Toutes les histoires

Douze ans en homme trans en ligne, et la décennie que cela a coûté

Féminin · Désisté·ePremière dysphorie 13 → Transition sociale 19 → Désistance 3010,8 k
Ces histoires ont été résumées à l'aide de l'IA.

Sur Reddit, les gens partagent souvent leurs expériences à travers plusieurs commentaires ou publications. Pour rendre ces informations plus accessibles, detrans.ai rassemble toutes ces pièces dispersées en un résumé et une chronologie uniques et faciles à lire. Tous les prompts du système sont documentés sur la page des prompts.

Parfois, l'IA peut halluciner ou affirmer des choses qui ne sont pas vraies. Mais généralement, les histoires résumées sont des reflets précis des commentaires originaux des utilisateurs.

Résumé

Je suis une femme détransitionnée/désistante : née femme, gay (attirée exclusivement par les femmes) et non conforme au genre. Je me suis identifiée comme trans d'environ 19 ans jusqu'au début de la trentaine, on m'a diagnostiqué une dysphorie de genre et approuvé une lettre pour la testostérone vers 2011-2012, mais je n'ai jamais pris d'hormones ni subi de chirurgie par peur des effets secondaires médicaux et de devenir une patiente à vie. J'ai perdu environ une décennie de mon adolescence tardive et de ma vingtaine à cause de la dépression, de l'isolement et d'un personnage masculin obsessionnel en ligne — une perte que je regrette profondément, notamment avoir raté la fac, les rencontres et du temps avec mes grands-parents avant leur mort. Après des années de thérapie, d'introspection et de maturation jusqu'au milieu de la trentaine, j'ai cessé de m'identifier comme trans vers 30 ans et je m'accepte maintenant comme une femme gay non conforme au genre ; j'ai maintenant 36 ans, je suis heureusement mariée à une femme et je ne fais plus partie d'aucune communauté LGBT ou trans. J'éprouve encore de la dysphorie corporelle, surtout à propos de ma poitrine et de mes règles, mais elle est gérable plutôt qu'invalidante ; je n'ai jamais eu d'idées suicidaires, mais j'ai passé des années à ne pas vouloir vivre pendant ma décennie dépressive.

Histoire complète

I was born female and grew up in a small working-class town in the early 2000s. My childhood was, by my own account, surprisingly good — my parents let me play with whatever toys I wanted, I only played with boys at school, and gender wasn't really an issue for me then. I was a sporty kid, the fastest and most athletic in my class of boys and girls. I don't remember identifying as a boy or a girl as a young child; I just liked 'boys' things — soccer, short hair, masculine clothes — and my parents allowed it, though relatives would comment that I'd 'grow out of it.' Puberty around age 13 was when everything changed. I hated female puberty with an intensity I can barely convey — breasts developing, hips widening, periods starting, fat redistributing, suddenly being sexualized. I remember the exact feeling of my hips developing and it feeling like I was running with a tire around my waist; my whole running stride was off. I was a tomboy and I was furious that my body was becoming something I didn't want. I had no desire to ever be pregnant, so to me the whole reproductive apparatus of my female body felt pointless and like a cruel joke. Around age 13 I became interested in female bodybuilders — their muscularity and masculine faces — while everyone else made fun of them; I thought Chyna from WWF was cool. I was intensely jealous of boys and men from about 13 to 20 — roughly eight years — because their puberty seemed to enhance what they already had (taller, stronger, faster) while mine took away what I had. I also knew I was gay from my teenage years — exclusively attracted to women, never to men. Being openly gay in my town in the early 2000s was not an option; it was seen as dirty and wrong. Boys who liked girls were 'cool and normal'; my attraction to girls was treated as disgusting. I experienced regular homophobic abuse from peers, and hostility for being gender non-conforming and masculine-presenting. I was nearly thrown out of women's bathrooms as a teenager because of my short hair and androgynous appearance, and got 'sir'd' by strangers. I hated getting changed in high school with other girls because I felt it was inappropriate for me to be around them undressing, and I'd wait in the bathroom until everyone was clothed. A girl at school told me I shouldn't play soccer with the boys, so I switched to playing with girls — it was boring but I felt I was supposed to. Around age 17 to 19 I discovered the concept of transsexuality online and it felt like the perfect solution: I could escape the homophobia, escape misogyny, escape being sexualized, be seen as a 'normal' straight guy, be friends with men without it being sexual, and get the masculine body I wanted. I spent my late teens and early 20s — from about 14 to 23 — almost entirely online, in chatrooms, Second Life, and roleplaying games, pretending to be a guy. I was happy in that fake life, but it was a lie; I formed friendships and even sort of relationships as a male persona, though I could never speak because my voice would give me away. I also watched transguy YouTubers from the late 2000s and could relate to them. At about 19 I made up my mind to transition. I quit my job because I wanted to start fresh as a guy somewhere new. I went to therapy specifically to get a referral letter for testosterone — that was required back then. My therapist, who specialized in LGBT issues, diagnosed me with gender dysphoria, certified me as a 'textbook trans' case (masculine, GNC, gay so 'straight' for a transguy, no history of abuse, androgynous and already passing without hormones), and approved me for a T letter for my doctor around 2011/2012. She also put me in touch with a transwoman who told me the first thing I needed to do was pick a male name and start going by it. I was in my early 20s at this point. That was the first red flag. The idea that being called 'Dave' would fix my gender issues struck me as ridiculous and performative. Then the fear set in: I'd heard about heart attacks, strokes, cancers, liver and heart problems, agonizing headaches (the theory then was that testosterone increased brain size against the skull), baldness, personality changes. I already suffered severe migraines. I also hated the idea of becoming a lifelong patient of the medical industry — dependent on synthetic hormones forever — and I'd been told a hysterectomy would be required after being on T due to cancer risk. I had heart palpitations and scares around that time — missed beats, a terrifying episode where I felt myself dying as I fell asleep — which made me even more afraid T would wreck my heart. I never took testosterone. I also never wanted the surgeries; I'd researched phalloplasty and was put off by the results. Getting the T letter and then freezing was the start of a depression that lasted about a decade. I was stuck in a 'trans wilderness' — identifying as trans socially but medically unable or unwilling to go further. I became deeply depressed: unemployed, staying up until the early hours, sleeping until 3pm, barely eating, losing weight, not taking care of myself, chronically online. I didn't want to kill myself but I 'didn't want to be around' during those years. I quit my job and never restarted my career properly. I left the lesbian community I'd been happy in because I felt I didn't belong as a non-woman. I drifted away from friends. I stopped visiting my grandparents so I wouldn't have to explain my trans identity to them, and they passed away during that period — something I deeply regret. I didn't date at all until my mid-20s, around 28, because I was too confused about myself; I felt like a teenager just beginning to date, which was not good for healthy adult relationships. The trans communities I was in felt cult-like to me in retrospect: they shared with each other the exact phrases you had to say to therapists to get approved — specifically 'I feel like a man trapped in a woman's body' — and there was a strong push to transition as fast as possible. I never said that phrase because it never made sense to me; I never felt like a man, I just didn't feel like a woman. I felt like me, trapped in a woman's body. The community's obsession with passing, its reinforcement of gender stereotypes, and its hostility to questions started to wake me up. What moved me toward desisting was a combination of things: my own fear of the medical side effects (the 'quick' decision), and then years of genuine self-reflection, therapy, and maturing (the slow decision). I saw other therapists — not gender specialists — and focused on confidence, self-esteem, internalized homophobia, and internalized misogyny rather than gender identity. I asked myself hard questions and answered them honestly: Would I want to transition if men and women were treated identically? If society were fine with gay people? If I lived on a desert island? I came to realize that a lot of what I wanted was just stereotypes — that I'd be continuing the horrible idea that men and women can only act in certain ways by 'switching sides.' I realized transition would be inauthentic and would reinforce the gender roles that had made me miserable. I identified as trans from about age 19 until my early-to-mid 30s — roughly a decade — and stopped identifying as trans around 5 years ago (so around age 30-31). I never medically transitioned: no hormones, no surgeries. I did wear compression shirts instead of binding because I disliked binding, and my chest became pretty much unnoticeable, though I still hunch over years later. I still experience gender dysphoria, mainly about my chest and my female reproductive parts generally, and periods — I've had them for over 20 years and they still make me dysphoric every month. But it's no longer the crippling, life-stopping kind; it's more an annoyance. I've never wanted children, so my uterus and eggs feel pointless to me, but I won't risk hormones or surgery to remove them because of the health side effects. I also had a prominent Adam's apple since my teens and was once tested for thyroid cancer (it was negative; the doctor said being thin makes it more visible on women). I have no other PCOS symptoms besides being slightly more hairy. I get occasional migraines. I've never been on T. I'm now 36. I'm a masculine, GNC, androgynous gay woman. I'm happily married to a woman — I started dating in my mid-20s after I began coming out of the trans identity, and I told my wife from the start about my history and my issues with certain areas of my body; she respects that. I wear my hair long now because with short hair I still get 'sir'd' and questioned in bathrooms; with long hair it basically stops. I wear androgynous/neutral clothes, men's or men's style clothes, no makeup, no jewelry besides a watch and wedding ring, haven't worn a dress or skirt since I was about 11. I'm 'stone' in the lesbian sense — no interest in my own genitals being touched — which I told my wife about up front; there's no history of sexual abuse behind it. My mental health now is much better. I still have low confidence and natural shyness, particularly around performing femininity with men, but I've worked on it. I exercise regularly — I hired a personal trainer to force myself into a routine, which worked for a year and gave me the motivation to continue at home. I still get dysphoric at the gym seeing out-of-shape men lift weights I can't, but I've largely stopped comparing myself to others. I'm no longer part of any trans or LGBT communities; I left trans spaces about 5 years ago and the wider LGBT community after that. I have a couple of old high school friends and my new friends have only known me as not-trans. I don't go to Pride anymore — the last few I attended had become too commercialized and kink-focused. On regret: I deeply regret the roughly decade of my life — my late teens through my early 20s — that I lost to the trans obsession and depression. I call it one of my very few regrets in life. I missed out on a 'normal' youth, on college (I didn't go because I didn't want to deal with being secretly trans/gay there), on dating experiences, on relationships with my grandparents, on career development. I wish I could get those years back. The regret is stable — I've processed it and accepted it — but it flares up occasionally. I'm grateful I didn't medically transition; I feel I 'dodged a bullet' and I feel a kind of survivor's guilt when I see younger women struggling with something I avoided. On my current views: I don't identify as trans and never would again. I accept I'm a woman because I'm an adult human female — that's all the word means to me now; I don't have a special 'womanly feeling' and I never did. I still have dysphoria but I've learned to live with it. I'm skeptical of the idea that being trans is a real, innate condition — I lean toward thinking most people who identify as trans are using it as a bandaid for other issues (internalized homophobia, misogyny, GNC-related abuse, neurodivergence, porn/fetish issues, trauma, being young), though I stay open to scientific evidence. I'm strongly opposed to medical transition for minors and critical of what I see as cult-like behavior in parts of the trans community, the lack of genuine therapy before medical interventions, and the medical industry's financial incentives. I'm supportive of adults doing what they want with their bodies. I advocate by commenting extensively on detrans communities to help others who are questioning, though I find it emotionally taxing. I consider myself desisted rather than detransitioned since I never medically transitioned, and I push back against both trans-community and detrans-community attempts to erase that distinction.