Toutes les histoires

Puberté à 11 ans, identité trans à 27 ans, et elle n'a choisi ni l'une ni l'autre

Féminin · Désisté·e624
Ces histoires ont été résumées à l'aide de l'IA.

Sur Reddit, les gens partagent souvent leurs expériences à travers plusieurs commentaires ou publications. Pour rendre ces informations plus accessibles, detrans.ai rassemble toutes ces pièces dispersées en un résumé et une chronologie uniques et faciles à lire. Tous les prompts du système sont documentés sur la page des prompts.

Parfois, l'IA peut halluciner ou affirmer des choses qui ne sont pas vraies. Mais généralement, les histoires résumées sont des reflets précis des commentaires originaux des utilisateurs.

Résumé

Je suis une femme qui a désisté et détransitionné : une lesbienne dysphorique non conforme au genre qui n'a jamais fait de transition médicale. Je suis née femme, j'ai eu une puberté précoce à 11 ans avec une grave dysphorie corporelle, et à 27 ans j'ai découvert l'identité transgenre, mais après des années de doute j'ai choisi de ne pas faire la transition, reconnaissant que ma détresse était enracinée dans l'homophobie et la misogynie intériorisées d'une éducation conservatrice et homophobe. J'éprouve encore une dysphorie résiduelle du haut et un malaise face à mes courbes, mais elle s'est en grande partie estompée avec l'âge, l'acceptation de soi, l'exercice et le fait de rester engagée dans la vie en dehors de mon corps. Je m'identifie maintenant comme une femme lesbienne, je suis critique de la transition médicale et de ce que je vois comme une contagion sociale chez les jeunes femmes, et je plaide activement pour la prudence, la thérapie et l'acceptation de soi radicale dans les communautés de détrans et de questionnement. Je n'ai connu ni idées suicidaires ni automutilation depuis ma désistance.

Histoire complète

I was born female and grew up in a small place outside the English-speaking West, in a conservative, homophobic society where I was expected to do what women 'are supposed to do' — be pretty, get a husband, have kids. I got my first bra and period at 11 and hit puberty very early, which I dreaded; I had severe body dysphoria for years, but trans was not a thing back then, so I had no framework for what I was feeling. Alongside that, I struggled with my identity because being a lesbian — therefore a woman — felt dirty, 'literally the worst.' My logic was that if I liked girls (which I really did), then I must be a boy. Years later I understood the level of internalised misogyny and homophobia I had built up from my education and societal environment. I later described this as 'internalised homophobia or should i say self-conversion therapy to erase homosexuality.' At 27 I discovered transgender identity and thought that was me. I describe that period as the worst time in my life, questioning my whole reality for something unachievable: being a man. I did a lot of work on myself and am happy to have desisted rather than transitioned. I explicitly note that I discovered trans later in life and thank god for that, otherwise I'm sure I'd already have done irreversible changes to my body. I never underwent any medical procedures — no hormones, no surgeries — and I have never altered my body. I made the decision not to transition. I still don't feel like a woman in a straightforward way and there are several male things I strongly identify with, but I really don't want to be a man either because I really don't like them (as a whole, though I have longed to have a man's body for a long time) and I know I will never get there. I describe myself as being 'somewhere in the middle' and say that's just as valid as the binary system. I still refuse to identify as non-binary because my body doesn't lie, and I'm still not simply a lesbian in my own mind — 'still a bit in denial I guess' — but it works for me. I am little by little making peace with my nature and learning to empower myself as a LESBIAN WOMAN. I now describe myself as a desister, a desisted female, a dysphoric woman and a dysphoric lesbian, and I say being dysphoric goes hand in hand with being gender non conforming for me, though they are not synonyms. I reject the descriptor 'cis' as absurd. I still have top dysphoria sometimes and am not fond of my curves, though they're not huge. I exercise to make peace with my body. I say dysphoria has close to disappeared for me although it does come back on bad days — it's a very mental thing and I found that aging up also helped. I've learnt to realise there's nothing wrong with my body, particularly my breasts, and that it's actually, objectively, beautiful, even though I'm far from feminine and still don't love my body. I'm really androgynous now and I love it, and I get gendered either way, which lets me express myself freely without being boxed into a man/woman binary. I've taken up piano in my 30s and found that getting busy, being entertained, spending time with friends, and looking outward instead of focusing on my body and its 'imperfections' helps a lot. My partner is a woman. To society we look like a lesbian couple, and I used to struggle with that word a lot, but my partner knows exactly what I am and we are lucky to have each other in a happy, healthy relationship. She probably likes my body more than I do. I take the view that there are many people who will love you however you end up being. In terms of what I now think about transition for others: I am not against trans people, but I find the trend is getting huge and it's fucking scary, especially among teenage girls. I believe there's an element of social contagion, pointing to studies showing this phenomenon happens more among women and comparing it to the rise of anorexia in the late nineties, and I've referenced studies on hysterical contagion and conversion disorder. I argue that transgender identity is deeply rooted in sexist and sexual stereotypes, that 85% of the time it reinforces binarism, and that it entails a life of medication and collateral physical and mental problems. I hold a gender-critical/biological view that sex can't be changed — being male or female is a physical reality, not a feeling or an aesthetic — while also saying trans people exist and some need to live that way and are happier after transitioning, and that I do support trans rights. I think gender dysphoria is a real mental issue that should be addressed with therapy rather than drugs and surgeries, and I question the logic of changing the body to fix the mind. I'm critical of HRT/SRS on the grounds that they might alleviate one issue but give you a bunch of new ones plus long-lasting dependence on treatment, and I've referenced the medical and pharma lobby. I've argued that there is a physical point of no (full) return in detransition — not necessarily genital changes but the inability to naturally produce sex hormones — after which detransition becomes retransition or a constant state of transition. I've also argued that 'inside is what really matters' is a distorted take, since most of people's lives have more to do with our outside, our body, and how we exist in the world. I've been active in detrans/desister communities since at least 2019, offering support and advice. I work as a data insight analyst and offered my skills to help with research on detransitioners and their stories and motivations. I regularly advise younger people questioning their gender to give themselves time, hold off on any medical changes, find a good therapist to deal with past and current issues, step back from the internet, focus on real life, studies, offline hobbies, friends and relationships, and go out into nature. I've told people not to do anything irreversible if they have any minimal amount of doubt, to cancel surgeries, and that they cannot go ahead with an irreversible, life-changing surgery without being 100% positive. I've advised against spending money on fraudulent products and instead to eat healthy, sleep well and keep active. I've also been critical of what I see as over-sexualisation and denial of womanhood among women in detrans communities. My core message to others is 'radical self-acceptance' and that the best cure for dysphoria is time and self-acceptance.