Toutes les histoires

Deux décennies de thérapie, puis des soins du trauma qu’elle pouvait se payer

Masculin · Détransitionné·e898
Ces histoires ont été résumées à l'aide de l'IA.

Sur Reddit, les gens partagent souvent leurs expériences à travers plusieurs commentaires ou publications. Pour rendre ces informations plus accessibles, detrans.ai rassemble toutes ces pièces dispersées en un résumé et une chronologie uniques et faciles à lire. Tous les prompts du système sont documentés sur la page des prompts.

Parfois, l'IA peut halluciner ou affirmer des choses qui ne sont pas vraies. Mais généralement, les histoires résumées sont des reflets précis des commentaires originaux des utilisateurs.

Résumé

Je suis une personne détransitionnée qui a lutté contre des idées suicidaires dès l’âge de 12 ans et a passé deux décennies dans des thérapies inefficaces avant de trouver enfin une aide axée sur le trauma que je pouvais me permettre. J’ai des opinions critiques sur les soins d’affirmation de genre pour les enfants, en citant le rapport Cass et le recul de l’affirmation en Europe, tout en insistant sur le fait que je ne blâme pas les personnes trans individuellement. Je compare la réaction de la communauté trans à mon départ à celle que j’avais reçue en quittant la religion à l’adolescence. Je rejette l’idée que les détransitionné·es « se sont fait ça à eux-mêmes », en soutenant qu’on nous a induits en erreur par de fausses promesses. Je garde mes propres opinions politiques (décrites par d’autres comme antiféministes, proches des MRA) et je ne crois pas que les détransitionné·es doivent partager une seule idéologie.

Histoire complète

I've been active in this community for a while now, and I want to lay out where I've come from and what I think, because my views don't always fit the mold people expect of detransitioners. I struggled with mental illness from before I was a teenager — I was dealing with suicidal ideation at the age of 12. Over the next 20 years I went through what I call "The Therapy Windmill," trying countless different therapists who all helped me almost none at all. I came to believe talk therapy is largely useless because trauma happens at a much deeper level and is stored in the body or a subconscious part of the brain; you can talk for years and never reach it. It wasn't until I was able to build a decent career and pay for whatever therapist I wanted, regardless of insurance, that I finally started finding therapists who were actually helping me. I found them by Googling trauma therapists in my area, going through a Psychology Today directory, calling anyone whose description spoke to me, and then grilling them on phone consultations about why their methodology would be different from all the others. I think so many of us, especially from abusive childhoods and toxic family messages, get beaten down until we give up on ourselves — you have to get angry enough to be confrontational and fight for what you need. I also left religion as a teenager, and I remember receiving a very similar response from hardcore Christians then to what I get now from parts of the trans community: the only way they could cope with someone who had truly, truly believed and worshipped wholeheartedly leaving was to deny that I had ever really believed at all. Seeing that same pattern repeated as an adult with the trans community has been almost amusing to me — it's literally no different. On transition itself, I'm not blaming individual trans people for their mistakes or regrets. What I blame is an ideology driven by emotion, panic, greed, profit, and social contagion that coerces people, including young children, into believing all of their psychological suffering can be solved by changing genders. I think it takes the most vulnerable population — young children with serious psychological health issues, often stemming from childhood abuse and trauma, with undiagnosed co-morbidities — and tells them trans will save them. I follow the NHS documents and the British Cass Review closely, and I believe the science shows most children experiencing gender incongruence will grow out of it by adolescence. I also believe affirmation, especially puberty blockers, is not a neutral act — it pushes a child toward transition, whereas without affirmation the vast majority would have resolved their dysphoria by adulthood. I've watched Swedish investigative documentaries on the effects of puberty blockers being hidden from the public and saved detransition testimonies from Florida school board videos to my hard drive in case they get taken down. I think puberty is a scary time for everyone, but part of the process is the body adjusting so that by the end of puberty mind and body are in harmony again; blocking puberty deprives a person of letting their body solve its own dysphoria. I'm also frustrated that the affirmation model began in America and spread to Europe, but Europe has since largely rejected it in favor of "watchful waiting," and I think North America has defined transphobia as anything that isn't complete affirmation, which I consider insane. I've been challenged on my presence here because of my politics — someone called me a "weirdo, anti-feminist, men's rights activist" — and I responded that I didn't realize you had to be of a particular political persuasion to be detrans, and that given the groupthink and purity tests that cause people to make regrettable decisions, I take the frustration as a compliment. I've also said I'm sympathetic to second-wave feminism's work breaking down harmful gender stereotypes, and I think we've regressed in the past decade to a biologically essentialist definition of gender identity. I have a girlfriend and she'd tell you I'm a gentle person; I've never said women deserve to be treated badly in my 10 years on Reddit. What really gets me is when people say we "did this to ourselves." You're damn right we made the decision to transition — because of all the lies, false promises, and disinformation we were given. We were told transitioning would save our lives, and then when it made everything worse, suddenly it's our fault. I'm glad detransition voices are being elevated more and more.