Toutes les histoires

Arrêter de se présenter en femme, garder les œstrogènes

Masculin · Détransitionné·e509
Ces histoires ont été résumées à l'aide de l'IA.

Sur Reddit, les gens partagent souvent leurs expériences à travers plusieurs commentaires ou publications. Pour rendre ces informations plus accessibles, detrans.ai rassemble toutes ces pièces dispersées en un résumé et une chronologie uniques et faciles à lire. Tous les prompts du système sont documentés sur la page des prompts.

Parfois, l'IA peut halluciner ou affirmer des choses qui ne sont pas vraies. Mais généralement, les histoires résumées sont des reflets précis des commentaires originaux des utilisateurs.

Résumé

Je suis un homme féminin (détransitionné socialement), né homme, qui a détransitionné socialement en décembre 2023 mais a choisi de rester sous THS aux œstrogènes depuis environ fin 2023. Je me présente en homme en public et au travail, je n'impose pas de pronoms ni n'utilise d'espaces féminins, mais je garde le THS parce que je déteste les traits masculins et qu'il a considérablement amélioré ma santé mentale et mon confort corporel. J'ai un petit ami et je ne vois pas notre relation comme celle de deux hommes gays. J'ai répondu aux communautés de détransition qui mettent tous les détransitionnés dans le même sac ou m'envoient des messages privés pour essayer de me convertir à arrêter le THS. Je n'ai aucun antécédent d'idées suicidaires ni d'automutilation dans cette transcription.

Histoire complète

I was born male and I've always had gender dysphoria — being a man, having male anatomy, and filling the social role of a male disgusts me. I had a really great, strong father figure and a good mother in my life, so it's not that simple to explain away; I don't lack for supportive parents. I transitioned medically with estrogen. By December 2023 I was about two months in on E — I remember telling someone that "2m of E is nothing tbh." I never mention puberty blockers, and I've never had any surgeries. Around mid-December 2023 I socially detransitioned. I told everyone I was just an androgynous male and went back to my old name, stopped dressing as female or wearing makeup outside of private settings or special events. I did this because attempting to be a "pretend woman" had brought me far more pain than the few times people treated me as female. But I couldn't bring myself to stop HRT: I really didn't want facial hair again, rough skin, or body hair — all of that grosses me out. So I settled into what I'd call a partial or social detransition: I present male at work and in general society to keep things simple, but I stayed on estrogen. That leaves me in what I've described as a "weird andro middle ground." I still get gendered as a girl about as often as I get gendered as a man even though I wear men's clothes and never use makeup. I'm mostly okay with that now and have found peace in not worrying too much about how strangers perceive me, focusing instead on the people I love. At work I get confused for a woman frequently even when dressing masculine, and public bathrooms have become awkward because men often ask me to leave — but that's the price I decided to pay. Long hair and smooth skin seem to do a lot of the work. By early 2024 I'd found a lot of happiness in not worrying about labels. I have a boyfriend; he's one year older than me, extremely hairy, 6'4, muscular, with rough skin and a beard — he likes being masculine. I present male to him most of the time, though I told him he doesn't have to see me as a woman if he doesn't; he apparently does. I don't wear makeup for him or feel any need to pass in front of him. I only really put effort into presenting female on special dates when it's just the two of us. I don't see our relationship as a gay male one and he doesn't either; I take on a more feminine role in the relationship, and I've said I'll wear a wedding dress rather than a suit when we marry. I don't force pronouns on anyone — I don't think you can actually change gender and I don't want to be associated with that claim — but I tell people I trust or love, and they usually refer to me as she/her without me putting expectations on them. I've also said I'd rather not fake being a gay man either, because I don't get along with the gay men I know and find them performative. I know my approach to life is very unconventional, but it balances everything out for me. Mentally, HRT dramatically improved my mental health and I'm much more comfortable in my body now. I can look in the mirror and be happier with myself, and I can dress femininely without looking "stupidly uncanny." I compared it to a cyst I had on my face as a kid: my original doctor refused to remove it, saying cosmetic surgery on a child's face was wrong, but eventually I went private and had it removed — I'm incredibly thankful, no one sees it and I never had to deal with it again. That's how I think about body modification: if you hate something and it's easy to fix, fix it. I've said I want a lip lift and possibly FFS, and I accept the health risks of staying on HRT as risks worth taking, comparing myself to a cis male friend of mine who takes steroids. I do "malefail" a lot, which makes me happy, but I don't consistently pass in "boymode" — I only pass when I go all out with makeup, clothes, and mannerisms, which is too much effort for every day. I found estrogen gave me breast growth that took years to fill out and was pretty puffy to begin with; on my chest they look "normalish" if I were presenting as a woman. I've warned others that taking HRT temporarily isn't smart and that most people shouldn't take it, since going off it likely means losing the fat that gives breasts shape. On the wider detransition community, I've pushed back hard. I got multiple DMs from people telling me all I needed was therapy, to accept being more masculine, to go off HRT, and to never get FFS. I found that rude — people change their bodies all the time for cosmetic reasons and no one has the right to try to convert me. I've complained that this group has a massive problem of lumping everyone together: "ALL DETRANS HAVE TRAUMA," "ALL TRANS PEOPLE TRANSITION FOR A FETISH," "HRT IS EVIL MEDICAL MALPRACTICE." I've also said I think a lot of accounts here are throwaways with no post history that just want to signal hatred of trans people rather than actually discuss detransition. I've said I don't care about the reasons some women here say I should detrans — that I'm "a liar to society" — because if I passed consistently I wouldn't care. I've also expressed some critical views of certain trans communities: I've said wanting to claim lesbian status is "a little weird" when you don't pass, that transbian couples aren't really like lesbian couples because of male socialization, and that trans women who want to be in lesbian spaces would be better off with their own spaces — calling the demand that cis lesbians accept them "a bit creepy." At the same time I've said people don't really have the right to tell others what their sexuality is, and that labels don't matter that much — just love who you love. On gender I've said it's legally defined and can't simply be self-identified. I've also noted that social contagion is an element among women, and that there isn't much social incentive to be a woman — you lose friends and family, so it takes real commitment. I've said trying to be extra progressive around gender actually hurts more trans people. I've dealt with jealousy of cis women who get to freely express femininity while I feel trapped; when that happens I log off, take an internet detox, and focus on hobbies or work. I've advised others not to compare themselves to anyone and to take breaks from the internet. Current status: I identify as a feminine male who has socially detransitioned but remains on estrogen. I don't use female spaces, don't force pronouns, and present male publicly, while continuing HRT for its effects on my body and mental health.