Toutes les histoires

Trois amis perdus, et une culpabilité qui a survécu à la transition

Féminin · Détransitionné·e327
Ces histoires ont été résumées à l'aide de l'IA.

Sur Reddit, les gens partagent souvent leurs expériences à travers plusieurs commentaires ou publications. Pour rendre ces informations plus accessibles, detrans.ai rassemble toutes ces pièces dispersées en un résumé et une chronologie uniques et faciles à lire. Tous les prompts du système sont documentés sur la page des prompts.

Parfois, l'IA peut halluciner ou affirmer des choses qui ne sont pas vraies. Mais généralement, les histoires résumées sont des reflets précis des commentaires originaux des utilisateurs.

Résumé

Je suis une personne détransitionnée (je n'indique pas explicitement mon sexe dans cette transcription) qui a transitionné étant mineure et écrit maintenant publiquement sur l'hostilité à laquelle les détransitionneurs font face en ligne. J'ai perdu trois amis transgenres à cause de ma détransition et je porte de la culpabilité d'avoir critiqué la communauté trans, ainsi qu'une colère considérable que je sens que mes messages ne traduisent pas entièrement. Je soutiens que la détransition est une forme légitime de découverte de soi qui mérite la même compassion que la transition, et je m'inquiète particulièrement de l'effet des contenus sur l'identité de genre sur les mineurs vulnérables. Je crois que les blagues en ligne et les affirmations répétées entre pairs ont contribué à ma propre conviction d'être trans. Je ne décris ni chirurgies, ni hormones, ni détails médicaux dans ce matériel.

Histoire complète

I am a detransitioned person who now writes openly online about what happened to me and about how detransitioners are treated. My own transition began when I was a minor, and I was told at that time the kind of thing that is often said to young people — the "without transitioning you will DIE" mindset — which I say "used to be told to me when i was a minor." I also describe being deeply involved in the trans community as a minor and later concluding that it "may have harmed me mentally when I was a minor." A specific mechanism I point to for how I came to believe I was trans is casual online humour: I wrote a comment saying that "that person can just have strange dreams," got called a transphobe for it, deleted the comment, and reflected that "innocent funny sentences like that made me believe i was trans when i wasn't (because, if so many people say so, they must be right… right?)." So peer/online reinforcement and repetition of jokes or claims among people around me were, in my own reading, part of what shaped my belief. I have detransitioned. I do not state a specific date for detransition, but I refer to "my own detransition journey" as something already under way by mid-2026, and I mention losing three transgender friends "by simply detransitioning because they didn't want to be associated with a fake trans person, as they said." That loss of friendships is one of the concrete social costs I name. I do not describe any surgeries, hormone regimens, or medical complications in this transcript, so I leave those details out rather than guess. What I do describe is a strong emotional and social aftermath: guilt. "Sometimes I feel bad even thinking critically about parts of the trans community or admitting that being deeply involved in it may have harmed me mentally when I was a minor," and that guilt worsens when people "immediately call you a transphobe for expressing those thoughts." I also express a lot of anger — at the end of my longer post I say the post "doesn't show my true feelings that are way more angry about this state of the community." My main public argument, which I have made in more than one post, is that detransition is itself a form of self-discovery and deserves the same compassion that transition receives. I ask: "isn't detransition also part of self-discovery?" and "Why should only one of those journeys be treated with compassion?" I am careful to say I am not attacking trans people: "I'm not talking about people attacking trans people or invalidating their existence," and "how can I hate (be a transphobe) people for being themselves when all I ever wanted, both for myself and for others, was exactly that?" I am particularly concerned about minors and online content. I think conversations around minors and trans-related content online are "way more complicated than people admit," and I argue that concern for children gets "immediate negative and hostile reactions" and that some minors are "vulnerable, confused, lonely, struggling mentally or searching for identity and belonging online." I believe acknowledging that some people were influenced in unhealthy ways "does not erase trans people or their experiences. Both realities can exist at the same time!" I am frustrated by statistics I consider inflated — I refer dismissively to "the one percent out of ass statistics" used to downplay detransition — and by the pattern I see where detransitioners get "hated on or silenced no matter what" on platforms like TikTok. I also note that some detransitioners are told their experiences are "irrelevant" because they supposedly make "real trans people" look bad, and I reject that: "Detrans people are not propaganda." On a personal level I am active in appearance-related self-presentation after detransition: I compliment other detransitioned people's looks, ask a "fellow girl" for a lip combo, and wish someone "the hair of your dreams in the future," which suggests I am navigating feminine presentation now. Someone else follows my Instagram "since my own detransition journey," so I have a public following around this. Overall I would describe my stance as critical of certain dynamics within the trans community and protective of minors, while explicitly not opposing trans people's existence or rights.