Estas historias han sido resumidas usando IA.
En Reddit, la gente a menudo comparte sus experiencias a través de múltiples comentarios o publicaciones. Para hacer esta información más accesible, detrans.ai reúne todas esas piezas dispersas en un resumen y cronología únicos y fáciles de leer. Todos los prompts del sistema están documentados en la página de prompts.
A veces la IA puede alucinar o afirmar cosas que no son ciertas. Pero generalmente, las historias resumidas son reflejos precisos de los comentarios originales de los usuarios.
Historia completa
I have been posting in gender-critical and detrans spaces on Reddit, and I want to be clear about where I stand. I identify as gender-critical ("gc") but I don't hate trans people personally. What I dislike is what I see as the toxicity of the trans community and how, in my view, it often tries to oppress women, lesbians and gays in the name of being "woke." Being trans doesn't fully make sense to me, but it makes more sense to me than identifying as hundreds of genders, and I have real respect for people who openly talk about abuses within the community.
My own background for why I can partly relate: growing up I felt weird about my race, nationality and religion — even as a tiny child I felt uncomfortable about it. I don't claim that experience is the same as gender dysphoria, but it's the closest parallel I have.
On the substance of the debate, my view is that the problem is the system, not the people — especially not individuals who aren't fueling the system. I think some people genuinely believe they're in the wrong body, but I believe they're a minority of self-identified trans people. My concern is that transition has become too easy: "woohoo i have lipstick, I'm a real woman!" If being trans involved intensive therapy, real consideration, and surgery eventually, I think most people would at least tolerate it. I'm moderate rather than extreme on this — there's a fair bit of stuff on gc I didn't agree with because I'm moderate.
A large part of my activity has been about Reddit moderation and censorship. When Reddit banned gc and other subs, I was frustrated because many hateful subs were left up — pro-rape and violence subs, incel subs, racist, sexist, misogynist, homophobic subs, and even actual transphobic subs — while the ones targeted were mild or even entirely inoffensive. I saw the ban as "nothing more than virtue signalling." I also noted that gc was heavily moderated and I had never seen a violent or hateful comment there, unlike many subs that were left up. I thought warnings should come first for something like gc if it were ever out of line, especially since something on the level of The_Donald had been "hateful vitriol for years" and only got quarantined that year. I named specific subs I believed were still up, including r/abuseporn and what I recalled as a misogyny-fetish sub, and a sub where would-be rapists told stories. My bigger worry was that there's "no trust anymore" and that the next wave of bans would hit "stuff like here and the lesbian subs."
I've also defended the authenticity of detrans stories against claims they're fabricated. I argued that a lot of the stories contain extremely detailed information that wouldn't be known unless you were trans or the parent/SO of someone who was. I described myself as "the kind of person these people use the T-slur for," and said that even if I had ill will towards trans people — which I don't — I wouldn't have that level of detailed knowledge. I also said there's "a certain edge" to the stories that's hard to fake, and that no matter how much is faked, there's some or a lot of truth. I warned that they should have a backup because "they've even been hijacking women's health subs, so I don't doubt somewhere along the line you guys are next."
I don't discuss any medical transition of my own in these comments, so I have nothing to report there. I'm supportive of detransitioners and critical of how transition is currently gatekept, but I hold a moderate, not blanket-anti-trans, position.