Toutes les histoires

Sept ans en homme, puis une théorie féministe pour comprendre pourquoi

Féminin · Désisté·e231
Ces histoires ont été résumées à l'aide de l'IA.

Sur Reddit, les gens partagent souvent leurs expériences à travers plusieurs commentaires ou publications. Pour rendre ces informations plus accessibles, detrans.ai rassemble toutes ces pièces dispersées en un résumé et une chronologie uniques et faciles à lire. Tous les prompts du système sont documentés sur la page des prompts.

Parfois, l'IA peut halluciner ou affirmer des choses qui ne sont pas vraies. Mais généralement, les histoires résumées sont des reflets précis des commentaires originaux des utilisateurs.

Résumé

Je suis une femme détransitionnée, non conforme au genre, qui s'est identifiée comme homme trans pendant environ sept ans, poussée par la misogynie intériorisée, l'homophobie, le désir d'échapper à la sexualisation et des difficultés de santé mentale. Je m'identifie maintenant comme une femme féministe bisexuelle surtout attirée par les femmes, et j'ai développé une théorie critique en six catégories de l'identification trans. Je m'oppose aux procédures médicales irréversibles pour les mineurs et je soutiens que les communautés trans devraient mieux filtrer l'accès à cette condition, tout en soutenant des espaces de troisième genre pour les personnes non conformes au genre. Je n'ai pas décrit dans ces posts de chirurgies précises ni de durées d'hormones.

Histoire complète

I was born female, and I now describe myself as a gender-nonconforming woman who was formerly trans-identified. I came to identify as a trans "man" partly because I hated being pretty enough to be socially policed and preyed on by older men; I thought becoming a conventionally uglier "man" would fix that, so I became strongly butch, spoke in a deeper register, conformed to masculine gender roles, and only wore loose men's clothing for about seven years. I also struggled with hormone issues caused by poor eating habits and mental health problems, to the point where people mistook me for a trans woman, which only added pressure to want to be a trans "man." Looking back, I understand my own trans identification as coming from internally identifying as a man in order to escape the roles and expectations assigned to my gender, combined with internalized misogyny and internalized homophobia. As a teenager I was a "rage-addled, physically awkward, emotionally unstable, and insatiably horny (but also sexually repressed thanks to growing up as a Christian)" kid who was horribly jealous of my brothers and not making good choices for my health and future. I believed I could solve my emotional problems and what I then called my "sexual deviance" with testosterone. I also used to feel jealous of men because I thought being a man would be easier. Eventually I had to face the truth that I wasn't actually a man, and I was able to redefine myself as a gender-nonconforming woman. I now know it's better to embrace being a female with body hair (and find a partner who accepts that) or shave whenever I feel like looking more femme. I don't specify surgeries, hormone durations, or medical interventions in these posts, so I leave those details out. I am a feminist and bisexual, mostly attracted to women. I engage heavily with women-centered spaces like TwoXChromosomes, though I've been frustrated by what I see as male moderators and male voices being centered over women's, including trans women being allowed to be representative voices while being disrespectful and misogynistic toward cis women. I don't mind trans women having a voice in women's spaces if they respect women and simply have a different perspective. I have strong, critical views about transition, especially for young people. I've laid out a six-category theory of who identifies as trans: "true trans" people with diagnosed sexual dysphoria who make serious effort to live as the other sex; NB/genderfluid/queer/crossdressers who need third spaces; predatory/misogynistic/fetishistic "transfemmes"; internally misogynistic/fetishistic "transmascs"; masculine butch lesbians; and feminine gay men. I argue trans people need to better gatekeep their condition to prevent young people from getting confused and electing hormone/body-altering procedures they don't need, since adolescent brains are still developing and puberty is already uncomfortable. I believe the focus should be on mental health instead of irreversible procedures for minors. I also think making space for people who want to live differently from their gender role is practical in a world where casual sexism, homophobia, and bigotry are normal, which is why I support third-gender spaces. I feel pity for people I see as having insecure narcissistic traits but believe the detrans community's voices shouldn't be overridden by what I call a toxic ideology.