Ces histoires ont été résumées à l'aide de l'IA.
Sur Reddit, les gens partagent souvent leurs expériences à travers plusieurs commentaires ou publications. Pour rendre ces informations plus accessibles, detrans.ai rassemble toutes ces pièces dispersées en un résumé et une chronologie uniques et faciles à lire. Tous les prompts du système sont documentés sur la page des prompts.
Parfois, l'IA peut halluciner ou affirmer des choses qui ne sont pas vraies. Mais généralement, les histoires résumées sont des reflets précis des commentaires originaux des utilisateurs.
Résumé
Je suis une femme qui a détransitionné — une lesbienne butch non conforme au genre, au début de ma vingtaine, qui a arrêté la testostérone après un peu plus de deux ans et ne regrette pas d’avoir transitionné. J’ai arrêté la T en partie à cause de la douleur physique et d’un traitement à vie, mais surtout par culpabilité d’avoir déçu d’autres femmes et par envie de cesser de cacher qui j’étais. Je garde ma voix plus grave, ma pilosité et ma taille, je n’essaie pas de passer pour une femme, et j’utilise surtout les vestiaires et toilettes pour hommes parce qu’on me chasse de ceux des femmes. Je suis très à gauche et frustrée que les personnes qui ont détransitionné ne puissent pas exister sans être politisées par l’un ou l’autre camp, et j’ai cherché une communauté détrans réservée aux femmes. Je subis un harcèlement continu en tant que lesbienne visiblement non conforme au genre en Écosse mais j’ai le sentiment d’avoir atteint une position de relative neutralité face à mon corps et à mon passé.
Histoire complète
I was born female and I'm a detransitioned, gender-nonconforming lesbian — I usually just call myself a butch woman now. I started socially transitioning around 14, in 2017, and began testosterone at 17, so I had just over two years of T before I came off it. I'm 20 now, and I don't have regrets about any of it. Transitioning was, in my words, "just part of my awkward teenage journey into new adulthood," and I wouldn't be where I am in terms of self-acceptance, politics, or friendships without it.
I came off T because I hated having to hide who I was — "just a butch lesbian" — in order to spin an internal sense of identity. It felt detrimental to have a me inside my head who differed from the me who simply exists. I also mention that T was causing me physical pain, and that being on lifelong medication wasn't ideal because I want to travel. A lot of it was guilt, too: guilt over letting down other women, guilt over my lack of female solidarity. I feel I have to detrans for womanhood reasons, which sucks but is no big deal compared to living forever in guilt. Dating "as a het man" when I knew I was basically a gay woman also sucked — I'd mostly date bi women who'd be offended when I acknowledged my sex.
I'm very chill with the changes T gave me. I have a deep voice, muscle tone, more body hair, and stubble — things I loved pre-T as a butch and still love. I'm 5'9", so I don't exactly pass as female unless I'm in a sports bra and nothing else, but I don't mind too much. I like my voice and I'm lazy about voice training; I don't care if I don't pass as female. I'm not going to be the same as a non-detrans woman and people just need to accept that. I kept my "male" name because I prefer it, and I still dress in men's clothes and act the same — the biggest change is just being she/herred and known as a woman. I also note that I greatly enjoy appearing male, which doesn't help, but I think we'll reach a point of neutrality in time.
Some things that fed into my transition: I never performed femininity because of sensory issues — I suspect overlap between autism/ADHD and transition because long hair, makeup, tight clothes, shaving, and skincare are all sensory hell. I was seen as "one of the boys" because misogyny says if you're not feminine you're not female, and I preferred boys' toys and boys' games. I honestly think that had a major part to play in why I thought I was "male inside." I also mention being a "warrior cats kid" growing up and that all my fellow warrior cats kids from childhood now have autism diagnoses. Realising I was female innately isn't why I detransitioned, but I can attribute sensory issues to a lot of things.
Binding was an issue: I used KT tape for about two of my five years of transition after binders messed up my ribs and back; the tape only gave me mild skin irritation. I also mention being AA-cup and living several years as a trans man without undergoing major surgery.
Changing rooms are a nightmare. I never wear a bra because I don't want to, so I feel unsafe in the men's, but I scare women in the women's. I've been chased out of women's toilets since I was 14 when I began socially transitioning (occasionally in 2017, common by 2019), and after starting hormones at 17 it became impossible to go in without being chased out — even when I had a fully female voice. I still use men's rooms. I've had security called on me before and it was not pleasant. I don't want to cause a scene or prove my sex to anyone.
On politics, I'm very far left and frustrated that one can't simply exist as a detrans person without being politicised — I'm expected either to be treated as entirely "cis" in left spaces or to wholly demonise transition in gender-critical spaces. I want a space to simply exist as a virilised woman without upholding an inner sense of identity. I've looked for female-specific detrans communities because chatting about female-specific issues with males feels tiring. I hung out in radical feminist spaces before detransitioning; they accept you're a woman but have an "okay... when will you detransition though" attitude. I'm not right-wing and don't think I'd be welcome there. I describe myself as "sorta neutral" on whether this sub is too anti-transition, though I hold strong views that sexed brain theory is debunked, that gender roles are socialised rather than innate, and that sports categories should be sex-based and gender abolished because it only harms women.
On sexuality and relationships: I'm a lesbian — "a dyke" — and I hang out at a few pride events at bars and clubs each year. I don't celebrate at parades. I plan to adopt and raise kids with a girlfriend rather than do "the normal thing." I cope with residual sex dysphoria by wearing at least a shirt during sex and focusing on my partner's pleasure over my own. I've experienced physical violence and sexual harassment growing up for being a very obviously gay woman I couldn't hide. I mostly get read as an effeminate man and called gay male slurs, and when I'm in a bra or bikini I get dyke and trans slurs. I live in Scotland. I was in an unhealthy but not abusive relationship where I associated staying with a male identity.
I don't have overwhelming regret or pain. There are downsides, but I can't see a reason to be sad about it. I'd tell others there's no rush — pausing medical transition is always an option, and re-transition remains possible if you change your mind.