Ces histoires ont été résumées à l'aide de l'IA.
Sur Reddit, les gens partagent souvent leurs expériences à travers plusieurs commentaires ou publications. Pour rendre ces informations plus accessibles, detrans.ai rassemble toutes ces pièces dispersées en un résumé et une chronologie uniques et faciles à lire. Tous les prompts du système sont documentés sur la page des prompts.
Parfois, l'IA peut halluciner ou affirmer des choses qui ne sont pas vraies. Mais généralement, les histoires résumées sont des reflets précis des commentaires originaux des utilisateurs.
Résumé
Je suis un homme gay féminin né garçon qui, pendant une longue période, a pensé être en réalité une fille et voulu transitionner, mais qui n’a jamais pris d’hormones ni fait de transition sociale, se contentant de se travestir de temps en temps. J’ai fini par réaliser que je suis juste un homme gay féminin, et je ne sais pas si je compte comme un désisteur. Je ne décris dans ce récit ni regret, ni troubles de santé mentale, ni interventions médicales. Je réfléchis maintenant de façon critique au fait que la transition comme la détransition sont utilisées comme des projets identitaires, et je plaide pour la nuance plutôt que la rhétorique alarmiste des deux côtés. Mon identité actuelle est celle d’un homme gay qui a désisté/détransitionné et qui n’a jamais transitionné médicalement.
Histoire complète
I am a gay man who was born male. For a rather long period I thought I was actually a girl and wanted to transition, but I never took hormones and never socially transitioned. I did cross dress occasionally and loved being viewed as a woman when I did — I described myself as a skinny feminine twink who just needed some makeup to 'pass'. Eventually I came to realize I'm just a feminine gay man, and I'm unsure how to label that experience (I asked whether I count as a desister). I never underwent any medical intervention, so there are no irreversible changes, fertility concerns, or medical complications to speak of.
I think about gender in materialist terms: gender is 'the super-structural detritus accumulated around the material realities of sex' — not real in a simple sense, but not fake either. I use examples like bravery being coded masculine because men have greater muscle mass on average. I'm skeptical of both trans and detransition discourses becoming identity projects; I warned that detransitioning can become an 'existential identity fixer' and source of community and meaning in the same way transition did for some people, and I advised people to ask whether they're using transition/detransition to indirectly satiate other needs like community. I also criticized the 'you're literally killing/saving people' rhetoric on both sides as hyperbole that strips nuance and leads to worse outcomes for everyone.
On sexuality, I'm gay and describe my attraction: my attraction to women is mainly visual, while my attraction to men is mostly smell and 'behavioral' — a picture of a man usually doesn't do anything for me, but a whiff of his scent does. I pushed back against studies using visual stimuli and blood-flow arousal data as definitive, and against the implication that bisexuality is 'something gone wrong'. I have a generally rationalist, Marxist-influenced frame (I once joked 'Wait what… what's Marxism?'), and I engage critically with radical feminism — I think it starts from rational materialist grounding but falls into essentializing traps. I don't describe mental health conditions, trauma, adversity, family dynamics, or regret in this transcript. My overall stance is reflective and analytical rather than distressed: I treat my period of wanting to be a girl as something I grew out of upon recognizing I'm a feminine gay man.