Todas las historias

Empujada por una amiga, sin disforia, y luego se la provocó ella misma

Femenino · Desistió687
Estas historias han sido resumidas usando IA.

En Reddit, la gente a menudo comparte sus experiencias a través de múltiples comentarios o publicaciones. Para hacer esta información más accesible, detrans.ai reúne todas esas piezas dispersas en un resumen y cronología únicos y fáciles de leer. Todos los prompts del sistema están documentados en la página de prompts.

A veces la IA puede alucinar o afirmar cosas que no son ciertas. Pero generalmente, las historias resumidas son reflejos precisos de los comentarios originales de los usuarios.

Resumen

Soy una mujer destransicionada/en desistimiento que solo hizo una transición social a una identidad no binaria y nunca tomó hormonas ni se operó. Una amiga trans femenina me empujó a la transición pese a no tener disforia previa, y la experiencia me dejó avergonzada y sintiendo que me había provocado yo misma la disforia. Tengo un extenso trauma sexual causado por agresoras y por una mujer trans a la que conocí durante una década, y me siento atrapada entre las comunidades críticas con el género y las activistas trans, que intentan influir en mis decisiones. Tengo una maestría en trabajo social y soy crítica con cómo se enseñan en el campo los estándares solo afirmativos. Actualmente me siento mal identificándome como no binaria/trans pero sigo incómoda con el materialismo rígido crítico con el género, y me preocupa perder amistades si abandono por completo la etiqueta trans o no binaria.

Historia completa

I was born female and grew up in the 1990s in a community where girls were encouraged to get dirty, play sports, and wear pants — girls who didn't enjoy those things got picked on for being 'girly girls.' I had a religious upbringing that gave me intense shame about being a lesbian. I was introduced to feminism when I was younger and really identified with it, but as I grew older I found myself dissatisfied with both main flavors of feminism. I have extensive sexual trauma from female abusers, which meant I never related to the idea of inherent safety in female-only spaces, and radfem spaces were not my jam. Sex-positive/third-wave feminism also fell short — the heavy focus on sexuality left me feeling awful, like I had nothing to offer anyone because I couldn't handle sexual stuff. My story was never the 'I assume women only get to be feminine, and I want to play football' narrative. I grew up very feminine and never resented it much until I realized I was a lesbian and was wholly uninterested in eventual pregnancy. The way people reacted to me not wanting to have sex with men OR have babies — they would've gotten the same point across if they'd literally said, 'But that's what you're for!' Feeling like my worth was limited to my capacity to provide sexual pleasure or have babies made it seem like opting out of gender as a concept would be better than fighting what felt like a losing battle to stop everyone from objectifying me. I was egged toward transition by a trans feminine 'friend' who would say that fitting feminine stereotypes made her more of a woman than I was. At the time, she'd only lived openly as a woman for maybe a month or two, but she'd accuse me of transphobia if I ever questioned her right to decide how I should understand my own gender. She made non-binary seem like a way to shirk my mother's expectations of me. In the back of my mind, I kept thinking, 'Obviously no one *wants* to look totally gender-ambiguous, right? We just have to because dysphoria.' This friend egged me to try on men's clothes and get a short haircut. When I did that, I felt so ugly. I only socially transitioned — I never started HRT — but the whole process felt like completely letting myself go/giving up on life. I didn't feel that sense of renewal and, 'This is me!' that my trans friends felt. Rather, I just felt gross and ashamed on a level that somehow surpassed my shame over being a lesbian. I now suspect that I actually gave myself dysphoria presenting this way. I never really experienced dysphoria prior to some 'friends' egging me. While I sometimes felt dysphoria and wanted a male form, I knew the male form I wanted was not achievable via HRT and surgery. Even after doing all that, I'd still be trans — I'd never be 100% the same as a cis man, and if my gender identity was so fluid, then surely I was gonna experience dysphoria whether I transitioned or not. The deciding factor was that not transitioning risked fewer complications than transitioning. I realized at one point that I personally have a better chance of learning to accept (if not love) my female body than I'd have accepting a transitioned-to-male body that would never be quite the same as a cis male body. The tipping point for me was realizing how much I hate being seen as trans, and then recognizing that most of my trans friends actually liked the changes they were seeing. Since most cis people don't understand what non-binary fundamentally is, I realized I'd rather be misgendered as female than let people think I was some type of 'not like other girls' situation. When I needed to get a face-to-face job, I basically gave up on non-binary in an 'I need to pick my battles' type way. I'd almost rather be dysphoric and miserable than have all my experience and feelings reduced to 'not like other girls.' I was abused by a trans woman I knew for a decade. The dynamic was complicated — there were elements of the 'guy who's friends with a lesbian' dynamic we had before she transitioned, as well as elements of the catty cis woman trying to outshine her best friend dynamic after she transitioned. She was someone who constantly lied about who she was to get what she wants — a pathological liar who emotionally, physically, and sexually harmed others. When I told my trans friends about this abuse, they got really nervous rather than supportive. When I talk about cis abusers, I never have to worry about friends saying, 'But think about how what you're saying might make her feel.' With my trans abuser, that's pretty much all I get. I was told my words could 'literally kill someone' if a trans woman heard me misgender my abuser. I have a master's in social work. We are trained to see affirming anyone who says they might be trans as a matter of social justice — we are told affirmation is in keeping with professional values, and anything else goes against those values. I hope the field can move toward leaving the agenda at the door. It's somewhat taboo in the field to suggest that any of the young people transitioning today might realize they're not actually trans in the future, or that social contagion might be a factor in the enormous uptick in youth requesting transition services. I'm not yet licensed and have mentioned wanting to get licensed 'once I'm a bit healthier.' I've been caught between two echo chambers — one where everyone who questions their gender is automatically trans and needs HRT, and another where anyone who questions their gender was simply a patriarchy-damaged fool acting against nature. I don't fully agree with either and am somewhere closer to center. I've hidden my doubts from certain friends; I truly think at least two people I'm friends with would stop trusting me completely if I turned out to be an 'evil scary cis lesbian' instead of a 'pure, wholesome non-binary person.' My friends almost *need* me to continue personally identifying as trans in order to still trust me. I still view sex and gender as separate yet related concepts, but that view is now considered problematic/transphobic. What's giving me pause about my non-binary identity is that I'm not cool with the way me sharing a subjective truth about how I experience myself is seen as completely overriding my sex to the point where I'm almost seen as ineligible to speak on issues female-socialized people face. I'm at a point where I feel all kinds of wrong identifying as non-binary/trans, but I'm also deeply uncomfortable with the staunch materialism of 'Your body is X, so that's all you can ever be.' I think I'm probably going to lose some friends if I don't retain some type of non-binary or trans label. I dislike the movement because of the fear mongering about suicide and how it's used to push people to make decisions they might not make otherwise. I also can't stand the way the cotton ceiling rhetoric has brought me back to square one in terms of shame surrounding my lesbianism — now I can no longer even use my orientation label to justify what I do and don't want. My current issue is the way the current movement has reinforced my shame over being a lesbian and left me feeling unsafe talking about being a lesbian in LGBTQ+ spaces. I've been active in detrans and questioning communities, engaging with debates about informed consent, gatekeeping, AGP, and the state of the trans movement. I've expressed concern about how quickly HRT is given in some cases and the potential risks of rushing into it. I've also discussed how porn addiction might contribute to some people suddenly thinking of themselves as gay/trans, referencing moral incongruence theory. I'm critical of both GC/RF ideology (which I don't vibe with) and uncritical trans activism, and I've advocated for nuance and for detransitioners being able to speak for themselves on their own terms.