Toutes les histoires

Excommunié par la gauche à cause des questions trans

Masculin · Détransitionné·e1,6 k
Ces histoires ont été résumées à l'aide de l'IA.

Sur Reddit, les gens partagent souvent leurs expériences à travers plusieurs commentaires ou publications. Pour rendre ces informations plus accessibles, detrans.ai rassemble toutes ces pièces dispersées en un résumé et une chronologie uniques et faciles à lire. Tous les prompts du système sont documentés sur la page des prompts.

Parfois, l'IA peut halluciner ou affirmer des choses qui ne sont pas vraies. Mais généralement, les histoires résumées sont des reflets précis des commentaires originaux des utilisateurs.

Résumé

Je suis une personne détransitionnée qui a fait sa transition il y a longtemps, avant la vague moderne de visibilité trans, largement influencée par un cercle d'amis trans et autistes et par un personnel médical trop permissif, mais qui a détransitionné après que cette communauté m'a coupé les ponts et que j'ai vu à quel point elle était manipulatrice. Depuis ma détransition, j'ai été excommunié de la plupart des espaces LGBT et de gauche, j'ai perdu beaucoup d'amis et j'ai été étiqueté transphobe à répétition, ce qui m'a laissé amer et socialement isolé. Je vois maintenant la transition comme un dernier recours trop facilement poussé, et je crois que la dysphorie de genre devrait être traitée comme une maladie mentale plutôt qu'affirmée médicalement. Je plaide de façon informelle dans les espaces de détransition, en avertissant les autres du biais des coûts irrécupérables et des dynamiques sectaires que j'ai connues. Je reste politiquement de gauche mais je me sens sans foyer politique à cause des questions trans.

Histoire complète

I transitioned a long time ago, well before the current wave of trans visibility — I knew I was weird and all I wanted at the time was to go stealth. Looking back, my dysphoria wasn't actually that bad; I was lured in by overly permissive medical staff who didn't adequately push therapy before offering life-altering hormones and surgery. I also had a friend circle that was mostly autistic and trans, and that community was a huge part of what kept me going. After some really stupid internal drama I was cut off from those 'friends,' and being pushed out actually let me see how gross and manipulative they were — they were in it for the fetish, and my presence 'killed their vibes.' Without that community pushing me, the drive to live my 'true self' died really quickly. Age was another factor; you could say I hit 'twink death' — estrogen prolonged it but couldn't stop the inevitable. When I detransitioned, the backlash was brutal. My friends backstabbed me 'something fierce,' and I lost a lot of them. I've been excommunicated from most LGBT spaces and from lefty spaces because of my views on trans issues — I'm a leftie, but it's really hard to be politically involved when transgenderism is such a powerful fracturing force. I tried speaking up about gender affirming care and got booted out of every Discord and Telegram group I was in. I spend time around artists, and when I've tried to speak up on these issues I've been 'unpersonned' from the whole group, and the people who noticed I was gone cheered when the mod banned a 'transphobe.' Most of the places I hang out are 'safe spaces' that will oust me if they catch a whiff of transphobia, and anything I say about my detrans journey can be misinterpreted, so I'm forced to keep quiet. This is the only place I have left to vent. I'm very bitter because my life experiences have been dismissed and I've been called a troll all because they didn't conform to the narrative. The abuse and gaslighting from the trans community was very hard to deal with. I've been called transphobic so often by people engaging in detransphobia that I've become heavily desensitized to the word. I missed out on the prime of my life chasing something impossible, and now I'm older and very, very short on friends. I have some personal trauma from how I was treated, and I actively avoid interacting with trans people now — they were a large part of my friend circle and it hurt, but the venom and backstabbing was too much. On transition itself, I believe it's an act of last resort and a recipe for tons of trouble. If there's any inkling of possibility you can manage with your current body, you should do it. Transitioning has been glorified as a magical solution, but it's the same shit with a different color, except you're at an extra handicap. I think too many people are being pushed to transition when we could just accept non-traditional roles instead — I love tomboys and for a while thought I was one myself. I'm a huge advocate for doing whatever we like to our own bodies, but most people aren't making informed choices because the information is heavily skewed. I believe gender dysphoria is a mental illness, not unlike anorexia, and should be treated as such — we don't affirm anorexia with liposuction. I've suggested to others that they need a therapist to determine if they're actually experiencing internalized misogyny instead. I've done some informal advocacy — mostly posting and commenting in detrans and gender-critical spaces, sharing my experience, and pushing back on what I see as grooming behavior (like the 'egg cracking' concept). I've also given practical advice to others considering detransition, telling them it takes real courage to own up to the error but that they'll be a better person for it.