Toutes les histoires

Une victime de faute médicale qui a voté Kamala — et se méfie des porte-paroles détrans

Féminin · Détransitionné·e390
Ces histoires ont été résumées à l'aide de l'IA.

Sur Reddit, les gens partagent souvent leurs expériences à travers plusieurs commentaires ou publications. Pour rendre ces informations plus accessibles, detrans.ai rassemble toutes ces pièces dispersées en un résumé et une chronologie uniques et faciles à lire. Tous les prompts du système sont documentés sur la page des prompts.

Parfois, l'IA peut halluciner ou affirmer des choses qui ne sont pas vraies. Mais généralement, les histoires résumées sont des reflets précis des commentaires originaux des utilisateurs.

Résumé

Je suis une personne détransitionnée aux États-Unis qui regrette farouchement sa transition et se considère comme une victime de faute médicale. J'ai voté pour Kamala et je suis de gauche politiquement, alarmée par les politiques de l'administration Trump sur l'immigration, le commerce et la santé, qui menacent selon moi tout le monde. Je suis très critique de porte-paroles de la détransition très médiatisés comme Chloe Cole, Maia Poet et Laura Becker, devenus des figures alignées sur le MAGA et financées par de l'argent opaque, et je plaide pour des voix de détransition plus modérées et politiquement diverses. Mon passeport a été retardé sous la nouvelle administration, et j'ai écrit des guides de sécurité pour les personnes détrans qui s'engagent dans le plaidoyer juridique et les manifestations contre des projets de loi punitifs.

Histoire complète

I am a detransitioned person living in the United States who fiercely regrets my transition and considers myself a medical malpractice victim. I voted for Kamala in the 2024 election and identify politically as someone left of the current Republican administration, though I try to be realistic about politics rather than idealistic. I first became alarmed about the political direction of the country after Trump took office in 2025. My heart sank when I saw that 100 detransitioners signed a letter supporting RFK's confirmation, given RFK's dangerous ideas around autism and psych medication access, including disturbing comments about 'reparenting' organic farm work camps. I have always thought 'trans genocide' claims were absurd, but I take seriously the possibility that people in power could enact forced labor policies. I am deeply frustrated with the current detransition spokespeople. Chloe Cole and Maia Poet are being openly unhinged in public, and Laura Becker uncritically worships Jordan Peterson. I think Maia was a gender non-conforming woman when she started speaking out, Laura is 'legitimately a weird person' and a case study in esoteric fascism tied to the US hippie movement, and Chloe comes from a well-off financial background and didn't used to be like this. I remember Chloe's online presence being incredibly normal at one point. I believe these spokespeople have been corrupted by dark money from parent and religious groups and went nearly directly from the trans community into MAGA stardom. They need to learn humility and I question if they understand how average middle-class Americans live. I am alarmed that complex personal issues around biology and gender have been used to manufacture consent for government overreach, including potential famine through deporting agricultural workers and angering trade allies, threats to OSHA and unions, and attacks on abortion access. I think trans/Detrans topics should never have been allowed to take center stage nationally, and I'm frustrated that liberals kept shoving trans issues into every cause as the primary focus for at least a decade while also being alarmed by the right-wing backlash. My passport has been delayed or messed with under the new administration, and I've been trying to find safe, reasonable legal advice. I reached out to the ACLU and was waiting to hear back. I was frustrated with their initial response but appreciated when they updated their guidance. I am critical of dangerous advice circulating in trans spaces, especially around doctoring legal IDs, which I believe would make any legal case much harder. I wrote an unofficial safety guide for detrans/desisted people participating in protests against Republican bills in the US. I believe people should lobby their reps directly through legal means, that you don't have to disclose your personal medical history to be a valid citizen advocate, and that crowd safety is the top priority. I encourage people to connect with local nonprofit leaders and leave immediately if things get dangerous or could result in felony charges. I believe many detransitioned people foresaw a wave of regret and mixed results coming, and recognized that social service infrastructure was not remotely equipped to handle it emotionally, medically, or financially. I think some tried to defuse this through gentle means - not agreeing with everything the trans community does, but not wanting to criminalize or control others unduly. I am concerned that delaying and denying resources to detransitioners will only cause more radicalization, and that both grassroots and astroturfed forces are eager to exploit socially isolated, desperate detransitioners in a larger political battle. I am generally supportive of legal advocacy and lobbying but cautious about protest safety. I am critical of both extreme right exploitation of detransitioners and extreme left dismissal of our concerns. I believe in political diversity among detransition advocates and wish more moderate voices were heard.