Toutes les histoires

Une commentatrice qui n’a jamais posté sa propre chronologie

Féminin · Détransitionné·e88
Ces histoires ont été résumées à l'aide de l'IA.

Sur Reddit, les gens partagent souvent leurs expériences à travers plusieurs commentaires ou publications. Pour rendre ces informations plus accessibles, detrans.ai rassemble toutes ces pièces dispersées en un résumé et une chronologie uniques et faciles à lire. Tous les prompts du système sont documentés sur la page des prompts.

Parfois, l'IA peut halluciner ou affirmer des choses qui ne sont pas vraies. Mais généralement, les histoires résumées sont des reflets précis des commentaires originaux des utilisateurs.

Résumé

Je suis une femme qui a détransitionné et qui est active dans cette communauté depuis fin 2021, surtout en commentant les publications des autres plutôt qu’en écrivant les miennes. Mes contributions portent sur la part de l’identité de genre qui vient des loisirs, de la mode et de l’apparence plutôt que de quelque chose de plus profond, et sur la friction entre la façon dont nous voulons être vus et la façon dont les gens nous lisent réellement. Je suis sceptique face à la culture du « quels pronoms ? » et à l’idée qu’être traditionnellement féminine ou normale est quelque chose dont on devrait se sentir coupable. J’ai des opinions tranchées : être jolie et jouer la féminité font largement partie de la façon dont la plupart des gens ressentent le fait d’être une femme, même si ce point de vue est impopulaire ici. Je n’ai pas partagé de chronologie médicale personnelle détaillée dans ces commentaires.

Histoire complète

I have been active in detransition spaces since late 2021, mostly commenting on other people's posts rather than writing my own. Looking back over what I've said, a lot of it circles around the same questions I was asking myself: what actually makes someone feel like a man or a woman, and how much of that is just hobbies, clothing, and how much attention we pay to our appearance. Early on, in November 2021, I commented on someone's before-and-after picture, saying the picture on the right "looks a lot more normal." That word, normal, stuck with me. A few days later I wrote about how people might be made to feel like they have done something wrong or need to feel guilty for being traditionally normal. That is something I had felt myself - the sense that being conventional was somehow suspect, and that wanting to look or act in a traditionally feminine way was something I should interrogate rather than just live. In December 2021 I got into a back-and-forth with someone who said they felt more comfortable as a man because of their hobbies. I pushed back and asked whether the hobbies came after the transition or after a preference for traditionally male fashion, and I described it as "almost like what came first, the chicken or the egg." That question was really for myself. I had to sort out whether my own masculine interests and presentation were the cause of how I felt or a consequence of a decision I had already made. I also reacted strongly to what I saw as intrusive social policing. I said that "asking about pronouns is so strange and rude to me." I told someone else that if you don't want to be referred to as what people see you as, you are going to constantly be dealing with the issue where you feel bothered or uncomfortable. That was a hard lesson I had learned in my own life - the gap between how I wanted to be seen and how people actually read me was a permanent source of friction, and no amount of correcting people made it go away. On medication, I showed I had enough familiarity with hormone dosing to question someone else's prescription: I asked whether they really meant .25 mg, pointing out that testosterone preparations are usually 200-250mg per ml and that they probably meant .25ml. I did not state my own dosing or regimen anywhere in these comments. A lot of my thinking in early 2022 was about femininity, appearance, and what actually constitutes being a woman. In January 2022 I made an unpopular comment (-27 score) on a post where a woman seemed to feel that caring about her appearance made her less of a woman than her girlfriend. I told her "I think it's because you wanted to look pretty and cared more about your appearance than your girlfriend. It doesn't make you more of a women or her less of one, but it might have made you look prettier." I went on to say that "looking pretty and feeling feminine is a large part of feeling like a woman, but someone could still be a women while chewing tobbaco, wearing men's clothing and getting a fade hair cut, it just isn't considered feminine to most people." That comment got a lot of pushback, and I doubled down in a follow-up: "Feeling pretty and feminine really has nothing to do with feeling like a woman in my opinion" was the claim I was arguing against, and I responded, "I have never met a mtf trans person who doesn't try to feminize themselves." I also commented on a boy being raised in a way I thought was confusing to him: "I bet you he is learning this shit in school and it's really confusing to who he is." That reflects a broader worry I had about how much of identity is externally planted rather than internally discovered. I never wrote a full post about my own transition or detransition in this transcript, so I don't have a detailed timeline of my own medical steps to share here. What I can say is that my thinking has moved toward a more grounded, biological and social-reality-based understanding of sex and gender, and toward skepticism about both the pressure to be non-traditional and the idea that identity is purely a matter of declaration.