Ces histoires ont été résumées à l'aide de l'IA.
Sur Reddit, les gens partagent souvent leurs expériences à travers plusieurs commentaires ou publications. Pour rendre ces informations plus accessibles, detrans.ai rassemble toutes ces pièces dispersées en un résumé et une chronologie uniques et faciles à lire. Tous les prompts du système sont documentés sur la page des prompts.
Parfois, l'IA peut halluciner ou affirmer des choses qui ne sont pas vraies. Mais généralement, les histoires résumées sont des reflets précis des commentaires originaux des utilisateurs.
Résumé
Je suis une personne détransitionnée qui a été active en 2023 dans les communautés de détransition, soutenant les autres tout en travaillant sur ma propre acceptation de moi. Je suis critique de la base de preuves de la transition, je crois que la contagion sociale alimente le virage des adolescentes vers la transition, et je pense que beaucoup de gens ne sont pas tout à fait honnêtes sur les raisons de leur détransition. Je n'ai pas décrit mes propres données médicales, ma chronologie ni mes chirurgies dans ces messages. J'ai posté « je me déteste aussi » en août 2023, ce qui suggère des difficultés persistantes avec l'image de soi, mais je reste engagée à soutenir les autres et à plaider pour une recherche plus objective sur la transition et la détransition.
Histoire complète
I have spent a lot of time in detransition spaces over the past year, mostly offering support to other people going through it, and in doing so I have ended up thinking a lot about my own situation and about the broader questions around transition.
Early on, in February 2023, I told someone who was unhappy with their treatment to actually go and explain things to their doctor rather than just saying "you ruined my life" — that the doctor should know they were not satisfied. That advice about communicating with medical providers is something I clearly felt strongly about.
By late February 2023 I was openly skeptical about the evidence base for transition medicine. I asked whether there had been any longer-term studies and how rigorous the existing studies were. I also raised the uncomfortable idea that some people might be lying to themselves about why they detransitioned: that "I detransitioned because of transphobia" plays better with the community than "I detransitioned because I wasn't really trans," because it takes the blame off the individual and puts it on society. I wrote that society not accepting you magnifies any self-doubts, and that looking for simple answers for detransitioners is part of the problem.
In March 2023 I expressed a general irritation with proliferating identity labels, saying it was "just another term to try and make people feel special" and that people fighting so hard not to conform are just conforming in a different way. Around the same time I was reassuring others about coming out as detransitioned to friends and family — telling them that anyone who says "I told you so" is being insensitive and immature, that people who truly care will be supportive, and that friends and family will probably be relieved because transitioning brings lifelong difficulties. I noted that detransition is not easy and that real friends should support you "100%, no questions asked."
I have thought about how to write about these themes too. In April 2023 I suggested to a writer that they could draw on Brave New World or Animal Farm, or do a fantasy where magic that changes people always has a price — "you lose a little bit of yourself each time you change" — and people keep changing trying to find happiness but only find temporary happiness. I encouraged them to just publish under a pseudonym and not worry about backlash, even suggesting that controversy could attract the right readers.
In May 2023 I was baffled and angered on behalf of someone whose friends since 2016 were giving them a hard time about detransitioning, calling it "a crappy thing to do." In June 2023 I shared an anecdote about someone who let their cat decide their gender based on which pile of clothes the cat sat on, and I posted a summary of the Dartmouth scar experiment to make the point that people's perceptions of how others treat them can be entirely in their own minds — that participants who believed they had a scar that had actually been wiped off reported being stared at and treated rudely. I saw a parallel there to how people interpret others' reactions.
I have also been supportive of detransition advocacy. In June 2023 I told someone I was glad they were helping get the word out and suggested they seek an interview with Benjamin A Boyce on YouTube, who I called my favorite interviewer for detransitioned people.
In July 2023 I gave a fairly detailed take on why the demographics of transition have shifted. I said that in the past it was mostly men in their 30s transitioning — I cited a gender therapist who said that used to be 90% of their clients, and now 90% are teenage girls. I argued that teenage girls are more susceptible to things like eating disorders, so social contagion plays a huge role in the demographic change, and that body image is more of an issue for girls and women. I complained that people dismiss the term "social contagion" because it's a simple explanation anti-trans people can throw out, and said we'd all be better off if it wasn't a battle between pro- and anti-trans people and instead people objectively looked into the social reasons behind transition and detransition.
In July 2023 I also reassured a woman worried about not knowing how to do makeup, hair, or having many outfits — telling her not to be so hard on herself because these are not things every girl or woman automatically knows or had friends to teach them.
In August 2023 I had a moment of raw honesty, posting simply "I hate me as well." In the same month I responded at length to someone worried about having a child because of their voice — noting they seemed to have "a bit of a fixation on your voice" — and telling them children are non-judging and will grow up used to their voice. I advised accepting the things you cannot change rather than seeking other people's approval, and said the main thing that could affect a child is if you seem ashamed of your voice: "Them seeing you get upset is what would have a negative effect on them." I told them to teach their kid to shrug off bullying and to say "sometimes people make mistakes" if misgendered.
Overall I come across as someone who has detransitioned, is working on self-acceptance and on not caring about others' opinions, is critical of how transition is currently being pushed especially on teenage girls, and is engaged with the detransition community as a supporter and commenter, though I have not described my own medical details in these posts.