Estas historias han sido resumidas usando IA.
En Reddit, la gente a menudo comparte sus experiencias a través de múltiples comentarios o publicaciones. Para hacer esta información más accesible, detrans.ai reúne todas esas piezas dispersas en un resumen y cronología únicos y fáciles de leer. Todos los prompts del sistema están documentados en la página de prompts.
A veces la IA puede alucinar o afirmar cosas que no son ciertas. Pero generalmente, las historias resumidas son reflejos precisos de los comentarios originales de los usuarios.
Historia completa
I don't have a personal transition or detransition story to tell — I never medically transitioned, and I've never posted my own account here. What I do have is a set of views I've developed over time, mostly formed by reading stories on this subreddit and by following the wider cultural conversation.
I've been taking a vitamin D supplement for an unrelated vitamin D deficiency, along with B12, which I credit with helping my depression immensely. I've also thought about bone health and calcium — someone suggested something like Ostelin (calcium plus vitamin D), and I figured I'd just eat more dairy and go outside more. I'm generally skeptical of health headlines; I found it amusing that an article basically said taking vitamin D supplements increases your risk of dying — from what, nobody said.
On the substance of what brings people here: I think the modern situation around gender identity is absurd. I've said things like "Welcome to the clown world we live in" and defended that as highlighting the absurdity of modern society rather than being political for its own sake. I'm skeptical of how the media frames these issues — I've noted that a conservative article being dismissed as "gosh darned right-wing transphobic propaganda" doesn't actually help anyone understand anything, and I've made the wry observation that I bet the "alt-right" drinks water too, meaning the label gets applied carelessly. I'm also critical of Planned Parenthood's role in this space — I said it was unsurprising coming from them.
I think it's reasonable that parents watching this culture emerge and affect their children feel apprehensive. Sometimes it seems like more and more people are identifying as trans, which makes me wonder how many are doing it purely to please their peers. My reasoning is that if dysphoria is something innate, like autism, its rate can't just shoot up — if the rate of children with autism started climbing, you'd start wondering what was in the water. I believe there are plenty of people on this subreddit who tried to transition or succeeded, only to realize their mistake and detransition, and I see that as strong evidence that many are being misled into thinking transition is right for them. Somewhere along the line the situation is being handled incorrectly, and I think it's fine to question and criticize it when people are being hurt in the process.
I've expressed hope that critical reporting gains traction so people become more informed about what they're doing. I find it scary that people who were abused or mentally ill when young may now be pushed by medical professionals and online communities toward permanently altering their bodies when they really just need someone to talk to about their past and come to terms with it. Mental health is incredibly important, and it's sad how much it gets ignored or downplayed. I've noted the irony that the WHO removed gender dysphoria from the category of mental illness around the same time it added "gaming disorder." I think the underlying problem, at least in the USA, is stigma around diagnosing, acknowledging, and treating mental illness correctly, plus accessibility — I have a friend who may have chronic depression or even bipolar disorder who can't afford treatment because his parents think he'll just "grow out of it" even though he's 23.
I've also pushed back on the idea that this subreddit should retreat to a less mainstream platform. I argued that it's better to have a foothold on a mainstream platform for the sake of awareness — if the sub moves to a new website, it will be used less and fewer people will learn of its existence. I'm wary of content being quietly suppressed; I've said of certain moderation or visibility practices that "it's always happening" and that the idea behind it is that you don't find out easily.
On masculinity and femininity, I've argued that you can be as feminine as you want and still be a man — pointing to James Charles, who wears makeup constantly and acts feminine but doesn't claim to be something he isn. I think that's a healthier model than identity claims. When someone posts a story here, I've cautioned other readers to keep in mind that one person's experience may not equal their own — different region, different culture, different time — and not to assume every story takes place in modern-day California.
I'm generally critical of transition as it's currently being offered, particularly to young people and to those whose real needs are unaddressed mental health care, but I hold that view as an observer and commenter rather than as someone who has personally detransitioned.