Toutes les histoires

Sept mois d’œstrogènes à 15 ans, et la croissance mammaire est restée

Masculin · Détransitionné·e339
Ces histoires ont été résumées à l'aide de l'IA.

Sur Reddit, les gens partagent souvent leurs expériences à travers plusieurs commentaires ou publications. Pour rendre ces informations plus accessibles, detrans.ai rassemble toutes ces pièces dispersées en un résumé et une chronologie uniques et faciles à lire. Tous les prompts du système sont documentés sur la page des prompts.

Parfois, l'IA peut halluciner ou affirmer des choses qui ne sont pas vraies. Mais généralement, les histoires résumées sont des reflets précis des commentaires originaux des utilisateurs.

Résumé

Je suis un homme détransitionné qui s’est identifié comme trans pendant environ trois ans et a pris des œstrogènes (Estrogel) plus du finastéride pendant environ sept mois, de novembre 2019 à fin juin 2020, avant d’arrêter à 17 ans. Je n’ai jamais fait de transition sociale et n’étais ouvert qu’auprès de ma famille et de mes amis proches. La croissance mammaire persistante et une silhouette plus féminine m’ont causé une vraie détresse après l’arrêt, et j’ai brièvement envisagé la chirurgie. Mon regret était intense au début mais s’est nettement amélioré — en 2021, je disais être bien plus heureux, plus à l’aise dans ma peau, et avoir fait la paix avec l’expérience. Je me pense maintenant simplement comme un homme, je me suis largement désengagé des communautés trans en ligne, et je suis critique à la fois des espaces trans qui rejettent la détransition et de la facilité avec laquelle les bloqueurs de puberté et le THS précoce sont suggérés.

Histoire complète

I was born male and, at 17, I described myself as a "17 yo MtFtM detransitioner" — someone who had identified under a trans label for about three years before stopping. My questioning started the way I think a lot of people's does: with Reddit posts and memes. From there it snowballed — I kept talking with a therapist I was already seeing for unrelated things, got on the UK GIDS (Gender Identity Development Service) waitlist, came out to close family members, and got deeply involved in online Discord communities. I frequented all the trans meme subs and even submitted some of my own posts. I absorbed the lines about starting HRT early and internalised the idea that being cis was bad. Looking back I'm genuinely unsure whether what I felt was real gender dysphoria, ordinary teenage pubertal insecurity, or whether I was clinging to an identity to cope with anxiety and depressive symptoms. In November 2019 I began Estrogen (Estrogel pump gel) plus Finasteride, and at first I thought it was the best thing I could do. About three months later, around February 2020, self-doubt crept in and I quit HRT cold turkey for about a week before going back on it in a panic. I think about that period a lot now, and what would have happened if I had stayed off. Importantly, apart from my closest family and friends I was never out to anyone — I never shared a preferred name or pronouns. "For all intents and purposes I was a guy on Estrogen." During the 2020 lockdown I had more time for introspection and realised I was becoming more unhappy with myself and my body on HRT, and that it wasn't solving my body-image issues. I also realised I had no active desire to transition socially. In late June 2020 I quit HRT for good, having been on it just over seven months. I noted I got lucky using Finasteride rather than a "real" testosterone blocker, and that my testosterone levels stayed high throughout. It was hard not to feel stupid. I acknowledged I was still a minor but that I had made the decision to start HRT and needed to own it, while also wishing someone had stepped in and told me to rethink it or helped me accept a male existence. I felt a mixture of regret, anger and sadness, and said I'd "fucked up my body a fair bit." I also criticised the trans communities I'd been in for total disregard for detransition — people suggesting it's fine for some to suffer if it makes HRT more accessible, and shifting blame onto young kids who fell into the trap, like me. About six weeks after stopping (August 2020), I wrote about the lingering physical effects. The two causing me the most distress were breast growth and body shape/fat distribution. Fat distribution had changed slightly but my body shape remained significantly more "feminine" than before. I'd experienced some shrinkage in my chest but it was still noticeable shirtless or in clothes, and it made me dysphoric. I'd been wearing hoodies and jackets to mask it, which was getting harder in summer weather and as life outside lockdown resumed. I said I'd wait a few more months to see if my chest returned to a more male appearance, and that I had even considered surgery, though I doubted there was enough tissue to make it possible. I hadn't spoken to anyone in real life about it and was nervous about seeing friends again. I also mentioned I'm naturally skinny/underweight, so losing weight wasn't really an option. By early 2021 I'd disengaged from the LGBT spaces I'd been in and unfollowed people across apps. I wrote about hostility toward detransitioners from multiple directions: a "rational trans"/transmed space that policed detrans language and claimed we could never have experienced dysphoria (I pushed back — surely discomfort with HRT or surgery *is* dysphoria), people welcoming homophobes who said detrans people "can all rot in hell," Twitter accounts saying 100 detrans people suffering is worth one trans person's benefit, and trans-critical spaces calling detrans people, especially detrans women (whom I noted I am not), mutilated. I said I don't make being detrans part of my identity — that Reddit account was basically the only public place I'd expressed it. In April 2021, a year after my last HRT prescription, I reflected on how disconnected I felt from that version of myself. I remembered the anxiety about filling the prescription during lockdown, the week-long pause in HRT around that time, and the doubt that kept growing after I resumed. I wrote: "April 2020 me is a totally foreign me. I don't recognise him at all." I wondered why I didn't see the red flags and why I waited four months after I clearly should have stopped. But I also said I didn't feel as angry or resentful as before. In the nine months since stopping I'd become more comfortable in my own skin, made more friends, picked up new hobbies, and disconnected from toxic spaces. I'd made peace with my transition to an extent, knowing I'd have wondered "what if?" otherwise. I said I don't think about my gender identity much at all any more — "I realised I never really 'felt' like anything — that I was just a man." The hard part was disengaging from the trans spaces and the people who'd had a harmful influence; I'd been "terminally online," investing my time and identity in trans communities on Reddit, Twitter and especially Discord. I wished I could pull April 2020 me out of that pit and tell him it wasn't wrong for him to be wrong about this. In January 2022 I reflected on how I'd stopped pursuing things I loved as a kid once I fell into the "gender-obsession rabbit hole," and on how hyper-affirmative online spaces push people to construct an identity so far from their real self that returning to the offline self becomes painful, driving them deeper online. I said I felt like I was putting on an act both online and offline, and that since detransitioning I've massively decreased my participation on Discord and Reddit. In another comment I expressed concern about puberty blockers being suggested so much, questioning whether long-term use would be detrimental to health. I never socially transitioned, never used a new name or pronouns publicly, and never had surgery. My regret centres on the time lost to trans questioning, the physical changes from seven months of estrogen (chest tissue and body shape), and the fact that I let so much of my life get engulfed in trans drama. That regret was intense at first — "hard not to feel stupid" — but it has clearly softened over time: by April 2021 I said I was much happier, had made peace with it, and no longer felt angry or resentful. I have not described any suicidal ideation or self-harm.