Toutes les histoires

Il a failli prendre les hormones — puis a compris qu'il aimait surtout les vêtements

Masculin · Désisté·e169
Ces histoires ont été résumées à l'aide de l'IA.

Sur Reddit, les gens partagent souvent leurs expériences à travers plusieurs commentaires ou publications. Pour rendre ces informations plus accessibles, detrans.ai rassemble toutes ces pièces dispersées en un résumé et une chronologie uniques et faciles à lire. Tous les prompts du système sont documentés sur la page des prompts.

Parfois, l'IA peut halluciner ou affirmer des choses qui ne sont pas vraies. Mais généralement, les histoires résumées sont des reflets précis des commentaires originaux des utilisateurs.

Résumé

Je suis un homme détransitionné/désistant qui a failli commencer les hormones mais s'est arrêté après avoir compris que j'étais à l'aise d'être un homme et que j'aimais simplement porter parfois des vêtements de femme. Je n'ai jamais subi de chirurgie ni pris d'hormones. Je me concentre maintenant sur l'acceptation de moi-même et je mets les autres en garde contre le fait de se précipiter dans la transition, avertissant que le questionnement de genre peut venir d'un traumatisme, de l'autisme, d'un TPL ou d'autres problèmes plutôt que d'une véritable dysphorie. Je suis critique des espaces pro-trans en ligne qui poussent des personnes confuses à s'identifier comme trans, et je plaide pour que l'expérience de la détransition soit entendue. Je n'ai décrit aucune idée suicidaire ni automutilation actuelle.

Histoire complète

I am a man who came close to starting hormones but stopped before doing so. Looking back, I realized I was comfortable being a man — I just liked dressing in women's clothes sometimes, and I came to understand that even cis people struggle with identity at some point. I don't have a detailed medical transition story because I never went through with hormones, but that near-miss shaped how I think and talk about this subject. What I keep coming back to is self-acceptance. I tell people that being a man or male means many different things to different people, and that the box of traditional masculinity only exists if you want it to exist. I've learned to find myself and accept myself, and I try to pass that on: get connected with the things you like, your hobbies, reconnect with your humour, watch comedy and laugh, cry when you need to, but don't wallow. It takes many years, and even people who have not gone down the trans route struggle with this for a long, long time — but if you work at it you will get there. I'm critical of how the mainstream trans community handles questioning people. I've spent time in pro-trans subreddits and found it concerning how much pressure there is to identify as trans. I've seen countless posts from people saying they feel confused about their gender, and instead of being told to take it easy and think it over, they're told they're clearly trans and should get hormones ASAP, complete with lists of clinics that prescribe with no questions asked. I named r/trans and r/asktransgender as the worst offenders. I think pro-trans rhetoric is often irresponsible because it doesn't consider alternative explanations for why someone might want to transition — schizophrenia, autism, BPD, narcissistic personality disorder, other stresses, insecurities or trauma — and that this ends up hurting people with genuine dysphoria too. I believe psychological evaluation before transition is important for exactly this reason. I also think there's room for people with platforms to warn about rushing into transition — not to say nobody should transition, but to say be careful, because questioning your gender may not always come from dysphoria. I've said plainly that many people regret these kinds of decisions and that the mainstream trans community tends to ignore or not recognize detransition, so people shouldn't expect much support if they go back. I've acknowledged that I can see the frustration on the other side too, and that I see a lot of nuance in trans spaces as well — it's not a complete dumpster fire — but there's still enough pressuring for me to be concerned. I shared an interview with Courtney Coulson about her detransition and said I'd post more if people enjoyed it. On whether that content should go to pro-trans groups, I said I was fine with it not being posted there and that it's up to the community to decide when that happens, but that when it does I'll be in the wings fighting the good fight. I think pro-trans movements need to be more aware of the detrans experience. I've also admitted I was a little guilty early on of using the same politicized tactics back, but that ultimately it just feeds the system and drowns out regular trans and detrans people. On a practical level I've given advice to younger people: don't do things out of desperation even if they seem logical; you can have typically male interests and behaviour without becoming a man; avoid guys on dating apps who get overly sexual or love-bomb you; and stay away from relationships until you're older and know who you are — I've made too many mistakes by getting into relationships I wasn't ready for. I've also commented that young boys are getting hold of porn way too early and that I wouldn't give my daughter or son a phone with Snapchat at age 12. I've noted that it's common for abused people to try to run away or become unattractive — through weight gain or transitioning — without actually facing the underlying problem, and that psychological evaluation matters because dysphoria can stem from things other than genuine gender dysphoria. Overall I'm cautiously supportive of transition for people whose dysphoria is genuinely pervasive and negatively affecting their life, but I strongly urge caution, self-examination, and psychological evaluation first, and I advocate for detransition experiences to be taken seriously.