Toutes les histoires

Une voix uniquement détrans sur Reddit en 2022

Féminin · Détransitionné·e112
Ces histoires ont été résumées à l'aide de l'IA.

Sur Reddit, les gens partagent souvent leurs expériences à travers plusieurs commentaires ou publications. Pour rendre ces informations plus accessibles, detrans.ai rassemble toutes ces pièces dispersées en un résumé et une chronologie uniques et faciles à lire. Tous les prompts du système sont documentés sur la page des prompts.

Parfois, l'IA peut halluciner ou affirmer des choses qui ne sont pas vraies. Mais généralement, les histoires résumées sont des reflets précis des commentaires originaux des utilisateurs.

Résumé

Je suis une femme détransitionnée qui était active dans les communautés Reddit détrans en 2022, même si je n'ai jamais décrit dans ce matériel ma propre chronologie de transition, mes démarches médicales ou mes raisons de détransitionner. J'ai défendu avec férocité les espaces réservés aux détrans contre les personnes retransitionnées et les posteurs trans, soutenant que les personnes retransitionnées appartiennent à la communauté trans plutôt qu'à la communauté détrans. Dans les débats, j'ai pris une position biologique essentialiste ferme sur le sexe, insistant sur une terminologie claire et m'identifiant ouvertement comme détransitionnée. Je n'ai décrit dans ces commentaires aucun problème de santé mentale, aucun détail de regret ni aucune idée suicidaire.

Histoire complète

I was born female, and I detransitioned at some point before mid-2022, when I was active in detrans communities on Reddit. My own transition timeline — when I first felt dysphoria, when I came out, whether I took hormones or had any surgeries — is not something I described in the material I have here, so I can't fill those in. What I can speak to is how I think and argue now as a detransitioned person. In July 2022 I was discussing community dynamics in a detrans forum, noting that one particular commenter always opened discussions the same way, and reassuring another user that they spoke clearly enough that at least two people in the thread understood them. I saw that commenter's tactic as an attempt to make people feel gullible and uninformed when they weren't. In early August 2022 I weighed in on how the subreddit should be moderated. I argued that the space was valuable precisely because it hosted real, uncensored detrans experiences, unlike a related subreddit I felt was "flooded by trans propaganda." I opposed giving a flair to retransitioned people, reasoning that "retrans people are ACTUAL trans, who got past detransition mentally and physically" and therefore didn't belong on a detrans sub; I thought a "questioning own gender transition" flair was sufficient. I was skeptical that engaging in good faith with hostile outsiders would be reciprocated, saying they would "see this gesture as weakness and would bite your hand." Later in August 2022 I got into a heated exchange with a trans woman about biology, sex, and language. I insisted on terms like "biological women," "trans women," "crossdresser," and "drag queen," and argued that a trans woman is not a woman in the biological sense, saying "Science does ;)" when challenged. I accused my interlocutor of misogyny and of lacking basic education, and I made strong claims about chromosomes, estrogen, and reproductive capacity — including that a trans woman "will never be a good mother" in a biological sense, though I conceded she could be a good mother figure. I framed my position as common, mainstream, and outside the Anglosphere, and pointed to a growing right-wing movement in the US that I believed would "put an end to this nonsense in a decade." I explicitly identified myself to my opponent as a detransitioned person: "You are talking to one right now." I also directed them to another detrans subreddit. Despite the hostility, I softened at the end, telling her she would be a good mother figure and that her children could call her mother. Overall, I come across as combative and confident in my biological essentialist view of sex, protective of detrans spaces, and willing to identify openly as detransitioned when arguing.