Toutes les histoires

Un clivage binaire intérieur — et avoir survécu à ce qui s'est approché

Masculin · Détransitionné·e53
Ces histoires ont été résumées à l'aide de l'IA.

Sur Reddit, les gens partagent souvent leurs expériences à travers plusieurs commentaires ou publications. Pour rendre ces informations plus accessibles, detrans.ai rassemble toutes ces pièces dispersées en un résumé et une chronologie uniques et faciles à lire. Tous les prompts du système sont documentés sur la page des prompts.

Parfois, l'IA peut halluciner ou affirmer des choses qui ne sont pas vraies. Mais généralement, les histoires résumées sont des reflets précis des commentaires originaux des utilisateurs.

Résumé

Je suis une femme détransitionnée qui a transitionné puis détransitionné, et je décris toute l'expérience comme m'ayant appris plus sur moi-même et le monde que n'importe quoi d'autre, tout en avertissant qu'elle ne devrait pas être vue comme un objectif. Je formule ma propre psychologie en termes de tension interne entre opposés binaires qui, je l'espère, mène vers l'intégration et l'individuation, et je soupçonne que l'autisme y a joué un rôle. Je suis critique à la fois des slogans trans et de l'auto-détestation d'inspiration TERF, qui politisent la question et nuisent aux détransitionneurs en quête de vrais conseils. Je fais référence à une période qui semblait assez dangereuse pour que je sois contente d'être « resté un peu en vie ». J'essaie de soutenir celles et ceux qui s'interrogent en mettant l'accent sur la découverte de soi plutôt que sur le fait de devenir une version idéalisée de soi-même.

Histoire complète

I was born male. I don't talk much about the specific timeline of my own transition and detransition, but I've described the whole experience of transitioning and detransitioning as having taught me more about myself and how the world works than anything else. I've said I'm glad I 'climbed that mountain' and remain 'somewhat alive,' which suggests the period was genuinely dangerous for me and that people around me at the time were not acting out of sincerity but out of fear and disgust. I also recall that when I detransitioned I met the same kind of naysayers I'd encountered when I transitioned. I think about the psychology behind these experiences a lot. I've described how in some people the female and male personae are extremely binary opposed, and that while that tension is painful, it can lead to a more reasonable solution, hopefully toward integration and individuation — noting that everyone has a conflicting personality or shadow side. I suspect this dynamic has more to do with autism than narcissistic personality disorder, though you can't exclude that possibility. I've also framed body alienation as a common way to describe suffering, not an ideology. I try to encourage others who are questioning. I've told people it's important to realize the 'win' in self-discovery, and that resolving an issue of the psyche isn't about becoming an ideal version of yourself but about placing the issue in a larger context you can find through self-discovery — that the questioning itself is the answer because it means you're growing. I'm critical of how the discourse around transition has become politicized. I've said that making this issue political — from pro-trans slogans to TERF-inspired self-hate — is rather recent and a disservice to detransitioners seeking genuine advice. I've also said that while transitioning and detransitioning taught me a lot, it should not be a goal, and there are other less harmful ways to deal with dissociating and identity feelings, though I'm unsure where we'd start preventing friends from making dangerous choices. I noted that the worst for me was people casually stating 'not dead yet,' and that this was before transition became politicized in US elections, Rowling, and Reddit. I've pushed back on posts I see as TERF or MAGA-adjacent, and on herd mentality, saying it takes a lot of mental energy to deal with dualities and the unpredictable way life is, and that it's easier to proclaim a fossilized view.