Toutes les histoires

Pas d'hormones, pas de regret : simplement quitter le binaire

Féminin · Désisté·e150
Ces histoires ont été résumées à l'aide de l'IA.

Sur Reddit, les gens partagent souvent leurs expériences à travers plusieurs commentaires ou publications. Pour rendre ces informations plus accessibles, detrans.ai rassemble toutes ces pièces dispersées en un résumé et une chronologie uniques et faciles à lire. Tous les prompts du système sont documentés sur la page des prompts.

Parfois, l'IA peut halluciner ou affirmer des choses qui ne sont pas vraies. Mais généralement, les histoires résumées sont des reflets précis des commentaires originaux des utilisateurs.

Résumé

Je suis une femme qui a détransitionné / désisté, qui garde les pronoms féminins et se comprend comme non conforme au genre et « en dehors du binaire » plutôt que comme un homme. Je n'ai jamais décrit de transition médicale (ni hormones, ni chirurgies, ni bloqueurs dans ce que j'ai écrit) et je n'ai pas parlé de regret, de thérapie, de traumatisme ou de sexualité. Mes opinions sont fortement abolitionnistes du genre : je vois la féminité comme une construction performative destinée à plaire aux hommes, et le non-binaire comme ce que les gens seraient par défaut sans les attentes patriarcales de genre. Je crois que la transition ne peut pas rendre cis, même si je soutiens le droit des gens de transitionner et de changer d'avis. En avril 2023, j'ai soutenu avec force que ce subreddit hébergeait des opinions approuvant le suicide et la maltraitance parentale comme alternatives à la transition, et j'ai dit qu'un tel contenu pourrait faire bannir la communauté.

Histoire complète

I have never posted a thread of my own here; everything I've written is in reply to other people, and reading it back, it traces a fairly consistent set of convictions about gender rather than a neat medical timeline of my own. I'm a gender nonconforming woman. I've described myself that way directly, and I've said plainly that I keep my gendered pronouns. What I've never felt is that the gender I was born as fits me: "Nothing about that gender fits who I am. Nothing about the opposite gender fits who I am either." That's how I understand non-binary — simply something that doesn't fit into the binary — and I use "outside the binary" as a personal way to understand why I feel like "a different species that can't even imitate the two genders in an acceptable way." I've been clear that I don't claim to feel like a different biological sex; I agree I am my biological sex, and I don't think it's possible to "feel" like your sex at all, because it just is what it is at all times. Gender, by contrast, is something society constructs on top of that, with nothing to do with my genitals or hormones. My thinking is strongly gender-abolitionist. I've argued that non-binary is ideally what people would be by default if we stripped away toxic gender expectations dictated by patriarchy, and I've said that if I wrote down a list of everything society associates with my gender, I would fit exactly one item: genitals. I've been blunt about how I see femininity — that it's misogyny that women are forced to perform the "unnatural act of femininity" while men get to exist in a natural state; that makeup, shaving, dressing for sex appeal rather than comfort, and behaving in a subdued, deferential way are performative and built around being visually pleasing to men. I've asked, exasperated, whether anyone sincerely believes having a vulva and estrogen makes you spontaneously want to wear makeup and shave. I've also been critical of this community at times. I said it isn't a good subreddit for actual gender abolitionists, because posting about not wanting to fit inside the box of male/female draws people who tell you that you shouldn't avoid forced femininity and patriarchal definitions of womanhood; I said most people here "just love societal imposed femininity and hate men rather than seeing gender as a social construct." On transition itself, my position has been that transitioning can't turn you into a cis version of the opposite sex: "your life experience is that of a trans person, not a cis person of that gender." I've said I see nothing wrong with wanting to be trans, and that trans can be its own kind of gender, but the problem arises when people need transitioning in order to feel cis and are terrified of not being seen that way. I don't see how someone can be happy transitioning if being seen as cis is the goal — while allowing that you can absolutely pass as your ideal gender. I've given advice to parents of gender-questioning kids. I told one mother that supporting gender nonconformity is good, and that a lot of people wouldn't transition if they were allowed to be more gender neutral without feeling displaced — giving the example that a boyish girl gets called an ugly girl, a slob, or a dyke, and that being deeply uncomfortable with how the world sees you is what pushes people to transition, because they'd rather have the label transguy than those. I suggested gently prompting a kid to question why they'd want to go all the way to full transition, and whether living perceived as a trans man or cis man would really make them happier. I also warned about binding at 13, saying it can damage skin elasticity and affect what kind of top surgery is possible later — and that framing it as important for a later step might stall permanent damage. I've been supportive of people reconsidering transition. I told one 20-year-old that if they felt pressured to transition because of their mother's enthusiasm, they should tell her honestly, and that transition is something you can change your mind about at any time — that you can decide later that it's for you, and you don't have to make it concrete now. In April 2023 I got into a sharp argument in a thread here. I accused it of promoting parental abuse and suicide as positive and necessary alternatives to transitioning, and said that if that sort of content is allowed, the subreddit as a whole should be removed. I said I want this space to exist and not get banned on Reddit for hosting views that suicide or parental abuse are an appropriate response to a desire to transition, and that extreme views like that push people away from taking detransition seriously. I also pushed back on the assumption that kids hide transition desires for trivial reasons, saying that if a child is hiding it, it's because they'd face extreme physical and emotional abuse, and that caring parents don't need teachers to tell them what's going on inside their child's head. I don't have any medical transition history in what I've written — no hormones, surgeries, or blockers are mentioned — and I haven't discussed therapy, diagnoses, trauma, or my own family beyond saying I'm a mother of a one-year-old son (who I noted would learn a new name, in advice to someone else). I haven't described regret, because I haven't described transitioning. Sexuality hasn't come up. I haven't said anything about suicidal thoughts or self-harm of my own. As for where I am now: I'm a detransitioned or desisted woman — I identify as a woman, keep she/her pronouns, and understand myself as gender nonconforming and outside the social binary rather than as a man or as someone who needs to transition.