Toutes les histoires

Brièvement trans à la puberté, puis non binaire pendant tout le lycée

Masculin · Désisté·ePremière dysphorie 12 → Désistance 19361
Ces histoires ont été résumées à l'aide de l'IA.

Sur Reddit, les gens partagent souvent leurs expériences à travers plusieurs commentaires ou publications. Pour rendre ces informations plus accessibles, detrans.ai rassemble toutes ces pièces dispersées en un résumé et une chronologie uniques et faciles à lire. Tous les prompts du système sont documentés sur la page des prompts.

Parfois, l'IA peut halluciner ou affirmer des choses qui ne sont pas vraies. Mais généralement, les histoires résumées sont des reflets précis des commentaires originaux des utilisateurs.

Résumé

Je suis un homme en désistance qui s'est identifié mtf brièvement au début de la puberté, puis comme non binaire pendant tout le lycée avant de désister après le lycée. Je m'identifie maintenant comme un homme gay féminin qui s'efforce de s'accepter en tant qu'homme, même si je ressens ce que je décris comme une dysphorie liée au TOC — peurs en boucle de vieillir en tant qu'homme et envies de transitionner que je ne veux pas vraiment. Les ISRS m'aident à fonctionner en réduisant la place que cela prend dans mes pensées, et j'évite la thérapie par peur d'être poussé de manière affirmative vers une identité trans. Je n'ai jamais pris d'hormones ni subi de chirurgie, et je suis devenu une voix active dans les espaces de détrans, discutant des typologies AGP/HSTS et défendant le droit des hommes féminins non conformes au genre d'exister sans avoir à s'identifier comme trans. Ma détresse est continue mais gérable, et je me concentre sur le fait d'apprendre à être bien en tant qu'homme.

Histoire complète

I was born male and first started feeling gender dysphoria when puberty began. For a while I thought I was mtf. In high school I discovered non-binary and identified as non-binary for pretty much all of high school, because I realized I didn't want to be a girl, just not to be a guy. After high school I started learning about detransitioners and related to a lot of them, especially gay male detransitioners, so I stopped identifying as non-binary and began watching a lot of 'terfy' content. I now describe myself as a feminine desisted man, and a big part of my current process has been learning to be okay with being a feminine gay man. I have thought a lot about where my gender dysphoria comes from. I used to literally believe that trans women were actual women trapped inside a male body (and vice versa), and I don't think I was the only one who believed sayings like 'being born in the wrong body.' I now see that as a spiritual or religious way of viewing things — the idea that we are not our physical bodies, or that there is a part of ourselves separate from our physical bodies. Even though I am non-religious, I used to think this through a more scientific lens, believing there was something inside the brains of trans people that made them similar to their desired gender. Now I know there is no real evidence for that, and I think the idea that there is some inner self, soul, or mind that is exactly the same as the opposite gender has the same level of validity as any other religion. It's fine if people believe that, but passing it off as the truth is questionable to me. I've also described this elsewhere: 'It feels almost spiritual as if there was a part of ourselves separate from our bodies and that part (gender identity) was placed incorrectly into our bodies. Obviously none of this has any scientific validity and is just used to express a feeling but the fact that people believe this to be true is kinda sad.' I have thought a lot about why gender non-conforming men like me end up identifying as trans. As a feminine desisted man, the idea I had of a feminine gender non-conforming man was someone who wears makeup or paints his nails but has short hair or a beard and still 'presents as a man.' I wish there were more men who looked even more gender non-conforming or androgynous — the best example I can think of is someone like John Maclean — who 'presents female' but still identifies as a man and uses he/him pronouns without having to identify as non-binary or 'transfem.' It seems that any male who reaches a certain point of gender non-conformity or femininity (long hair, women's clothing) stops identifying as a man. That made me, as a feminine man who wanted to present more femininely than most gnc men, think I must not be just a gnc man but non-binary, trans femme, or a trans woman. I think non-binary actually pushes gender stereotypes even more and prevents people who want to present as the opposite gender but not fully transition from just being a gnc man or woman. I've noted that I've seen a lot of Asian examples of the type of guys I'm talking about, guessing it's because they don't have the whole queer non-binary culture over there. I have engaged with the autogynephilia/AGP typology literature. In a conversation with a parent worried about their son, I explained that research shows two main types of mtf transsexualism: homosexual transsexual (HSTS) and autogynephilic (AGP), where HSTS show signs of femininity much earlier in life, like childhood, while AGPs usually don't, and even later their femininity does not come naturally and is usually imitated. I suggested asking the son about his sexuality — if he says he's bisexual or a 'trans lesbian' I would probably assume AGP — while warning that trans people are usually very insulted when told their gender identity stems from a fetish. I also pointed them to Ray Blanchard's work, since he came up with the typologies. In another conversation I suggested that the prevalence of 'gay trans men' is 'sort of the female version of autogynophilia,' which I think is called autoandrophilia, though I've also heard it called autohomoeroticism. My dysphoria has been a major ongoing struggle. As of mid-2024, when I was 20, my dysphoria was worse than ever, even though I had desisted. I don't think it's real dysphoria — I described it as more of an OCD thing: because I'm still uncomfortable being a man and the idea of growing older as a man is terrifying, my mind swings to the complete opposite, thinking I want to become a woman. The worst part is envisioning myself getting older, which triggers the thought 'wait, I actually should transition now before it's too late, if I let myself get older I will never be able to.' It loops endlessly because of OCD and I don't know how to cope; I've been really close to just giving in despite not actually wanting to be a woman. Typing it out helps, but I've been afraid to go to therapy for fear of them being affirming and saying 'no, you're actually a woman or non-binary' — I just want to learn to be okay with the fact that I'm a man without trying to be something else. I've also related to another person's description of being so dysphoric you don't understand why men are seen as attractive, and I've acknowledged that we both tried to escape our maleness, so of course we aren't going to be completely comfortable in it 100% — that takes time, even years. I also have times where I fear growing older as a man and times where I still want to transition. I've tried to reframe things: I told someone they don't have to meet either male or female standards of beauty, that they can present femininely without taking hormones or identifying as trans and just be a feminine man, and that there's beauty in that. I've encouraged others by saying 'You don't have to cut your hair or change anything to be more of a man. We need more males like you to show the range of men there are.' On treatment, I've found that SSRIs helped me not think about the dysphoria as much — it's still there, but I can now function. I have offered support to other male detrans/desisters, noting there aren't that many of us. I've also engaged with detrans community symbolism, commenting that 'lizard' (regeneration) has become a symbol for the entire detrans community, surgeries or not, and anyone can use it. I live in the U.S. I've commented critically on what I see as a persecution complex among some groups, comparing it to 'Christians thinking they are somehow being persecuted and will be thrown in jail for being Christian.' I don't describe any medical transition — no hormones or surgeries are mentioned in my posts. My transition was social/identity-based: identifying as mtf briefly, then non-binary through high school, then desisting. My current identity is a desisted, feminine gay man who is male, dealing with residual OCD-driven dysphoria about aging as a man but working toward accepting myself as a man.