Estas historias han sido resumidas usando IA.
En Reddit, la gente a menudo comparte sus experiencias a través de múltiples comentarios o publicaciones. Para hacer esta información más accesible, detrans.ai reúne todas esas piezas dispersas en un resumen y cronología únicos y fáciles de leer. Todos los prompts del sistema están documentados en la página de prompts.
A veces la IA puede alucinar o afirmar cosas que no son ciertas. Pero generalmente, las historias resumidas son reflejos precisos de los comentarios originales de los usuarios.
Historia completa
I was born female and I am a very masculine, butch lesbian. I have experienced moderate sex dysphoria for years, and I describe myself as desisted rather than detransitioned — I never took testosterone, but I did bind close to daily for about two years, which caused permanent flattening of my breast tissue. I also had a breast reduction just over a year before mid-2020 specifically as a dysphoria-management measure; I was very open with my surgeon about the reason and was already reidentified at the time. The reduction was one of the best decisions I've ever made — I experienced roughly a 90% reduction in top dysphoria. However, less than a week after surgery I noticed I had started fixating on a new body part I might get 'just one surgery' on, which was a major wake-up call that the discomfort just shifts location, and it convinced me not to pursue any further interventions.
I never believed drugs and surgery could actually make me male, which helped limit the appeal of transition for me. My dysphoria has been much more what I'd describe as obsessive/compulsive than anything else. I have days where I'm fence-sitting about transition, but most of the time I understand that transition is a major medical intervention and that using it to address what is really an emotional problem would not be a good idea for me. I've weighed the options and the cons of transition simply do not outweigh the pros for me personally. I don't refer to myself as cis, but that's how I describe my situation when asked.
I think the roots of my dysphoria are mostly being gay and naturally extremely gender nonconforming, plus being someone who does well with fairly well-defined roles. There are loose threads I could tug at, like admiring an older male cousin a lot as a kid, but ultimately I think I'm the kind of very GNC person who was extra susceptible to falling for the idea that being very GNC and gay were indicators that I am something other than a woman — and that being something other than a woman was the cause of my differentness from most women. I had a long history of childhood identification with (not as) maleness. When I first became actively gender dysphoric, I really believed most women had some kind of gender identity — a sense of 'womanself' — that I lacked, and I saw my lack of it as further proof I wasn't a woman. I now think that belief was simply false.
Just running into the concept of gender dysphoria created an obsessive thought pattern in me that hadn't existed previously, even though I did have some discomfort with certain body parts and social expectations. I spent years looking for community in queer spaces before realizing we were either being pushed out for 'homosexuality crimes' or being pressured toward transition — and those kinds of spaces exacerbated the negative feelings around the things I was learning were part of me. I've had people I'd never discussed gender with ask me if I was going to transition, and at this point it's statistically a reasonable assumption for them to make given how I look.
What moved me toward desisting was largely reconceptualizing dysphoria — changing my understanding of it from a condition I suffer to a set of negative feelings I experience, often with flare-ups. I try to sit in the feeling and ask what brought it about, but I let myself experience it without catastrophizing or becoming obsessive about it. I moved from asking 'how do I fix this' to 'how can I learn to live with this pain,' which has been more helpful than anything else. I don't try to fix myself when I'm experiencing grief, so I shouldn't when experiencing dysphoria. No longer framing it as a matter of identity and letting go of the whole worldview where I was trying to find my term/label/box was most helpful. I gave up the notion of some magical internal difference between men and women that resides in the soul. The question isn't what you 'are' — it's what you want to do and be.
The purpose of desisting for me was twofold: first, to accept myself as the female person I will be until the day I die, and second, to free myself from the arbitrary and harmful notion that being female means I need to be a certain way. I don't own a single item of women's clothing and never have. I lift weights and keep some muscle, which is majorly helpful because it keeps me in touch with my body and my masculinity at the same time. I get bad dysphoria flare-ups when I need a haircut, so I prioritize that. Hiking and being out in contexts where I'm not thinking about my body in a gendered context also helps. Being open with close friends about preferring masculine terminology helps. I pass frequently as male, especially in winter, and I enjoy having that ability.
I've been in therapy for several months working on dysphoria specifically, without transitioning, and have found it helpful. I found my therapist through GETA (Gender Exploratory Therapy Association), which helped connect me with someone in my city who treats dysphoria the way she'd treat obsessive thinking, depression, or anxiety. I also reached out to IATDD a while back and found a therapist I liked. I'm by no means over gender dysphoria, but I find it less important in my life and I'm getting better bit by bit at dealing with flare-ups or upticks. Doing something that requires great concentration seems to help. I also like the podcast Gender: a Wider Lens, hosted by two adolescent therapists opposed to pediatric transition.
I lost about 80 lbs roughly 1.5 years before mid-2023, having been heavier my entire adult life. That alone made it very difficult to feel like I was in my own body — I'd literally never seen my adult face without a lot of weight on it. It took months, maybe a year, to feel like I was looking in the mirror and seeing myself, and about six months to recalibrate my sense of how wide my body was. That experience was somewhat comforting in helping me understand the weirdness and distress that can come with large body changes generally, independent of gender.
I have dealt with obsessive tendencies for years, which I recognize as a very common problem among people who experience gender dysphoria. I treat obsessive thoughts the way I'd treat any unhealthy thought pattern: try not to focus on them too much, don't shame myself for having them, and focus on what I'm currently doing and where I currently am. The vast majority of days I just don't think about it, and when I do fall into the pattern I don't get stuck in it for days or weeks. I also take prescribed stimulants for attention problems, which help me a lot with daily life, though I don't consider myself to be addressing a medical problem when I take them. I also have eczema.
I have experienced some difficulty with community. It's very upsetting how hard it is to find community with people like myself without being constantly exposed to practices that entice me but which I'm specifically trying to avoid. A lot of extremely GNC women are strongly drawn to the concept of transition, and there's really no winning: if you try to build community based on the shared experience of not transitioning, you're accused of hatred rather than simply trying to surround yourself with something positive for you. I've compared it to someone with a tendency to drink too much specifically seeking sober friends.
I have never taken testosterone and recently spent a week in a very conservative, religious country and chose ahead of time to simply pass myself off as male rather than deal with the potential scandal of people realizing I'm gay. I had no problems at all. I generally avoid women's bathrooms to avoid making other women uncomfortable, which is unfortunate because using them is my birthright, but I default to single-stall or gender-neutral bathrooms when I can find them. I think single-stall bathrooms that anyone of any sex can use, in addition to single-sex bathrooms, are the best compromise solution.
I have a good life right now with lots of hobbies and a nice career. I don't want to put myself at risk of medical complications from surgery or testosterone, and the idea of having to take something regularly simply to be myself annoys me — especially when I already have difficulty staying on top of treating existing medical issues. I think a lot of the problem with how we see dysphoria is that dysphoric people see it as a major life problem that needs to be fixed, when the source is at least not mostly internal. I think there's basically zero reason to believe dysphoria is innate, though I acknowledge we can't know for sure. I think a lot of us have a real investment in seeing dysphoria as innate because it allows us not to question where it came from.
I now think that dysphoria is a form of psychological distress, not a medical condition or disease, because there is no underlying physical pathology. I don't consider therapy for psychological distress to be medical treatment. I personally consider gender dysphoria, depression, and anxiety to be in the same category of distress, and I don't consider any of them to be 'illnesses,' despite having struggled with several of them moderately to severely at different times in my life. I think there needs to be much more research into coping mechanisms other than transition, since right now there really is none.
I have strong opinions about the current state of transition medicine, particularly regarding minors. I think parents who have concerns about whether medical transition is right for their child are told outright lies and functionally religious beliefs by medical professionals — that their child is more likely to kill themselves if they don't sign onto puberty blockers, and in some places they stand to lose custody if they don't go along with it. I think this is a self-feeding problem: the more queer spaces make clear they're not comfortable with female masculinity outside of transness, the more GNC women disidentify, which in turn makes it more likely people assume any GNC woman in a queer space doesn't consider herself a woman.
I believe transition is cosmetic surgery and hormones, not magic. I don't believe there is any inherent soul-level difference between someone for whom transition will work and someone for whom it won't — we simply have different approaches to the same struggle. I think the denial that autogynephilia exists at all, in the face of men who are open about experiencing it, is pure copium, though I think Blanchard's two-type theory came from an era that likely saw people transitioning for fewer reasons than now. I also think sexual attraction changes with exogenous testosterone are common enough to be a real side effect to consider.
I have never been married and have no children that I've mentioned. I have had difficulty dating as a butch woman, though I recognize that being very GNC is a niche interest and that some women are really into it. I have gay male friends. I have a good relationship with my family, though I haven't discussed them in detail.
I don't regret the breast reduction — it was extremely helpful for my dysphoria and I'd make the same choice again. What I do regret, in a broad sense, is the years I spent looking for community in queer spaces that were pushing me toward transition, and the time spent in the identity framework that I think made my dysphoria worse. The realization after my reduction that the discomfort just shifted to another body part was painful but ultimately clarifying. My dysphoria is not gone, but it is much more manageable now, and I have days where I barely think about it at all.