female
Community norms and suffering
A few describe pressure inside trans online spaces, where enduring binding showed how real one's dysphoria was:
But the fact that i didn't wear it that often made me feel self-conscious like "oh my dysphoria must not be as bad as so and so cause they wear a binder 24/7 and i only wear one once in a blue moon". I internalized this idea that to be "trans" is to suffer. —Space-A1ien, detrans female
Others see binding being presented to girls as a fun or empowering choice rather than a risky one (see social contagion and peer influence). Some also link binding to body-image problems more broadly, such as wanting to look thinner or flatter (see body dysmorphia and eating disorders).
Gender dysphoria
Some detransitioned women do describe intense, long-standing distress about their chest that they still regard as dysphoria. They often say binding was the only relief they had, even if they now see that distress differently. In these accounts the distress was real. What they question in hindsight is the meaning they gave it and the response they were offered. The reframing dysphoria page explores how detransitioners reinterpret this.
Detransitioners' reflections compared with trans men's accounts
Trans men and detransitioned women often describe the same physical experience of binding. They differ in what they think it was for and whether it was worth it.
| Question | Trans men often say | Detransitioners often say |
|---|---|---|
| Why bind? | To relieve chest dysphoria and pass as male | To escape puberty, sexual attention or being seen as female; later reinterpreted |
| Was it worth the harm? | Yes: a survival measure until surgery | Often no: harm without lasting relief, or relief that fed the problem |
| Did it make distress worse? | Sometimes a reminder of the chest, solved by tape or surgery | Sometimes a cycle that was solved by stopping |
| What is the end point? | Top surgery | Stopping binding, sometimes without surgery |
Worth the cost, or a cost without a return?
Trans men's strongest case is that binding was the lesser harm. One describes lasting breathing problems as the price of staying alive until surgery:
Honestly I binded my chest for 13 hours a day 7 days a week for 3 years instead of committing suicide until I got top surgery. I still have breathing issues a year later but I don't regret it because I did what had to do to survive. —DryAbbreviations7357, trans man (FTM)
I don't regret it, because I wouldn't have gotten through those years without it (even though my chest was hideable too.) Now my ribs are a bit wonky. —isbrealiommerlin, trans man (FTM)
This matches what Peitzmeier's participants said: the benefits outweighed the physical harm. Detransitioned women often describe similar harm, but without the same sense of return, because the identity it served did not last. One desisted woman who developed nerve pain put it plainly:
... I wish so much that I didn't set myself up to be in so much pain and agony. —taintedmoondust, desisted female
The difference does not show that either group is wrong about its own experience. It shows that whether binding is "worth it" depends on a future that a 13-year-old cannot know.
A reminder of the chest
Both groups describe binding as a constant reminder of the body it hides. Some trans men say so directly:
binding just gets old after having done it for so long since atp i just want these things on my chest gone 😭😭😭 binding just reminds me that i have tits —vampirepunk06, trans man (FTM)
it felt suffocating. i couldve maybe gotten used to it but it also felt like a constant sensory reminder of my dysphoria .. and it didn't give me the "look" i was going for anyways? —amoe-ba, trans man (FTM)
Both of these men conclude that surgery is the answer. Detransitioned women who describe the same feeling, such as the accounts in the section above, concluded that the answer was to stop binding. Some trans men also report that their distress eased with time and testosterone, so that they bind only occasionally. That suggests chest distress is not fixed for them either.
Sensory warnings
A recurring detrans theme is that the body resisted binding at first, and that this was overridden:
I remember almost having a panic attack the first time I was wearing a binder in a situation where I couldn't just take it off, and it began to feel so suffocating. I made myself power through it, though, and eventually having the binder on was soothing rather than anxiety-inducing. I probably should have listened to those early warnings from my body and mind! —siren-sigh, detrans female
Stopping binding and recovering body comfort
Detransitioned and desisted women describe stopping binding as harder than expected. Their accounts suggest that both the body and the sense of being comfortable in it can recover, though often slowly and not always completely. For the wider process, see healing and recovery and social detransition.
Stepping down gradually
Several describe stepping down in stages rather than stopping overnight. They moved from a binder to layered sports bras, then to a single sports bra, then to loose clothing:
Basically, over time, I tried to decrease my "level" of binding by alternating different methods, spending more and more time at lower levels of binding until I was at nothing. This doesn't just include full physical breast binding, also things like the types of shirts you wear and number of layers. —imbibitionn, detrans female
The same woman had bound almost 24 hours a day for two years. It took her more than a year to stop, and she found the first time out unbound "absolutely terrifying". Others suggest starting with physical activity, where a sports bra makes breathing easier, and paying attention to what the body can do rather than how it looks:
Exposure and training your brain to focus on other things basically. I bring up physical activity because I find focusing on what my body can do and seeing progress there as opposed to how it looks is very helpful for dysphoria —writteno, detrans female
These approaches resemble exposure therapy, a standard treatment for anxiety in which a person gradually faces a feared situation until the fear fades. Some women also stopped comparing their bodies with men's, and stopped looking at images of mastectomies and transition online.
Physical recovery
Accounts of breast recovery vary. Many describe partial recovery over one to two years:
My boobs have definitely recovered a fair amount since I stopped binding, but it took about two years to notice a difference. —AngelCrumb, desisted female
Yes I had little pancakes after binding for 4 years. They did fill back out with time. —scoutydouty, detrans female
One woman who had also taken testosterone describes substantial recovery after stopping it:
My breasts were very damaged by testosterone for 3 years and binding for 5 years. They were small and saggy and looked like gynecomastia, they didn't look right. After a year and a half of estrogen they have grown... a LOT.. regained elasticity, they perk, my chest is full and normal looking. —ali-pal, detrans female
Others report little change and have learned to live with it. Common practical advice in these threads is: wear a well-fitted, soft, supportive bra or none; build upper-body muscle; regain lost weight if underweight; and remember that breast shape changes across the menstrual cycle and with age. Some found their ribs and posture improved after stopping. Others were advised to see a physiotherapist or orthopaedist, or found swimming helped. Anyone with persistent breathing difficulty, rib pain or numbness should see a doctor.
Learning to live with the chest again
Getting used to the physical sensation of an unbound chest can take months. Some say discomfort that once felt like dysphoria turned out to be partly a matter of habit, and that softer garments helped:
Sports bras and bralettes have been a savior to me. I have much larger, saggier breasts so at times it isn't the most flattering, but they're so much more comfortable. —anarchistparakeet, detrans female
Some warn that a binder kept "just in case" can pull them back:
I would like to be flat again sometimes, like I could imagine binding once in a while just for fun, but I think buying a binder would risk opening a door that leads me back to dependence and unhealthy ways of dealing with dysphoria. —catchbinkill, detrans female
Others found that being a masculine or butch woman needed no binder at all. They dressed as they liked and stayed female (see lesbian feminism and butch identity and gender stereotypes):
I did get rid of my binders though, because they were uncomfortable and made my ribs sore. Sports bras flatten me out enough and they don't impede my breathing like some binders did. —AbsentFuck, desisted female
For parents whose daughter wants to bind
Parents in r/detrans threads face a dilemma: banning a binder may drive a daughter to secret, more dangerous methods such as tape or bandages, but buying one may endorse the idea that her body is wrong. Approaches parents and detransitioned women suggest include:
- asking what exactly bothers her about her chest: its size, its visibility, being looked at, being read as a girl, or what it seems to mean
- offering alternatives first: well-fitted sports bras, compression tops, loose and layered clothing
- if she already binds, agreeing limits (never overnight, never during exercise, days off) and watching for pain, breathlessness or skin problems
- remembering that, in Peitzmeier's data, days per week of binding was the factor most consistently tied to harm
- finding therapy that explores the distress rather than treating binding as the start of a pathway (see gender exploratory therapy)
See also when your child says they are trans and social transition at school, which covers schools that let pupils socially transition without telling parents.
Related pages
- Social transition
- The transition pipeline
- Mermaids: binders, blockers and the charity inquiry
- Mastectomy (top surgery)
- Internalised misogyny
- Testosterone in females
- Fertility
- Desistance
- Reframing dysphoria
- Healing after detransition
- Study archive · Support directory
References
- Peitzmeier, S., Gardner, I., Weinand, J., Corbet, A., & Acevedo, K. (2017). Health impact of chest binding among transgender adults: a community-engaged, cross-sectional study. Culture, Health & Sexuality, 19(1), 64–75. source.
- Peitzmeier, S. M., Silberholz, J., Gardner, I. H., Weinand, J., & Acevedo, K. (2021). Time to first onset of chest binding–related symptoms in transgender youth. Pediatrics, 147(3), e20200728. source.
- Julian, J. M., Salvetti, B., Held, J. I., Murray, P. M., Lara-Rojas, L., & Olson-Kennedy, J. (2021). The impact of chest binding in transgender and gender diverse youth and young adults. Journal of Adolescent Health, 68(6), 1129–1134. source.
- Pehlivanidis, S., & Anderson, J. (2024). A scoping review of the literature exploring experiences in the trans and gender diverse community with chest binding practices. International Journal of Transgender Health. source.
- Bumphenkiatikul, T., et al. (2025). Non-medical gender affirming practices among transgender individuals: a systematic review on the health implications of chest binding and genital tucking. International Journal of Sexual Health. source.
- Olson-Kennedy, J., Warus, J., Okonta, V., Belzer, M., & Clark, L. F. (2018). Chest reconstruction and chest dysphoria in transmasculine minors and young adults: comparisons of nonsurgical and postsurgical cohorts. JAMA Pediatrics, 172(5), 431–436. source.
- Mehringer, J., Harrison, J., Quain, K., Shea, J., Hawkins, L., & Dowshen, N. (2021). Experience of chest dysphoria and masculinizing chest surgery in transmasculine youth. Pediatrics, 147(3), e2020013300. source.
- Miroshnychenko, A., et al. (2024). Mastectomy for individuals with gender dysphoria younger than 26 years: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery. study page, source.
- Swift, K., & Janke, J. (2003). Breast binding... is it all that it's wrapped up to be? Journal of Obstetric, Gynecologic, and Neonatal Nursing, 32(3), 332–339. source.
- MacDonald, T., et al. (2016). Transmasculine individuals' experiences with lactation, chestfeeding, and gender identity: a qualitative study. BMC Pregnancy and Childbirth, 16, 106. source.
- Gribble, K. D., Bewley, S., & Dahlen, H. G. (2023). Breastfeeding grief after chest masculinisation mastectomy and detransition: a case report with lessons about unanticipated harm. Frontiers in Global Women's Health. study page.
- Cass, H. (2024). Independent review of gender identity services for children and young people: final report. study page.
- Charity Commission for England and Wales (2024). Charity Inquiry: Mermaids. source.
Last updated:
Suggest an Article or an Improvement
Spotted something missing, unclear or wrong on this page, or have an idea for a related article? Let us know and we'll take a look.
Related pages:
- Names and Pronouns: Meaning, Effects and Going Back
Why a new name and pronouns can lock in an identity, what the chosen-name research shows, effects on families, pronoun law, and how detransitioners go back.
- The Transition Pipeline: From Social to Medical
How often social transition leads to blockers, hormones and surgery, why each step is easier than stopping, and detransitioners' accounts of the conveyor belt.
- Social Transition at School: Parents, Policy and Secrecy
School gender support plans, policies that keep parents uninformed, US court cases and laws, England's 2026 guidance, and what detransitioners report.
- Gender-Questioning Pupils: A Guide for Teachers and Staff
How teachers and school staff can respond to gender-questioning pupils: the evidence, legal duties in England and the US, parents, and pupils who desist.
- Social Transition in Young Children: Evidence and Risks
Social transition before puberty: how young children understand sex, the TransYouth Project and its critics, persistence, parents, and known risks.