Estas historias han sido resumidas usando IA.
En Reddit, la gente a menudo comparte sus experiencias a través de múltiples comentarios o publicaciones. Para hacer esta información más accesible, detrans.ai reúne todas esas piezas dispersas en un resumen y cronología únicos y fáciles de leer. Todos los prompts del sistema están documentados en la página de prompts.
A veces la IA puede alucinar o afirmar cosas que no son ciertas. Pero generalmente, las historias resumidas son reflejos precisos de los comentarios originales de los usuarios.
Historia completa
I am a licensed counselor — not trans myself — and I have been posting on r/detrans since early 2020 because I am concerned about, and a bit skeptical of, the wave of people newly identifying as trans. I like to be informed about all approaches to an issue as a therapist, and I have said this forum is excellent for that. Reading the stories here encourages me to be a better quality therapist.
From the start I have felt tremendous pressure to conform to trans-affirmative therapy. I would love to be allowed to explore my trans clients' stories in more depth and even challenge them some, but I risk lawsuits and my license if I engage in that type of therapy. I have listened as the Southern Poverty Law Center said at a conference I attended that they were in the process of "hunting down" therapists who don't conform — I found that chilling. I have only had a very few clients who identified as trans; I either referred out per the client's request or the therapy ended before I could address the trans issues. I would not do affirmative therapy if the situation arose. My preference is to work honestly with clients or refer, although I noted the ACA has ethical restrictions on referring clients on this issue. I have never caved to outside pressure on this because my ethical obligation weighs very heavily on me; it is more that I live with constant worry that I will be sued by clients. I have talked to my family about this possibility of lawsuit or loss of license and everyone has vocalized complete support of me following my conscience. So I care for my clients as they truly need, not how some bullies tell me to.
I have argued that we draw a false binary between "Affirmation Therapy" and "Conversion Therapy" — there are a myriad of other ways to approach therapy with the LGBT+ community, and bans tell therapists they can only do one type of therapy when the issue is transgender. I have also said the only ethical alternative I have seen is gender exploratory therapy, and that anyone seeking a therapist should screen for conversion therapy as well.
My interest in gender dysphoria and detransition began through studying under Mark Yarhouse through Sexual Wholeness (the Institute for Sexual Wholeness), which trains Christian counselors and psychologists to deliver ethical sex therapy as an alternative to AASECT. I am a therapist with Sexual Wholeness and I am trained in the gender exploratory model for clients with gender dysphoria. I am also one of the providers listed with the Gender Exploratory Therapy Association, which lists mental health professionals around the world who do not affirm and take a more neutral stance about gender identity; I have said I get tons of contacts all over the country regularly for this type of treatment, and they offer trainings and meetings. I have recommended Partners for Ethical Care and Thoughtful Therapists (UK/Ireland) as additional resources, and I have offered to DM people to help them find ethical help for their gender dysphoria. I have noted that most Christian counselors through the Institute for Sexual Wholeness are fully capable of providing excellent therapy to people who are not Christian, and that I have seen several clients from various religious backgrounds who found it a quality fit. I do not believe Christian teaching condemns gender variance — I have said the Christian Bible allows for a pretty wide variance of gender expression.
I have thanked members of this community for putting together research, noting that studies like it struggle to get funding from universities since they run contrary to the popular mantra, which makes them invaluable to professionals seeking to offer genuine help to questioners, desisters, and detransitioners. I have linked to the WPATH files and the Cass Report, arguing that gender affirmation treatments are not evidence-based, that WPATH members admit this in secret, and that one clinician noted informed consent isn't really possible with this vulnerable population. I have said clinicians who only do as asked by patients under the guise of informed consent are almost certainly committing malpractice. I have also argued that patients bear no responsibility in engaging in transgender medicine because informed consent was not secured — it couldn't be, I have said, because trans medicine is still experimental and there is no reliable research on long-term effects, and that I remain astonished that transgender medicine is allowed on anyone under age 25 when the frontal lobes have finally developed.
On a personal medical note: I am a natal female with a hormonal intersex disorder (a congenital condition) that caused hirsutism, and I have a lifetime's experience taking spironolactone for it. My doctors were mostly concerned with my congenital issues causing fertility problems; I do not recall them ever mentioning spiro impacting fertility. The lowest dose I have been on was 25 MG twice daily, and I am currently on a pretty high dose — 100 MG in the morning and 75 MG in the evening. It works and I do not want to come off it, though the effects are limited; I advise people not to think of it as the end-all-be-all for hirsutism but as support while dealing with unwanted hair growth, and to give it at least six months with an objective before-and-after measurement. I have noted it suppresses production and function of testosterone and will dampen sex drive, and that nothing traps you on it once you've begun.
I have never experienced gender dysphoria and testosterone has never been prescribed to me. I resonated strongly with a poster's line that our bodies are shrines — that just because you don't like the way it looks doesn't mean it's a bad body.