Toutes les histoires

Poussé à transitionner pour l’androgynie, pas pour la dysphorie

Masculin · Détransitionné·e692
Ces histoires ont été résumées à l'aide de l'IA.

Sur Reddit, les gens partagent souvent leurs expériences à travers plusieurs commentaires ou publications. Pour rendre ces informations plus accessibles, detrans.ai rassemble toutes ces pièces dispersées en un résumé et une chronologie uniques et faciles à lire. Tous les prompts du système sont documentés sur la page des prompts.

Parfois, l'IA peut halluciner ou affirmer des choses qui ne sont pas vraies. Mais généralement, les histoires résumées sont des reflets précis des commentaires originaux des utilisateurs.

Résumé

Je suis un homme qui a désisté, qui s’est identifié comme trans pendant environ une décennie et a désisté il y a plusieurs années, et je vois maintenant le fait d’être trans comme une thérapie médicale et sociale plutôt que comme une identité. J’ai été poussé à transitionner parce qu’on me mettait à l’écart pour ma non-conformité de genre et mon androgynie plutôt qu’à cause d’une inadéquation claire entre l’esprit et le corps. Je me sens humilié et déprimé par mon implication passée, que je décris comme le réveil d’une secte, même si je ne la regrette que « un peu » et moins que si j’étais resté trans. Je suis critique de l’activisme trans, du récit « trans ou suicide » et des thérapeutes qui traitent le fait d’être trans comme un nouveau type de personne, tout en admettant que la transition puisse être appropriée pour les cas les plus sévères. J’ai décidé en avril 2024 de ne pas annoncer publiquement ma détransition sur les réseaux sociaux, préférant simplement avancer.

Histoire complète

I was born male and identified as trans for roughly a decade before desisting several years ago. I came out to friends and family and was, by my own account, "so obsessed with this for a decade, so loud and political about trans issues to my friends and family." I socially transitioned and, I believe, medically transitioned, though I don't spell out the specific interventions or dates in what I've written so far. My name was already an androgynous nickname before I transitioned, and I've kept it. What pushed me toward transition was feeling othered for being gender nonconforming. I was androgynous, and I was told I was trans as if there were a definitive scientific consensus about gender expression and typologies. Nonconforming meant being a different "type" of human to them, and I felt pressured to see myself through their lens. I've come to believe there are many reasons people transition, not just one mind-body narrative: Blanchard's typologies (AGP vs HSTS), political insecurities around male/female as oppressor/oppressed, neurodivergence, exclusion of gender nonconformity, trauma and escapism, cultural trends and social media influence, fear of not living up to cultural standards for one's sex, and abuse. I was interested in Blanchard's typologies a few months ago but ultimately felt they were maybe a bit vilifying and left me with more questions than answers. I desisted years ago but never publicly announced it. In April 2024 I was considering posting on Facebook or Instagram that I no longer identify as trans, having written a few drafts over the years — some overdramatic, some political, some super casual. Friends from years ago probably still think of me as trans. Ultimately I decided not to post: "I suppose I don't want the attention. I'll just move forward." I now feel humiliated for having ever been part of it. I wrote that I'm "honestly so f*cking sick and depressed by all this" and that it feels like waking up from a cult fandom. I described gender as having once been such an important subject for me, but now "it's a fascist cult." I carry some regret about having been trans — "a little bit" — but not more than staying trans would have caused. I don't describe specific medical complications, fertility concerns, or surgeries in what I've written. I don't detail formal therapy in my posts, but I do reflect philosophically: "The first step is to accept that we are our sex. It's just biology. It doesn't have to dictate what clothes you wear or what activities you be a part of. Reevaluate what sex means to you, and try to have a healthier relationship with your body." I say I live with "a bit of gender-existentialism after having been trans," but add I suffered an "existentialism-existentialism" before that. On sexuality, I don't explicitly state my orientation, but I've commented to someone else: "Maybe you're fine being a woman, but you'd rather not be sexualized in public? That's totally normal," and I've raised AGP as a category in discussing reasons for transition. I've also noted that as a desisted male I see things "from the other side." My current attitude toward transition for others is conditional: "I'm not entirely against transition for those with absolutely severe dysphoria -- but that isn't *at all* the public discourse." I believe trans is not an identity but a medical and social therapy that "should be reserved for the most severe and rare cases, not popularized as the new way we all see ourselves." I'm critical of the "trans or s*icide" narrative as "horrible and dangerous," critical of activists as "emotionally abusive" people who "exaggerate violence against them to force sympathy," and critical of therapists who are "taught to believe being trans is a newly discovered type of human." I advocate for normalizing gender nonconformity instead of medicalization, and I hope the current moment moves toward more expression-based understanding rather than identity and medicalization.