Todas las historias

Nunca transicionó, y se pasó 2023 argumentando en contra

Femenino · Desistió990
Estas historias han sido resumidas usando IA.

En Reddit, la gente a menudo comparte sus experiencias a través de múltiples comentarios o publicaciones. Para hacer esta información más accesible, detrans.ai reúne todas esas piezas dispersas en un resumen y cronología únicos y fáciles de leer. Todos los prompts del sistema están documentados en la página de prompts.

A veces la IA puede alucinar o afirmar cosas que no son ciertas. Pero generalmente, las historias resumidas son reflejos precisos de los comentarios originales de los usuarios.

Resumen

Soy una mujer destransicionada que nunca hizo una transición médica pero se convirtió en una crítica activa de la medicina de género juvenil y en una defensora vehemente de las personas destransicionadas en r/detrans en 2023. Argumenté que los menores no pueden dar su consentimiento a cambios hormonales y quirúrgicos casi permanentes, que los bloqueadores de la pubertad están insuficientemente probados y son potencialmente peligrosos, y que la transición no es una cura para la disforia. Usé el planteamiento truscum/tucute, fui escéptica con las afirmaciones de identidad no binaria y me opuse a la nueva terminología para la mayoría cis, aunque sigo apoyando los derechos legales de los adultos trans. Reconocí en otros, y posiblemente en mí, una disforia corporal durante la pubertad que se confunde con disforia de género y que, señalé, normalmente se supera. No relaté intervenciones médicas personales, diagnósticos de salud mental ni ideación suicida propia.

Historia completa

I was born female. I never transitioned myself, but I became deeply engaged with the r/detrans community in early 2023, writing extensively about hormones, puberty blockers, and the medical transition of minors. My own history with gender discomfort is something I recognise in others rather than narrate in detail here: I described knowing people I went to school with who were, I believed, experiencing body dysphoria that they had convinced themselves was gender dysphoria, and I noted that both body and gender dysphoria are common during puberty and that statistically you're likely to grow out of it. I also reflected on how, in a time when your body is changing, you dislike it, and your mental health starts to get worse, it's easier to be influenced — and I asked another commenter directly how they learned at age 12 what being trans is all about, whether anyone was pushing them, or whether they stumbled across it themselves. On hormones I was consistently cautionary: 'Testosterone isn't a fun hormone, and injecting it into you definitely will have it's bad effects.' I contrasted it with estrogen, which I read and saw as 'a lot more of a gentle hormone,' while still saying it can leave bad effects and advising people to look into what they're taking. I argued that many people transition in their twenties and that stopping puberty partway is not necessarily safe — it may be better to let it finish before taking other measures. I was openly skeptical of puberty blockers, citing possible FDA findings of blindness and brain swelling, the fact that the same medication is used to chemically castrate sex offenders, and the concern that five or ten years of research is not enough to establish long-term effects. I said plainly: 'I don't understand how anyone could think stopping an important process like puberty would ever be a good idea.' I posted one thread myself, asking detransitioners what they thought of Utah's new law banning gender affirmation care for under-18s. My own position was that regardless of how much dysphoria someone has or how long they've had it, if they're a minor they cannot consent — while allowing that consent ages should fluctuate by risk, as with dental care at 14 in the UK. I defined gender-affirming care critically as therapy 'designed to affirm, basically refusing to deny what the kids believe about their gender, and not showing other options other than that they're trans. Basically being yes men.' I worried that doctors can influence dysphoria and that dysphoria can also be faked, making the question harder than 'if they have dysphoria.' I was sceptical of transitioning minors 'especially with the way pharma works in the us' and noted European countries pulling some puberty blocker brands, while doubting the law's protective intentions but thinking it 'may have positive outcomes.' I reacted with shock to reports of a thirteen-year-old getting top surgery: 'I'm honestly surprised you got top surgery at thirteen. For something people are claiming only happens on the rarest of circumstances, it happens a lot!' I framed the issue as protecting rather than endangering trans kids: 'Nothing is reversible. We're not protecting or defending trans kids by letting them do this, instead we're endangering children who are going through gender dysphoria.' I was active in intra-community debates too. I used truscum/tucute terminology, saying 'Detransitioning is transphobia accord to tucutes' and defining tucutes as those who think you can be trans without dysphoria. I said non-binary as commonly described didn't make sense to me given the 'gender construct ≠ gender movement,' and I argued that if you make no effort to present as male or female you don't get to be upset about being misgendered. I described the obsession with labels, rules, and boycotting ideas as seeming like 'one big religion.' I was critical of what I saw as a rising number of females with gender dysphoria, wondering whether 'certain FTM activists' were preying on the body dysphoria of young women. I opposed new terminology for the majority, arguing trans people are a small minority and that 'non trans' needs no name, while still supporting laws and rights for trans people. I explicitly defended detransitioners: 'Posts like these are why I'm willing to defend detransitioners as much as possible... Even one detransitioner case should be enough to prove the harm of transitioning children.' I congratulated someone who had grown out of their dysphoria, saying it was great they were finally comfortable in their own skin, 'a euphoria which a lot of people who transition never really get.' I also told someone that transition is not a cure: 'It's a hard pill to swallow. But there is no cure. For some people, transitioning is enough to live with the dysphoria, for many, it's not. It's expensive, painful, and emotional, to try reach something you can't quite achieve.' On sexuality and dating I was encouraging to a man worried about his body, saying nothing to be ashamed of, that it's not uncommon, and that 'the day you find the woman who makes you feel good about it is when itll get a lot easier for you.' I added that many guys like butch girls, tomboys, or girls who are different or quirky. I was dismissive of idealised surgical photos, saying most pictures of surgeries aren't real and that learning to love the scars 'is a near fetish.' I did not describe undergoing hormones, surgery, or detransition myself, and I did not report a diagnosis, therapy, or mental-health crisis of my own.