Toutes les histoires

Jamais transitionné — mais à regarder les autres le faire

Masculin · Désisté·e362
Ces histoires ont été résumées à l'aide de l'IA.

Sur Reddit, les gens partagent souvent leurs expériences à travers plusieurs commentaires ou publications. Pour rendre ces informations plus accessibles, detrans.ai rassemble toutes ces pièces dispersées en un résumé et une chronologie uniques et faciles à lire. Tous les prompts du système sont documentés sur la page des prompts.

Parfois, l'IA peut halluciner ou affirmer des choses qui ne sont pas vraies. Mais généralement, les histoires résumées sont des reflets précis des commentaires originaux des utilisateurs.

Résumé

Je suis un homme masculin aux cheveux longs qui n'a jamais transitionné mais commente activement dans cette communauté, très critique envers la transition et les hormones. Je compare regarder quelqu'un transitionner à regarder quelqu'un ruiner sa vie avec de la meth et je soutiens que l'identification trans est la seule maladie mentale que nous accommodons en modifiant la réalité. Je n'ai aucun antécédent personnel de transition médicale ; les faits personnels pertinents sont familiaux (un père dont les pieds ont rétréci avec la perte de poids due au diabète, une sœur avec trois enfants touchés par la meth) et une carrière impliquant de nombreuses vérifications d'antécédents. J'encourage aussi les autres posteurs ici et je crains que les nouvelles règles sur les discours haineux mettent le subreddit en danger. Je ne m'identifie ni comme détransitionné ni comme trans.

Histoire complète

I have never posted my own story here, but I have been reading and commenting in this community for a while, and what I write comes out of that. I am a masculine guy with long hair; I have said so directly when someone suggested hair mattered for how a person is read. I am six-something feet tall and wear between an 11 and a 13 shoe depending on the brand, which I brought up when people were arguing about whether hormones can shrink feet — my point was that shoe sizing is unreliable and that people attribute human error to impossible science. I have never taken hormones myself and I have never transitioned. What I do have is a strong, consistent set of views about what transition does to other people. I have written that I can't imagine any hormone makes your feet or hands shrink, and that the people claiming it are delusional. I've compared watching someone transition to watching someone destroy their life with meth, and I've said that watching someone get indoctrinated into mutilating their bodies is horrific. I've argued that trans-identification is the only mental illness where we try to alter reality to fit a person's worldview, comparing it unfavorably to how we treat someone who believes he is Jesus. I've said I've never met a trans person who didn't have massive peer pressure combined with depression, and I've suggested both being trans and other things are most likely the result of sustained trauma. I've been harsh about trans women who call themselves lesbians, calling them almost 100% sexual predators hiding in sheep's clothing. On hormones in livestock, I noted I see what two months of hormones do to slaughter cattle and can't imagine humans are much different, then corrected myself when told steers are infertile, and said I see long-lasting effects in animals that aren't alive more than two months and can't imagine how terrible people's lives will be afterwards. I have practical, career-side experience too: every job I've had has run a criminal background check, including for security clearances, and I've argued that failing to disclose former legal names on an application amounts to falsifying it. I have family context that shapes my views on drugs and harm: three out of four of my sister's kids were meth babies and now have behavioral problems, and my father went from a 15 wide to a 14 shoe after losing 50 lbs and getting his diabetes under control, which is my go-to example of fluid retention rather than bone change making feet look smaller. I do engage supportively with people here. I've asked someone what they think would make them happy, told them we all fuck up in life, told someone they don't have to apologize for telling their story and that self-acceptance is a big chunk of the journey, been glad when someone found happiness, reassured someone about their hairline, and asked what reasoning their therapist gave for transitioning. I've expressed concern that new 'hate speech' rules put the sub in jeopardy because anything that doesn't fit a certain narrative is flagged, and I've sympathized with how a stranger's kind words can validate a struggle. I've also made a political observation that leaning hard to the left has become a license to deflect any criticism as a Nazi comparison, like they've lived long enough to become the villains themselves. I don't describe myself as detransitioned or as having transitioned at all. I'm here as an outside observer with strong critical views on transition, some personal experience of background checks and family harm, and a habit of offering encouragement to people going through hard times.