Toutes les histoires

Le finastéride et le Rogaine n'ont pas pu défaire les dégâts

Masculin · Détransitionné·e586
Ces histoires ont été résumées à l'aide de l'IA.

Sur Reddit, les gens partagent souvent leurs expériences à travers plusieurs commentaires ou publications. Pour rendre ces informations plus accessibles, detrans.ai rassemble toutes ces pièces dispersées en un résumé et une chronologie uniques et faciles à lire. Tous les prompts du système sont documentés sur la page des prompts.

Parfois, l'IA peut halluciner ou affirmer des choses qui ne sont pas vraies. Mais généralement, les histoires résumées sont des reflets précis des commentaires originaux des utilisateurs.

Résumé

Je suis un homme détransitionné qui a quitté une communauté trans qui me rejette maintenant et trouvé du soutien auprès de femmes critiques du genre. La transition m'a causé une perte de cheveux permanente que je n'ai pas réussi à inverser avec le finastéride ou le Rogaine, et je considère maintenant l'autogynéphilie comme un schéma addictif à vie que je dois gérer, les spécialistes me disant que le recâblage prend environ trois ans. Je crois que ma dysphorie découlait de la conviction d'être dans le mauvais corps, et le rétablissement a exigé de reprogrammer cette fausse identité et de traiter les problèmes sous-jacents. Je suis très critique envers les systèmes médicaux, thérapeutiques et politiques qui ont permis ma transition et envers le manque de soutien pour les hommes détransitionnés. Je partage activement des médias, des recherches et des récits d'avertissement sur la détransition pour alerter les autres sur la permanence et les failles du consentement éclairé de la transition médicale.

Histoire complète

I am a detransitioned male. I came out of a trans community that now hates me, and I have found more support from women I once would have called TERFs than from anywhere else. I mingle online every day with those women, and more of them than I can count have supported me in my detransition. My transition involved hormones, and I was not adequately warned about what they would do. I recall reading an informed consent document from Fenway Health listing permanent masculinizing effects like hair loss, and I noted that even that document understated the risks. When I began my gender transition, I got sucked into the idea that taking Finasteride and using Rogaine might bring my hair back — it never did. My hairline had already begun to receding in my mid-20s, before transition. I tell others to proceed with the mindset that it's gone but still cling to hope that it might return, and to warn others, because it's clear people are not reading or understanding the informed consent documents they've signed. A central issue for me in detransition has been coping with autogynephilia. I describe AGP as a compulsive, addictive behavior: "Like an alcoholic or drug addict, I'll have to fight the urges to relapse for probably the rest of my life." Specialists I've talked to on these types of behaviors say it takes three years to rewire your brain from addictions. Coping with AGP will be a lifelong part of detransitioning for me. I have thought a lot about how I got here. I believe gender dysphoria follows from being convinced you're in the wrong body, not the other way around — I compare it to David Reimer, who developed dysphoria because Money pinned the wrong biological sex on him. "Once you let someone convince you that you're in the wrong body, even if you asked them to play along, then gender dysphoria ensues, because it's an unfixable situation." I also believe a big part of recovery is reprogramming your thinking: "You led yourself to believe that you are male when you adopted the FTM identity. Remember that, it's an identity, nothing more." (I used that phrasing while advising someone else, but it reflects how I understand my own path.) Every time the thought comes that you're not your biological sex, you remind yourself that you are, and you work on the underlying problems leading you away from your biological reality. I have also reflected on the role of sexual abuse and sexuality. I've noted that if you were sexually abused as a female, that's much easier for society to digest than if you were a male, because it makes you look weak — and that there's a sexual component for males who transitioned because they're autogynephilic, and "Who wants to admit that and where do you get help for it?" I've pointed to research suggesting people may engage in certain sexual behaviors to cope with PTSD or other mental health problems, as avoidance behavior. I have been in therapy and I recommend it to others: "They can teach you some coping skills and strategies. This 'life' thing is no bed of roses, it's more suffering than pleasure generally. The trick is learning how to cope with the hand you were dealt." I also recommend heavy-duty reading on gender dysphoria — its types and causes — pointing people to 4thWaveNow's piece "Gender dysphoria is not one thing" and Ray Blanchard's work. I am critical of the medical and therapeutic establishment. I believe detransitioners were failed by the medical community that promised to do no harm, by therapists advancing gender ideology, by government leaders who validated these transitions through legal fiction, and by friends and families who played along. "The only thing we failed at as detransitioners was not wising up about what had been done to us before we did." I've argued that prescribing social and medical transition as treatment for gender dysphoria is unlike treatment for any other mental illness, and I've quoted McHugh's line that transgenderism is the only disease of the mind where the body gets treated instead. I've also thought about the asymmetry of support. I've said there's nowhere near as much help for a detrans male, almost none in fact, and that it's an area that has to be built. I've noted that FTMs are able to get much more help and support than an MTF, while MTF desisters get more media visibility. I've defended GC/radfems as offering real education about how trans people employ sex stereotypes as a transition and credibility tool, while acknowledging that some in that community have a seething hatred for all things male — something I've been on the business end of. I've also noted that people of faith and their organizations are willing to offer help to both male and female desisters, even though it's tough to accept after having them as an enemy while trans, and that they're often anti-gay as well. I follow detransition media closely. I've shared and defended Silas González's detransition documentary and his 23-year journey, Third Way Trans (whom I suspect works in the mental health field), Walt Heyer, and the amicus brief by nine formerly transgender people arguing gender identity should not be a protected class. I've complained that the only media outlets consistently publishing anything about detransition are conservative or faith-based, and that this is used as grounds to discredit them. I've also posted news stories about people cautioning others about transition — including a Sydney man, Dean, who after 10 years as "Andrea" detransitioned, and who said being trans "was like a thing for me to escape being homosexual; it seemed more acceptable for me to be a woman" — and about clinicians warning that the informed consent model is leading to a surge in reversal surgeries. I have not described any surgeries of my own in detail. I have discussed the medical risks of testosterone for females (including hysterectomies to protect against cancer risk) and the permanence of masculinizing effects, and I've advised someone on supplements (Saw Palmetto, Red Clover, Fenugreek, Stinging Nettle, Ovarian Glandular) to stop them given elevated testosterone from a cancerous tumor, noting saw palmetto can decrease the effectiveness of estrogen products. On identity, I describe myself plainly as a detransition male. I've argued that a female reproductive system and female chromosomes make a person a woman, and that putting on female clothing and makeup is just a stereotype of a female, not "living as a woman."