Ces histoires ont été résumées à l'aide de l'IA.
Sur Reddit, les gens partagent souvent leurs expériences à travers plusieurs commentaires ou publications. Pour rendre ces informations plus accessibles, detrans.ai rassemble toutes ces pièces dispersées en un résumé et une chronologie uniques et faciles à lire. Tous les prompts du système sont documentés sur la page des prompts.
Parfois, l'IA peut halluciner ou affirmer des choses qui ne sont pas vraies. Mais généralement, les histoires résumées sont des reflets précis des commentaires originaux des utilisateurs.
Résumé
Je suis une femme détransitionnée qui a adopté une identité trans puis pris de la testostérone, en ne développant de la dysphorie qu'après avoir adopté l'identité, et j'ai détransitionné au milieu de la vingtaine. Le principal changement irréversible que je regrette est ma voix — j'atteignais les notes sifflées d'Ariana Grande et je ne peux plus chanter. J'avais des idées suicidaires à l'époque où j'ai adopté l'identité trans, pour des raisons qui n'avaient selon moi rien à voir avec le genre, et ma santé mentale s'est nettement améliorée après la suppression des réseaux sociaux. Je suis critique de la façon dont la transition est poussée vers les jeunes et des espaces en ligne qui m'ont selon moi manipulée, tout en croyant que certaines personnes sont véritablement trans. Je me décris actuellement comme « juste moi » et un « garçon manqué en ce moment », et je crois que j'aime les mecs maintenant.
Histoire complète
I was born female. I don't have a clear memory of childhood gender dysphoria, but I do remember my childhood as being unusual — at 13 I was on Tumblr talking a 25-year-old out of suicide, and at 17 I was writing fanfiction for people ten years my senior while having never held anyone's hand. I've said that my childhood experience was really similar to someone else's story and that I've often wondered if I'd been born in the current era whether I would have transitioned.
I came to gender questions through feminism first, though I describe it as the 'corporate leftist flavor ala BuzzFeed.' I ended up taking on a trans identity — I've said I never really 'pretended to be trans' so much as people kept telling me I was, even though I knew in my heart I was doing it because I wanted to, not because I should or had to for some reason like suicide. At the time I was suicidal, but for different reasons. Strikingly, I've said I developed dysphoria after taking on the identity, not before. I also said men had nothing to do with how I viewed myself as a woman.
I transitioned onto testosterone. I've said 'T for some reason made me bi' — everyone just seemed to be everywhere and beautiful. I detransitioned in my mid-20s. I don't use a label anymore and don't care much for pronouns. Since detransitioning I've said I think I like guys.
The most concrete irreversible change I've dealt with is my voice. I used to be able to hit Ariana Grande's whistle notes and singing was one of my favorite hobbies; now I say I 'just sound like a frog' and I can't sing anymore. I've described that loss as deeply sad because the voice is 'literally and metaphorically one of the most powerful things about you.' I've also expressed fear that guys won't like me, and pushed back on the 'you don't need male validation' line by saying the need for human connection is very real and natural — what if a partner likes singing and I can't join him.
I've reflected on the harm of the online spaces I came through, saying 'I can't even begin to explain the hell I probably put my parents through.' I believe many of us fell into it 'from online grooming gangs to begin with,' and I recommend keeping recovery offline. I've also described the process of changing identity after a breakup as being like when girls dye their hair a different color, and told someone processing the loss of a trans identity to grieve it with friends, family, or a support group.
On causes, I've argued that the internet made us dissociated from our bodies — the idea that 'these meat suits oppress us' and that we're placed on a hierarchy of privilege/oppression based on immutable characteristics. I've criticized the logic that 'if you do this, you are trans but don't know it yet' as being just as toxic as the toxic-masculinity version people reject. I've also been skeptical of fetish/AGP framings in some contexts, saying of one person that it seemed like an idealized version of what being female is rather than a fetish, and in another case saying something didn't sound like AGP but like addiction as a trauma response and heavy depression, recommending a dopamine detox and trauma therapy for PTSD.
On detransition generally, I've argued against truscum/transmed gatekeeping on the grounds that it's near impossible to tell who transition will benefit in the end. I've been critical of drag performances for children and of children being taught that gender is a spectrum and that children can be born in the wrong bodies. I've also said I think detransitioners will be lumped in with LGBT+ 'as if this was all just part of the gender journey.'
On sexuality and coming out, I've said I always thought it was weird to flaunt my sexuality — that should be between me and one other person — while understanding why mass coming-out mattered during the Obama-era marriage equality fight. Regardless of preference, I only need one person. I've also said the most supportive and caring people in my life have ended up being 'cishet,' which I didn't see coming.
Mental health-wise, I was suicidal at the time I took on a trans identity, for reasons I say were different from gender. I've credited deleting Twitch in 2023 and Instagram in 2022 with my mental health skyrocketing, and I recommend actively eliminating triggers and note studies since 2015 on social media and mental health. I've talked about body image too — looking back at pictures of myself at 16 and not being able to fathom how I thought such a cute kid was ever ugly.
On relationships and family, I've given advice to a parent of a detransitioning son, suggesting they look back to things he liked in childhood — piano lessons, rock climbing, pottery, volunteering at a shelter or religious organization — something that allows mastery and takes the mind off identity, and I recommended the podcast 'Gender: A Wider Lens.' I've said I have a partner who understands. I've also commented that in my opinion people in their 20s and 30s have a much easier time detransitioning than those 40+, while stressing I'm not an expert.
Current status: I'm a detransitioned woman. I describe myself as 'just me' and 'tomboy at the moment.' I don't hold a strong political identity — I've said I don't even know what 'conservative' means anymore because anything not the status quo gets called a dog whistle; I am just me. I'm generally supportive of other detransitioners and critical of how transition is pushed, particularly toward young people, while still believing some people are genuinely trans.